Sakura new excerpt (from those chinese ones)

[lndra]

It's shown in the canon material; illustrations are done by Kishimoto; the clinic appearing in Part 3 would confirm the writer collaborated with Kishimoto... and despite all this they're not canon?

Each novel that has not been created by Kishimoto has had canon illustrations. No, Kishimoto has not collaborated with the writers. They are all written by different authors who have experience writing manga(s).

So, let me ask you this: the clinic is shown, and you know that part is definitely canon. Though for example, say Sakura receives a bouquet of flowers from the children, and there's no clear evidence of it being ''confirmed'', as there's no way the viewer would know that about the flowers so late after the events of the novel, what would it be considered? M.I.A canon?

If the novels are not stated to be canon, and that the sole fact that Kishimoto did not help, or form any contribution to these novels. They would not be considered canon. Point, blank.

I think it's actually hilarious how you basically nitpick and declare every detail as canon/non-canon for god knows what reason.

I find it a little disappointing that you try to grasp as the little utmost bread crumbs that you can feed on to further prove that you have no actual substance to your knowledge of these novels. They have been made much longer than the one's released this year. None of which have been made canonical, or stated so. So I beg to ask the question on why we are arguing about them.

Why are you going in judgemental mode? First of all, who I like and do like is my business. Second, I don't love Sakura at all, I don't even like her, I just hate how you do everything in your power to bring down her character in every single and little way, so I prefer to take a defensive pose - both because I completely disagree with what you write and because I like an argument. It has nothing to do with my actual neutrality towards her.

I see. Though that's your opinion, I could care less about it, I will respect with what you think of me.

 

[lndra]

What a huge liar.

Your thread:

You must be registered for see links

Made last week. Kakashi, and Shikamaru novels were out by then.

You already understood why I made the thread in the first place

You must be registered for see links

You must be registered for see links

Nice try.

 

[Zef]

You already understood why I made the thread in the first place

You must be registered for see links

You must be registered for see links

Nice try.

> Links me to the same thread I linked.

SMDH

 

[Xlad]

I am here caused I had sensed rustling going on.

 

[lndra]

> Links me to the same thread I linked.

SMDH

Should read the comments. You do know how to do that, I assume?

 

[ANiMUS]

I am here caused I had a sense rustling going on.

R u Sera Kang?

 

[Zef]

Should read the comments. You do know how to do that, I assume?

What do the comments chsnge? Lol

-You made a thread last week because you knew jack about the novels.

-Now you're in here accusing people of not knowing about the novels.

-You do this, and yet your knowledge on the novels are still false.

-Then when I call you out on your ignorance you get butthurt, and threaten to screen cap my posts from another forum as if it changes the fact that you don't know shit.

Stay irate.

 

[Xlad]

R u Sera Kang?

I am many things.

I am Sera Kang.
I am Ha-Ru.
I am Esdeath.
I am Chelsea.
I am Bambietta.
I am Äs Nödt.
I am Chifuyu.
I am Kuro Shinigami.
I am Saeko Busujima.
I am Rangiku
I am Yoruichi.
I am In Gyi Yoon.

More importantly, I am the last of MellowHype's league.

 

[ANiMUS]

I am many things.

I am Sera Kang.
I am Ha-Ru.
I am Esdeath.
I am Chelsea.
I am Bambietta.
I am Äs Nödt.
I am Chifuyu.
I am Kuro Shinigami.
I am Saeko Busujima.
I am Rangiku
I am Yoruichi.
I am In Gyi Yoon.

More importantly, I am the last of MellowHype's league.

Although I have changed my name so many times I can never keep up with everyone else :|

U have the exact number of name changes as I do XD

 

[lndra]

What do the comments chsnge? Lol

/Thread that you linked me to
Comment from me: The novels are not canon
Your repsonse: Why make a thread if you already knew the novels were not canon
Comment from me: I wanted to know if it changed or not.

Mostly because the hype for the next list of novels were getting big, I thought more news released that I missed. Thanks for contributing the game of not knowing how to read ~

 

[Zef]

> Ignores the rest of my post because he still don't know shit.Lol

 

[Ambivalence]

This is ridiculous. You're deliberately viewing the actual point of what I wrote in a different way. Instead of even acknowledging they're at least semi-canon, you bisect them into pieces and declare only what's shown to be canon. If the novels were completely non-canon, like you're trying to prove, instead of a child clinic in Part 3 there would be another building or empty space, which would undoubtedly prove they are filler. I realize I'm speaking like it already happened, but that's just an example.

And wow at the '''knowledge'' part. I'm pretty sure I know just as much as you do - written the author behind Blood Prison, illustrations by Kishimoto, manga/later canon works done by Kishimoto determine the novel's validity.

This reminded my why I hate long arguments... you'll never accept what I'm trying to get through, so why even bother. I'll leave this present.

 

[lndra]

This is ridiculous. You're deliberately viewing the actual point of what I wrote in a different way. Instead of even acknowledging they're at least semi-canon, you bisect them into pieces and declare only what's shown to be canon. If the novels were completely non-canon, like you're trying to prove, instead of a child clinic in Part 3 there would be another building or empty space, which would undoubtedly prove they are filler. I realize I'm speaking like it already happened, but that's just an example.

And wow at the '''knowledge'' part. I'm pretty sure I know just as much as you do - written the author behind Blood Prison, illustrations by Kishimoto, manga/later canon works done by Kishimoto determine the novel's validity.

This reminded my why I hate long arguments... you'll never accept what I'm trying to get through, so why even bother. I'll leave this present.

I'll just quote this with another quote of mine

People seem to believe that I hate the character or the novels themselves. That's not the case. I actually read and have enjoyed them thus far. It is just that Kishimoto had made novels, and has showed pieces of their information in the manga at times. Yet they were never shown to be canon, but when fan favorite characters get novels. They like to allude to the fact that they are. They provide more character development than the actual manga, sad fact is so. I actually hope that Sakura get's her clinic in Part 3. She needs something of her own that is not Sasuke.

For me, there is no semi-canon. It is canon, or it is not. Same with fillers.

It is yes, it is no. The red pill, or the blue pill. I am not the middle man. Though I am sorry if I caused any discomfort.

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

I'll just quote this with another quote of mine



For me, there is no semi-canon. It is canon, or it is not. Same with fillers.

It is yes, it is no. The red pill, or the blue pill. I am not the middle man. Though I am sorry if I caused any discomfort.

Never herd of this semi canon argument till now. Not sure why people are busy defending fillers now? Where were they few years ago?

 

[Xlad]

Although I have changed my name so many times I can never keep up with everyone else :|

U have the exact number of name changes as I do XD

Many more. Lol

 

[Xāvî1]

It's a matter of opinion.

Indeed its a matter of opinion!

 

[BLAZE]

Thanks for sharing

 

[Shruikan]

Why are all these novel threads degenerating into canon/non canon BS?Its off topic.Honestly makes it seems you guys are afraid of its canonicity or lack thereof

OT:THANKS for sharing as always Lol

 

[Natsu Shazneel]

Why are all these novel threads degenerating into canon/non canon BS?Its off topic.Honestly makes it seems you guys are afraid of its canonicity or lack thereof

OT:THANKS for sharing as always Lol

Yup I have a fear of literature that has zero percent to do with my life. Lol

 

[ᴍᴏᴏғʏ]

Thanks for translating, I enjoyed reading it.