[VS] Roger, Shiki, rayleigh, whitebeard, dragon vs All the marines

[sage1999]

Scenario 1: All prime. Garp included in the Roger group
Scenario 2: WB wth a hole in his chest and half the face blown off
Scenario 3: Garp on the Marine side
Scenario 4: Like Scenario 1 but all the yonko (and their army) on the marine side
Location: Marineford
Location 2: Alabasta
Location 3: Raftel
The Marines have ALL the intel on the pirates, but the pirates hv none.
All Admirals and Shickibukai on Marine side
The nakama of each pirate is present (Dragon revolutionary army, Shiki army and WB alliance in pirates side)
State: Both parties bloodlusted (Like Akainu*Whitebeard rage)

Who wins?

 

[Punk Hazard]

This is gonna be impossible to debate. What most people here don't seem to understand is that there are countless scenarios and dynamics that can happen, and it's not like each person is gonna have one fight all throughout. Basically, there's no way of knowing which side would win in a fight when it's this many. I don't understand why people make threads like this, you might as well just make Whitebeard vs Akainu or stick to individual matchups.

 

[WoldOfFingo]

As powerfull as they may seem the marines would take this in scenario 1

Aokiji, Akainu, Kizaru, Fujitora, new admiral , Kong , Sengoku Mihawk, Doffy, Kuma


That's already 7 or 8 admiral tier fighters. 2 more than the revs and pirates.
There is no character that can beat 2 admirals, so if u have 2 in spare who can run around and cause chaos having abilities that can melt holes in you're body the size of a basketball it gives u an enormous advantage.

What is the meaning of scenario 4 even lol ? Marines are already overpowered in top tier numbers and u give them 4 Yonko and their fleets as back up?... Unholy stomp in marines favor

 

[keshav31]

First of all you are placing past & present together.If all the pirates like WB,roger,dragon etc are in their prime then of course pirates win.First Roger was never get captured even with this same strength of marines(excluding Yonko).WB can fight equally with roger so how you think marine can defeat them. Yonko strength decrease as shanks is in Roger crew

 

[Anduril]

I'd rate this thread a 1/5 amongst all "vs" threads.

 

[Mugiwara kun]

Lol. This is impossible to judge. Would be interesting though