First: Your poll sucks, only hype sasuke options? come on!
Second, Itachi is prodigy reasons:
- At age 12, already leader of Anbu
He became Anbu leader at 13 dude, get facts straight.
- At age 12, or before, MS, without help of anyone (not a brother implanting eye powers on him).
Itachi awakened MS at 13 after Shisui "killed" himself, while Sasuke could have awakened it at 12 or at the same age as Itachi at the very least if Naruto killed himself, or he if he killed Naruto at the Valley of the End. What Itachi gave to Sasuke was a temporary amaterasu, nothing more
- He couldn't get the EMS you say? What about after killing everyone in Uchiha clan... he did it too with sasuke and just take his eyes? No, he wanted to keep sasuke alive, thats the reason itachi didnt have EMS
Maybe, I agree with you here.
Sasuke, at the age of 12 was still with Naruto and Sakura after just passing the chuning exams. So Itachi genius, sasuke... let's say "half-genius".