Sakura is bad medic you say ?

[-ahhimane-]

Naruto's hard attempt to build the chakra made Shikamaru change his decision of dying. But Sakura played a role of healing him continuously and stopping him from dying. She's still a good healer.
Tsunade is a boss in medical ninjutsus and on par in that field. Sakura hasn't improved to that level yet. That's why Tsunade's one tap on Shikamaru's forehead made an instant recovery and also Naruto was also forcing his chakra to prevent Shikamaru from death so both happened instantly. Sakura is still a good medic ninja. She's in Top 5 in medical group
The top 5 are (not in order) Tsunade, Sakura, Kabuto, Chiyo, Shizune

 

[fayeon]

Naruto's hard attempt to build the chakra made Shikamaru change his decision of dying. But Sakura played a role of healing him continuously and stopping him from dying. She's still a good healer.
Tsunade is a boss in medical ninjutsus and on par in that field. Sakura hasn't improved to that level yet. That's why Tsunade's one tap on Shikamaru's forehead made an instant recovery and also Naruto was also forcing his chakra to prevent Shikamaru from death so both happened instantly. Sakura is still a good medic ninja. She's in Top 5 in medical group
The top 5 are (not in order) Tsunade, Sakura, Kabuto, Chiyo, Shizune

I agree . ......

 

[Troyg39]

I dont know why this is overrating.

Sakura was helpful to him shikamaru was alive because the naruto cloack .those who died there chakra and naruto's got sucked already.

For shikamaru choji might helped him .
Shikamru might have some of his chakra but he was losing it even if the tree wasnt sucking him anymore he was losing chakra and stamina .

Sakura was not VERY helpful but she was keeping him alive

She kept healing him for 2 chapters if she did not and he left alone all that time without healing waiting for naruto's help he would die .

Why would ino thank sakura is she did not help him ? I am not overrating anything theres mothing proves what sakura did was useless .

And her healing is not only for wounds .

When she healed naruto she said" i will restore naruto chakra and give him full recovery "

So she was doing the same for shika

1st bold is why it's overrating her. Your last post ended with "without Sakura Shikamaru would be dead" now you are backtracking and saying he is alive because of Naruto's cloak. That's what I'm saying. She didn't keep him alive. He remained alive because he didn't have all his chakra sucked up like the other ninja. She did what she could but it wasn't nearly as much as you tried to make it out to be earlier

2nd bold: How do you know he was losing chakra? Stamina yes but chakra? I always thought you lose chakra by using it. He wasn't using it and it wasn't being sucked up, so how I doubt it was just jumping out of his body. He was losing stamina due to fatigue/damage suffered in the war and a low amount of chakra. But again, he stayed alive because he had enough chakra to remain so. What Sakura did was the same thing she does to heal physical wounds. She didn't give him any chakra

3rd bold: If she did the same thing for Shikamaru as she did for Naruto, Shikamaru wouldn't have remained in the same state for 3 chapters. He was even under the assumption that he was going to dying BEFORE Naruto stepped in. Which proves that Sakura wasn't keeping him alive or helping him to recover, he was still dying even with her "help"

Sakura's role wasn't to make him better but to keep him alive. Without her he would have been dead. Her medical jutsu was what kept him alive.

Sakura's role was to do what she could for him. Like I said in the above response, Shikamaru was under the assumption he was going to die even while Sakura was trying to save him. He was still getting worse and dying with her help. He didn't recover until Naruto stepped in. He wouldn't died with or without Sakura's help had Naruto not stepped in. What do you think the "Sorry dad, Naruto doesn't want me to go there yet" comment was for?

 

[I Sun I]

1st bold is why it's overrating her. Your last post ended with "without Sakura Shikamaru would be dead" now you are backtracking and saying he is alive because of Naruto's cloak. That's what I'm saying. She didn't keep him alive. He remained alive because he didn't have all his chakra sucked up like the other ninja. She did what she could but it wasn't nearly as much as you tried to make it out to be earlier

2nd bold: How do you know he was losing chakra? Stamina yes but chakra? I always thought you lose chakra by using it. He wasn't using it and it wasn't being sucked up, so how I doubt it was just jumping out of his body. He was losing stamina due to fatigue/damage suffered in the war and a low amount of chakra. But again, he stayed alive because he had enough chakra to remain so. What Sakura did was the same thing she does to heal physical wounds. She didn't give him any chakra

