Red Dead Redemption or Gta 5

[UzumakiWade]

Which game do you think is better?

IMO GTA 5 isn't what it was hyped up to be at all. While once i sat down with red dead o just couldn't get my eyes off my screen. Don't get me wrong, i had plenty of fun with GTA 5 but i found myself getting bored with the free play after completing the game while Red Dead's free play could've been a separate game on its own and i still would've bought it!

So if some Rockstar fan was making a choice on whether to get either Red Dead or Gta 5 which one would u recommend?

Can we all agree that RDR is the best Rockstar game?

 

[SaadBoujane]

Gta 5 is way better. RDD is just; get on this horse, go do this mission, get on this horse go kill this guy, get on this horse and go hunting. It's repetitive. Gta v is a whole world you can explore and practically do everything you want that you can't do in real life (e.g f*ck B*tches)

 

[Zook1]

Gta 5 >>>>>

 

[griffnat13]

Gta 5 is way better. RDD is just; get on this horse, go do this mission, get on this horse go kill this guy, get on this horse and go hunting. It's repetitive. Gta v is a whole world you can explore and practically do everything you want that you can't do in real life (e.g f*ck B*tches)

I agree. GTA has so much to do

 

[Solog0d]

Rdr. But gta V is also good

 

[Saiyan Prince Vegeta]

Red Dead was fun, to an extent. Rockstar has a habit of making great games that get boring when you complete the main story. GTAV has Online which is fun and you can make your own stories. RDD did have an online mode, but it wasn't as fun as I hoped it would be.

 

[Mr Freeze]

GTA 5 all the way but Red Dead was hard to stop playing, it was just that good even for a western(or whatever they called that time event) type game. A goddamn grizzly bear coming at you can be scary AF

 

[Solog0d]

Gta 5 is way better. RDD is just; get on this horse, go do this mission, get on this horse go kill this guy, get on this horse and go hunting. It's repetitive. Gta v is a whole world you can explore and practically do everything you want that you can't do in real life (e.g f*ck B*tches)

Gta V. get in that car. Kill him. Get in that car, capture him. Get in that car do this that blabla. Oh you can go tennis ( nobovy ever does that).
Great and all they have put all those things im it. ut rdr is better

 

[UzumakiWade]

I agree. GTA has so much to do

Really? :rollseyes:

 

[From the Dark Spire]

Gta V. get in that car. Kill him. Get in that car, capture him. Get in that car do this that blabla. Oh you can go tennis ( nobovy ever does that).
Great and all they have put all those things im it. ut rdr is better

Now for me to CORRECT this..... Get in the car, kill him. Make a plan, go perform a heist. Steal the jewelry, escape the cops in the most epic way possible. (especially when they rode their bikes into those 18 wheeler trucks in those tunnels.) Go kill somebody, turn out into a big shoot out. Put on big bodysuits shooting miniguns at the cops, escape in a train, that you can still get on an access whenever you want.... BUY properties, continue to get paid.. Buy cars online, compete in races... Steal a nuclear goverment weapon in a submarine in a trevor mission, get tatted, hair cut, REPEAT MISSIONS, NEED I SAY MORE???

 

[6thHokage]

Gta 5 solo all.

 

[SaadBoujane]

Now for me to CORRECT this..... Get in the car, kill him. Make a plan, go perform a heist. Steal the jewelry, escape the cops in the most epic way possible. (especially when they rode their bikes into those 18 wheeler trucks in those tunnels.) Go kill somebody, turn out into a big shoot out. Put on big bodysuits shooting miniguns at the cops, escape in a train, that you can still get on an access whenever you want.... BUY properties, continue to get paid.. Buy cars online, compete in races... Steal a nuclear goverment weapon in a submarine in a trevor mission, get tatted, hair cut, REPEAT MISSIONS, NEED I SAY MORE???

This comment just soloed you, solog0d.

 

[From the Dark Spire]

This comment just soloed you, solog0d.

I feel so honored. That's the first time someone's ever said a comment by ME, SOLOED anything.. Thanks

 

[Bieber]

GTA5 by far.

 

[Risuna23]

I feel so honored. That's the first time someone's ever said a comment by ME, SOLOED anything.. Thanks

Save it as your sig then:|

 

[Meee]

I liked Red Dead's story more but i had more fun on V.

John Marston > Michael & Franklin

 

[Gamaken]

Neither .

 

[God Of Destruction]

I liked Red Dead's story more but i had more fun on V.

John Marston > Michael & Franklin

travour >>> your Fav

 

[AlphaMaleLion]

GTA 5 is better, i love RDR too....

But GTA 5 sure is overrated.

 

[P3ĮÑ]

Honestly Read dead redemption had a far better story then what GTA 5 had to offer, it's stupendously overrated, the ending was null and void, never much in depth and I never practically understood what it was about. It had 3 endings, and out of those THREE endings only one was decent. In other aspects it never offered much as GTA sa did in terms of accessibility and interactions, such as the GYm, eating, girlfriends etc.

But to narrow it down, story wise RDR takes the cake for me, gameplay wise, free raoming, killing people. GTA 5,