Sarada's reaction is Understandable. Sasuke, Kirin dont care..

[Melanin]

Adopt = /= being forcefully dumped upon you by your crush . No. That is nannying

And you know for a fact that Sakura was forced to take her into her home and raise her?

Please post that scan, I'll wait..

 

[Dannie]

Na her reaction makes her ungrateful, inconsiderate of the actual mother who raised her may not be her mother but she is still the one who raised her.

Yeah, I guess she should just have a big ass smile on her face and act as if nothing happened.

 

[Netflix and Chill]

Thank God kishi didn't chose to continue Sakura's fodder bloodline...thank God!

 

[Alexiel]

Adopt = /= being forcefully dumped upon you by your crush . No. That is nannying

And how do you think this reflects in regards to the biological ones? (A.K.A. Sasuke and Karin?)

Sakura may be a fool, but the other two are just disgusting. To abandon a child just like that -an no "lol Karin in danger" BS... she basically threw away Sarada to work for Orochi)

 

[UzumakiRyu]

Yeah, I guess she should just have a big ass smile on her face and act as if nothing happened.

Her reaction is expected but doesn't take away the fact she pretty much was very disrespectful to the person who raised her and loved her as her own.

 

[Aquaglow]

I bet at the end of this gaiden manga, it comes up that Sakura is her mom 100% :lol

I have the same feeling too! I can imagine Karin going Whaaaaaaaaaaaattttt when did that happen?? when she finally she meets Sarada?

 

[Ken Kaneki]

And you know for a fact that Sakura was forced to take her into her home and raise her?

Please post that scan, I'll wait..

No scan but I would rather have her raise Sarada in some kind of constraint (initially at least ) rather than raising her crush's lovechild of her free will. That would be just sad and extreme fangirling if she raises a bastard child on her free will

 

[Ken Kaneki]

And how do you think this reflects in regards to the biological ones? (A.K.A. Sasuke and Karin?)

Sakura may be a fool, but the other two are just disgusting. To abandon a child just like that -an no "lol Karin in danger" BS... she basically threw away Sarada to work for Orochi)

People can't say that Sasuke was out due to mission after this chapter. Sarada disappeared and*he didn't even notice or care. He was there this time. No excuses

 

[Aquaglow]

Nah man, DNA match + this chapters theme that genes is not equal to parenthood makes this a done deal

Well I don't believe in "genes not equal to parenthood"! The BIOLOGICAL parent is a REAL parent! Whether anyone likes it or not and no amount of adoption or care can change that!

 

[Alexiel]

People can't say that Sasuke was out due to mission after this chapter. Sarada disappeared and*he didn't even notice or care. He was there this time. No excuses

LOL, he never cared (I mean he never even got to wonder how did she look). And the fact Sarada and Karin are portrayed as two drops of water implies he doesn´t care for the biological mom either and sure as hell never visits her either -if not explain why didn´t he recognize Sarada inmediately after meeting her for the first time-.

This development surely dumped on the "daddy" aspect of Sasucakes. Well, I guess once a inmature reckless brat, always an inmature reckless brat.

 

[Conspirator.]

I agree with this thread. Only someone who is a numskull to the zenith would say that Salad's reaction was not rational or was unjustified, especially when you further take into account that she's not even a teenager. From her current perspective, she has been shunned and neglected by her biological parents since she was born, and to further augment her incredible amount of pre-existing doubt and sadness, her dear Daddy tried to kill her and couldn't even recognise her. Her nanny, Sakura, is an out-and-out liar and cheat who's photoshopping skills far exceed her people and parenting skills, unfortunately, as evidenced by her making her "daughter" homeless just because she was curious to know her heritage. To see your "mother" lose her temper over such an innocuous question must clearly hurt, because her intentions in making that question were not harmful, but merely inquisitive in nature.

Salad is obviously having a major identity crisis right now, and such a thing is obviously tearing her up from the inside. This is the result of being fed a steady dose of lies for the best part of a decade about her heritage, roots, and identity. There's few things worse than having an identity crisis. Overall, good thread.

 

[Dannie]

Her reaction is expected but doesn't take away the fact she pretty much was very disrespectful to the person who raised her and loved her as her own.

Oh I don't know.. maybe it's because she has been lying to her for 12 ****ing years..? Ever thought about that? Pretty sure if someone has been lying to you or keeping a huge secret from you for 12 years that involves your entire life and where you came from then you would be acting the same way too, so don't sit here and tell me that you would be 'respectful' to someone who lies to you about your birth, gets mad at you and breaks your own house, and makes up BS about your own husband wearing glasses or not.

Maybe if Sakura actually told her the truth from the beginning instead of acting feeble and stupid then she wouldn't be acting like this, but no. She has to sneak outside of the damn village with questions just to get an answer, since she can't seem to get a solid answer from anyone in the village including her own damn "mother" and find answers from her father who doesn't even recognize her existence only until she says something.