3rd bold: If she did the same thing for Shikamaru as she did for Naruto, Shikamaru wouldn't have remained in the same state for 3 chapters. He was even under the assumption that he was going to dying BEFORE Naruto stepped in. Which proves that Sakura wasn't keeping him alive or helping him to recover, he was still dying even with her "help"



Sakura's role was to do what she could for him. Like I said in the above response, Shikamaru was under the assumption he was going to die even while Sakura was trying to save him. He was still getting worse and dying with her help. He didn't recover until Naruto stepped in. He wouldn't died with or without Sakura's help had Naruto not stepped in. What do you think the "Sorry dad, Naruto doesn't want me to go there yet" comment was for?

Why in the world sakura would heal his physical wounds ? You know she have more tech than healing wounds .

Your logic is

He is losing chakra so i will heal his unexisting wounds .

He did not have any wounds he was drained from chakra thats all .

And even if he lost all his chakra he wont die instantly but if no one helped him like sakura and waited for naruto magical feelings than he would sure die .

Naruto let many people die by the tree and not saved them like shikamaru .

Shikamaru was saved because
1-his and naruto feelings
2-sakura aid
3-naruto chakra


The others who died only had naruto chakra but it did not save them alone . Did it ? Here comes why shikamaru would die without sakura .

Even ino thanked her why would she thank her if what sakura did . Did not help him ?

 

[Tingun]

Ok if naruto can do it alone than why there was still people dying ? Even before naruto sucked by the god tree . The people was dying with naruto cloack .

Naruto wasnt aware what he did in this chapter so why wouldn't he do that with everyone without awareness too

Shukamru had extra help it was sakura

He's been protect everyone. he only stopped when their chakra got sucked away, but now he's recovered.

 

[I Sun I]

He's been protect everyone. he only stopped when their chakra got sucked away, but now he's recovered.

You are talking about chapter 646 ? If that so . Before the god tree attack naruto it did attack many shinobis and they died while holding his chakra . Thats all happend when naruto chakra was still not sucked (this sound nasty)

 

[Troyg39]

Why in the world sakura would heal his physical wounds ? You know she have more tech than healing wounds .

Your logic is

He is losing chakra so i will heal his unexisting wounds .

He did not have any wounds he was drained from chakra thats all .

And even if he lost all his chakra he wont die instantly but if no one helped him like sakura and waited for naruto magical feelings than he would sure die .

Naruto let many people die by the tree and not saved them like shikamaru .

Shikamaru was saved because
1-his and naruto feelings
2-sakura aid
3-naruto chakra


The others who died only had naruto chakra but it did not save them alone . Did it ? Here comes why shikamaru would die without sakura .

Even ino thanked her why would she thank her if what sakura did . Did not help him ?

*sigh*

1st bold: Never said she didn't.

2nd/3rd bold: You are wrong sir or madam. He's been fighting in a war. He has scratches on his face and has probably suffered some internal damage. The fact that you think he's squeaky clean physically baffles me

4th bold: He wouldn't die instantly you say? Tell that to the other ninja that did immediately die and are left on the battlefield dead as a doorknob. Shikamaru didn't die because he didn't have all of his chakra sucked out. Those that did have all of it sucked out died immediately. The slowest death that we've seen as the result of chakra consumption was Kakashi, and even he died within seconds. Shikamaru was already down on the ground before Sakura had even realized it. If he had ran out, he'd be dead.

5th bold: Never said she didn't help. That's not the point I'm making. I'm saying her help isn't as much as you people keep trying to argue. When you keep someone alive, you keep them in a constant state. They don't get any better, but they don't get worse either. Shikamaru was under the assumption that he was going to die even while Sakura was healing him. He was getting worse even with help. He was still dying even with her help. She did not play an important role THIS TIME. She did what she could. That's it. If she had given him chakra, he would've been recovering as chakra is what started his recovery process. So since she wasn't giving him chakra, then she must've been healing his physical wounds, otherwise what the heck was she doing? Just touching him for the fun of it?

