Sasuke deserves his revenge (agree or disagree?)

[minatoisagod]

well just those other elders and tobi left and he's good

 

[MidKnight]

The uchiha were planning to rebel because they were accused for what one uchiha did without any type of evidence what so ever, So they were isolated and spied on so they took notice. Look at it from the uchiha point of view if all of a sudden these guys just started acting all funny gather you and branch of family in one location n started spying on you what would you think??? Personally i think they were trying to kill me. :shrug: just saying


Well i don't think sasuke should go after the whole village to be honest but regardless they'll be coming after him anyway so why not slaughter there ass and for danzo to have itachi kill and 8 yr old for shame U_U. If he does goes after the elders you really think the solider of konoha is going to sit and watching even after knowing the truth??? How would you be able to wake up and look your self in the mirror knowing that you let the person go scott free killing your family even itachi felt like Sasuke had to kill him for that.

Its funny how no one has mentioned this yet.

 

[LBeezy]

Sasuke deserves death.

Revenge is never justifiable. Sasuke chose to wollow in his anger, rage, and hatred. Naruto's countless efforts to catch up to Sasuke because he admired Sasuke, thought of him as a brother. Sasuke always had people open to him even if they were fans, as time progressed, Sakura was there trying to understand as well as Naruto and kakashi but he chose to shun them all away. He chose to fall into this path.

Also how can it be said that Naruto's pain of loosing Jiraiya is less then Sasuke's loosing a clan? He looses his clan, that's clan pride, pride itself is a sin, yet Naruto had somebody he cared about, a father (grandfather figure) somebody who raised him and loved him and he lost that as well. To me Sasuke's only grief should've been for his mother. Sasuke's dad was a ****, his mother was kind to him and loved him.

Sasuke Had love to begin with, lost it. Naruto never knew what love was in the beginning, found it, then lost it, imo that's more to grive about and to be vengeful for. You know what Naruto did that Sasuke didn't? He chose not to act on his hate for Nagato, he chose to try and resolve the issue in a civil manor. Sasuke allows himself to do what he does, Sasuke doesn't attempt to fight the anger, he doesn't attempt to reconcile and to listen to reason and leave his path of vengance. He keeps heading towards it.

There's a reason to why he does this too, it's because of the legacy of the Uchihas. They've always been a clan of hate, they were built on jealousy and vengance. Sasuke's vengeful personality comes directly from his heritage. A heritage of people that looked for vengance in whatever they could because once the Elder Son of the Sage made that his mark and lost himself in it, he doomed his clan to have only one mindset, one creed to live on. Without vengance the Uchihas can't live. For a select few, they managed to find their way out, Itachi and Shisui (as far as we know) but Sasuke demonstrates typical Uchiha behavior and his only peace will come in death because he wollows in vengance and suffers because of those demons inside him in death his soul may find hope.

Wow... I literally couldn't agree more!.... Beautifully put. I couldn't have said it any better myself.

 

[Reborn]

Its funny how no one has mentioned this yet.

They were not all prosocuted, they were not all convicted and put in prison, a precausion was taken because nobody knew who it was and it was rather odd that you didn't see any Uchiha present in the village's defense wasn't it, and Sasuke and Itachi's parents were gone.

Konoha put them in a corner of the village so in revenge the planned to overthrow the government, that's a fair trade off?

 

[Naruto Ninetails]

na.......i don't think

 

[Sasunarufan13]

In my opinion, he deserves to get revenge on the Elders because it was their order that caused the Uchiha clan to be wiped out. I don't really agree with him killing the entire village, but I can understand why he would do that.

 

[Blaze Release]

Sasuke deserves death.

Decided to take a break but when i saw your post i had to log on because this is actually one of your worst arguments imo and you've contradicted yourself from the very start when you said and i quote; "sasuke deserves death"

Revenge is never justifiable. Sasuke chose to wollow in his anger, rage, and hatred. Naruto's countless efforts to catch up to Sasuke because he admired Sasuke, thought of him as a brother. Sasuke always had people open to him even if they were fans, as time progressed, Sakura was there trying to understand as well as Naruto and kakashi but he chose to shun them all away. He chose to fall into this path.

You started your post with sasuke deserves death. Then in this paragraph you said revenge is never justifiable, most people would agree that capital punishment is a form of revenge so how can you say he deserves death then say revenge is never justifiable it doesnt make sense imo. None of the people who you claim where nice to sasuke although i agree had no idea what he was going through. Not just the fact that his clan has been wiped out, he words of his older brother also tormented him and id even go as far as saying its itachi's words more than his actions (killing the clan) that tormented sasuke.