Regardless if Sakura is taking care of her or not is not the problem and I don't know why people keep repeating it as if that matters. Salad didn't ask for that life nor did she ask to be born into a shitty world with foolish parents, so I don't see how finding out about her real life and birth is being disrespectful when the same people she is trying to ask are being idiots about it. The only person who seems to be helping her is Suigetsu and he's not even from the their village.

Someone that I have been calling "mom" for 12 years only to find out that she is not my real mom, and you expect me to be calm about it?
My dads an a$$hole and never visits me and doesn't even remember what I look like and you expect me to be calm about it?
My home is destroyed because my so called "mom" has anger issues and you expect me to be calm about it?
No one in the village will tell me how I was born and you expect me to be calm about it?
I go and search for my father for the first time in my life and he tells me to mind my own business and you expect me to be calm?

Yeah my whole life is one giant lie, but I should be respectful to some woman who was part of the giant lie all because she took care of me for 12 years. Yeah, no, that's not how it works. In those 12 years that you have been taking care of me you have been lying to me for 12 years as well, so congrats.


EDIT: and for someone who supports Bolt and his stupid reasons for neglecting his father, I don't think you should be throwing around the word 'disrespect'. Bolt is the epitome of disrespect.

 

[UzumakiRyu]

Oh I don't know.. maybe it's because she has been lying to her for 12 ****ing years..? Ever thought about that? Pretty sure if someone has been lying to you or keeping a huge secret from you for 12 years that involves your entire life and where you came from then you would be acting the same way too, so don't sit here and tell me that you would be 'respectful' to someone who lies to you about your birth, gets mad at you and breaks your own house, and makes up BS about your own husband wearing glasses or not.

Maybe if Sakura actually told her the truth from the beginning instead of acting feeble and stupid then she wouldn't be acting like this, but no. She has to sneak outside of the damn village with questions just to get an answer, since she can't seem to get a solid answer from anyone in the village including her own damn "mother" and find answers from her father who doesn't even recognize her existence only until she says something.

Regardless if Sakura is taking care of her or not is not the problem and I don't know why people keep repeating it as if that matters. Salad didn't ask for that life nor did she ask to be born into a shitty world with foolish parents, so I don't see how finding out about her real life and birth is being disrespectful when the same people she is trying to ask are being idiots about it. The only person who seems to be helping her is Suigetsu and he's not even from the their village.

Someone that I have been calling "mom" for 12 years only to find out that she is not my real mom, and you expect me to be calm about it?
My dads an a$$hole and never visits me and doesn't even remember what I look like and you expect me to be calm about it?
My home is destroyed because my so called "mom" has anger issues and you expect me to be calm about it?
No one in the village will tell me how I was born and you expect me to be calm about it?
I go and search for my father for the first time in my life and he tells me to mind my own business and you expect me to be calm?

Yeah my whole life is one giant lie, but I should be respectful to some woman who was part of the giant lie all because she took care of me for 12 years. Yeah, no, that's not how it works. In those 12 years that you have been taking care of me you have been lying to me for 12 years as well, so congrats.


EDIT: and for someone who supports Bolt and his stupid reasons for neglecting his father, I don't think you should be throwing around the word 'disrespect'. Bolt is the epitome of disrespect.

I can tell you if the same happened to me and I was told someone else was my real mother who gave birth to me I wouldn't of acted the way Sarada did and why would I? I would of been raised by the person I see as my real mother and the one I would give my life for so why would I give it for a complete stranger who's never been in my life at all? Nothing would change and so nothing should change for Sarada either.


Sakura is the one who raised her and is her mother, Karin is just DNA that's it.

Tell me something if you were put in Sarada's situation and you were told the person you were raised by and you called mum wasn't and you said like she did "Why should I care about someone who isn't my real mother" and the mum who raised you died in front of your eyes? Would you still hate her for lying to you or regret what you said?

 

[Alexiel]

Uhh you forgot to purt due bloame on your fav, Dannie. she´s to be accounted for abandoning her child just as much as Sasucakes. And sure, Sakura screwed up with the lie... but she was woman enough to take care of the baby. This is a manga fact. Point. End of Story.

Don´t let your bias cloud your judgment.

Poor Sarada.

 

[Darth Uchiha]

Na her reaction makes her ungrateful, inconsiderate of the actual mother who raised her may not be her mother but she is still the one who raised her.

Um....maybe she's just an actual normal human being, who, like most people, would be upset upon finding out the person who has said they are their real parent their whole life isn't. An adult would be upset and angry because of this, Sarada is a thirteen year old girl.

 

[UzumakiRyu]

Um....maybe she's just an actual normal human being, who, like most people, would be upset upon finding out the person who has said they are their real parent their whole life isn't. An adult would be upset and angry because of this, Sarada is a thirteen year old girl.