You are talking about chapter 646 ? If that so . Before the god tree attack naruto it did attack many shinobis and they died while holding his chakra . Thats all happend when naruto chakra was still not sucked (this sound nasty)

As far as this goes, they died because the tree sucked up the cloak and all of their chakra. Naruto couldn't heal them because his chakra cloaked had gotten drained all the way too. Again proving Shikamaru wasn't completely out of chakra. He had a tiny bit of the cloak left, which made itself visible again when Naruto's feeling caused the chakra to resurface and regenerate.

 

[Kurome]

She's not a good one either :|

 

[hanchan]

The whoe point of sakura effort were for nothing is wrong .

Wether she kept shkiamaru alive or only healed his wounds she did help him in a way so he doesn't die .

And no she is not bad medic ninja that was not her full ability if she had katsuyu pieces it would be different story she could have healed him instead of naruto by remote healing

Its healing + chakra transfer

But kishimoto made the slugs pieces die because of plot and he wants thats scene between naruto and shikamaru

If sakura was not able from the start there wont be that excuse for remote healing

 

[hanchan]

She's not a good one either :|

She is better than almost all the medics expect tsunade and kabuto

Did you see any medic healing after they arrived expect of sakura and shizune ?
She healed everyone on her own at first . Fodderizing all the rest medics .

She is not good she is amazing .

 

[Oblivionx]

she is useful...! admit it and get over it...!

 

[-Punk-]

Everything can be resolve by the power of feelings . Manga fact.

 

[repulse]

Meh. Naruto is still greater than Sakura anyways. Threads like these are pointless, the majority of Naruto readers still view Sakura as being one step away from useless....or even just useless altogether.

 

[NarutoandHinata]

Ready to begin the final stages of his plan, Obito unleashes the Ten-Tails' true form, the original source of all chakra known as the Shinju. It began unleashing countless branches, attacking every living target to absorb its chakra, killing the victim in the process. One of the few survivors of the ordeal but severely drained of nearly all his chakra, Shikamaru collapsed in Chōji's arms. Drifting in and out of consciousness, the young man apologised to his parents for his failings. Shortly after when Hashirama had Ino link everyone telepathically to inform them of what his original had learned about the Eye of the Moon Plan and the Shinju, Naruto's senjutsu-enhanced Tailed Beast Mode combined with Ino's telepathy causes his emotions and personal memories to be conveyed to everyone. Still weak, but conscious, Shikamaru sympathised with Naruto over the loss of Asuma.

As Naruto joined Sasuke in attacking Obito, the residual chakra still inside Shikamaru expanded and began to aid in healing him. While Sakura believed that Naruto was splitting his attention between fighting and healing, Ino explained that it was actually Naruto's chakra acting off his subconscious will. Thinking back on his time with Naruto, Shikamaru drew strength from his belief in him and the hardships Naruto had faced. Shikamaru resolved to stand by Naruto's side as his adviser when he became Hokage, believing he needed someone intelligent around him, similar to the role Tobirama had played with his brother Hashirama. This way, Naruto would never be alone again. Finally recovering enough to sit up, Tsunade later appeared on the battlefield and expedited his recovery with her abilities.

Sorry but Sakura is not included. She tried though.

 

[FemmeFatale]

Now, what was said about Sakura being a bad medic?

 

[iNotorious]

Meh sakura didn't do $#!t, Naruto's cloak gave him a longer time to be alive until tsunade shows up and fixed him, sakura was just sitting near him ''trying'' to heal him and she's like ''Naruto don't worry i got this'', i slapped my face 4 times, tsunade just came and tap shikamaru and he's healed? dafuq man! that's a medic! sakura? bch plz C:

I like her though but her job as a medic with shikamaru sucked.

 

[Turson]

Sakura is 2nd best medic after Tsunade. Thats should be clear for anyone.

 

[iNotorious]

Sakura is 2nd best medic after Tsunade. Thats should be clear for anyone.

You mean third, Kabuto solos.

 

[Turson]

You mean third, Kabuto solos.

Kabuto? His ability to use Mystical Palm technique from few meters is the only feat that Sakura didnt display.

IMO mass remote healing >>> that.

 

[iNotorious]

Kabuto? His ability to use Mystical Palm technique from few meters is the only feat that Sakura didnt display.

IMO mass remote healing >>> that.

Quality -> Quantity.