Also how can it be said that Naruto's pain of loosing Jiraiya is less then Sasuke's loosing a clan? He looses his clan, that's clan pride, pride itself is a sin, yet Naruto had somebody he cared about, a father (grandfather figure) somebody who raised him and loved him and he lost that as well. To me Sasuke's only grief should've been for his mother. Sasuke's dad was a ****, his mother was kind to him and loved him.

Cannot believe im saying this to you but that is nonsense, the whole paragraph. We dont know the population of the uchiha, but lets assume for the sake of this argument that they were atleast 200. Are you comparing somebody who has lost 200 people to somebody who has lost 1. Are you comparing somebody who has lost 200 blood relatives to somebody who has lost 1 sensei, i agree jiraiya was like a godfather, but nevertheless not a blood relative. Are you comparing somebody who has lost watched both his parents killed right in front of him to somebody who didnt see how his sensei was killed. Its funny because at the very start naruto had every intention on killing nagato but after the words of minato and him remembering jiraiya did he come down. People also forget this but shikamaru also wanted revenge for asuma his teachers death. Both naruto and shikamaru wanted revenge for 1 person dying and that 1 person wasnt even a blood relative and yet nobody acknowledges sasuke's quest for revenge is on a much much greater and personal level to naruto and shikamaru's. Didnt shikamaru get his revenge?. Whether sasuke's dad didnt care about him (which he did), sasuke's dad still loved him very much and wanted him to be like his big brother itachi due to his accomplishment. Whilst you can question his dad you cannot question his love

Sasuke Had love to begin with, lost it. Naruto never knew what love was in the beginning, found it, then lost it, imo that's more to grive about and to be vengeful for. You know what Naruto did that Sasuke didn't? He chose not to act on his hate for Nagato, he chose to try and resolve the issue in a civil manor. Sasuke allows himself to do what he does, Sasuke doesn't attempt to fight the anger, he doesn't attempt to reconcile and to listen to reason and leave his path of vengance. He keeps heading towards it.

At the highlighted part again, *sigh*. Sasuke had a loving home for 7 years and knew what the love of not only a parent felt like but also a sibling and relatives. Never naruto had anything from the start therefore he doesnt know how that feels to begin in. Somebody who had loved and lost will feel more grief than somebody who hasnt been loved or hasnt loved at all. You make it sound as its only about the clan. Its also about itachi's words that haunted and tormented him.

There's a reason to why he does this too, it's because of the legacy of the Uchihas. They've always been a clan of hate, they were built on jealousy and vengance. Sasuke's vengeful personality comes directly from his heritage. A heritage of people that looked for vengance in whatever they could because once the Elder Son of the Sage made that his mark and lost himself in it, he doomed his clan to have only one mindset, one creed to live on. Without vengance the Uchihas can't live. For a select few, they managed to find their way out, Itachi and Shisui (as far as we know) but Sasuke demonstrates typical Uchiha behavior and his only peace will come in death because he wollows in vengance and suffers because of those demons inside him in death his soul may find hope.

Bold part again is nonsense. Tobi is a troll, i guess we should also believe all the other things he has said. The uchiha wanted peace and went joined forces with the senju. They even looked down upon their leader and sided with the leader of the senju. I wonder whether the senju couldve sided with the leader of the uchiha. There is no such thing as typical uchiha behaviour. How many uchiha characters do we really know enough off apart from obito, shisui, itachi, madara and sasuke and even them we still dont know enough. In every clan there will be good people and they were be people who cannot accept certain things, will not call them bad people because everybody has their reason. If you look at the list of uchiha's that kishi has focused a bit more on, the so called good people being shisui, itachi and obito outweigh the so called bad people in madara and sasuke. I do not believe that either side belong in either category apart from obito who i guess you can say was good. The rest, you can question all of them from shisui to itachi, madara and sasuke. All 4 arent good nor do i believe they are bad.

Anyway to the OP, im not sure what you mean by does sasuke deserve his revenge?. If you mean on the leaf, no. If you mean the elders no. He got his revenge when itachi died my his hands and thats enough. If i was sasuke i wouldnt take revenge on the leaf or the elders nor would i return to konoha. Id go some place else and revive my clan

 

[ANBU Kakashi23]

his reaction to learning a handful of select village elders gave the order to murder his clan in response to their planning a coup, is murder the entire village -___-

everyone is entitled to revenge, but hes just interested in destruction, in killing random people that dont know he exists , ill say hes entitled to revenge, but what he wants is pointless