Yes it does, Her reaction is perfectly normal but does not excuse the fact she pretty much discarded the 12 or so years Sakura raised her and pretty much shit on that entire life.

 

[Darth Uchiha]

Yes it does, Her reaction is perfectly normal but does not excuse the fact she pretty much discarded the 12 or so years Sakura raised her and pretty much shit on that entire life.

Are you not human or something? Are you a machine? Some anti-logic bot trying to run hoops to protect Sakura? Look, as a fellow anti SB like myself, I'm glad to have you around, the thing is, if my own parents had been lying to my for 17 years and weren't my actual parents, while I still loved them, I would be incredibly pissed, I wouldn't just understand and not react, because I am human.

 

[Conspirator.]

Yes it does, Her reaction is perfectly normal but does not excuse the fact she pretty much discarded the 12 or so years Sakura raised her and pretty much shit on that entire life.

That's a vacuous comment. She's only just found out the truth, and you expect her to behave in a "logical" manner(I put the quotations in since I am going to assume that your definition of the "right" response is the right one, which I disagree with in any case). Again, she's just found out that her entire life has been a lie with regards to her parentage, and you think it's normal for a 12-year-old girl, to keep her equanimity and say "This is bad, but Sakura has provided for me for so long, she's my real mother, I'll respect that and go back to her blah blah blah". No, that's a very unrealistic response from even an adult. It's natural for one's emotions to run strong and to react strongly about such things, as this is just how one would feel on the spur of the moment. Her "overreaction" is not wrong in the slightest given the circumstances, and she's definitely not at fault in any way.

 

[UzumakiRyu]

Are you not human or something? Are you a machine? Some anti-logic bot trying to run hoops to protect Sakura? Look, as a fellow anti SB like myself, I'm glad to have you around, the thing is, if my own parents had been lying to my for 17 years and weren't my actual parents, while I still loved them, I would be incredibly pissed, I wouldn't just understand and not react, because I am human.

Not human? What? Did you read what I said or not understand it? Did you see the part me telling you her reaction is normal? or are you selectively reading my post? anyway like I said Sarada saying "Why should I care about someone who isn't my real mother" or whatever makes her ungrateful because like I've said a million times Sakura was there when Karin wasn't for her entire life.

Does that make me inhuman for stating this? You have your opinion and I have mine.

That's a vacuous comment. She's only just found out the truth, and you expect her to behave in a "logical" manner(I put the quotations in since I am going to assume that your definition of the "right" response is the right one, which I disagree with in any case). Again, she's just found out that her entire life has been a lie with regards to her parentage, and you think it's normal for a 12-year-old girl, to keep her equanimity and say "This is bad, but Sakura has provided for me for so long, she's my real mother, I'll respect that and go back to her blah blah blah". No, that's a very unrealistic response from even an adult. It's natural to feel emotional and overreact about such things, as this is just how one would feel on the spur of the moment. Her "overreaction" is not wrong in the slightest given the circumstances, and she's definitely not at fault in any way.

Huh? I said Sarada's reaction is expected of a kid but what she said speaks volumes, If Sakura had died where would that hate go? Would turn into total regret that's where.

 

[Dannie]

I can tell you if the same happened to me and I was told someone else was my real mother who gave birth to me I wouldn't of acted the way Sarada did and why would I? I would of been raised by the person I see as my real mother and the one I would give my life for so why would I give it for a complete stranger who's never been in my life at all? Nothing would change and so nothing should change for Sarada either.


Sakura is the one who raised her and is her mother, Karin is just DNA that's it.

Tell me something if you were put in Sarada's situation and you were told the person you were raised by and you called mum wasn't and you said like she did "Why should I care about someone who isn't my real mother" and the mum who raised you died in front of your eyes? Would you still hate her for lying to you or regret what you said?

She's not my real mother, but at the same time I would still feel bad that she died, but that's it. It's not out of sympathy for taking care of me nor would I regret what I said. It's for the fact that she died. That's all.

Even when it comes to divorced parents - both of my parents got divorced but my mom was the one who cheated and left and to this day she is scum, so this situation is quite different because no matter if she stayed and took care of me for 5 years, the wench still cheated and left, so if she were to die right now I wouldn't care.

Uhh you forgot to purt due bloame on your fav, Dannie. she´s to be accounted for abandoning her child just as much as Sasucakes. And sure, Sakura screwed up with the lie... but she was woman enough to take care of the baby. This is a manga fact. Point. End of Story.

Don´t let your bias cloud your judgment.

Poor Sarada.

I don't consider Karin to be a mother to anyone. She is just part of Salad's creation.

We are discussing about Salad being disrespectful to Sakura when that notion by itself makes no sense given her circumstances.