[Discussion] Rate the story arcs

[xxSasukEkUnxX]

God Tier:
Enies Lobby
Water 7
Skypiea
Amazing Tier:
Whitebeard War
Arlong Park
Alabasta
Thriller Bark
Sabaody
Good Tier:
Baratie
Orange Town
Little Garden
Jaya
Impel Down
Punk Hazard
Go ahead and skip it you won't miss anything tier:
Drum Island
Fishman Island
Yours?

 

[kmrasengan]

I agree with your list but I put Punk Hazard in the amazing tier.

 

[Yusuke Urameshi]

I didn't like Skypiea or Thriller Bark that much. My favorite has been Impel Down and Marinford War.

 

[NArutouzzi]

whitebeard war is my favorite for now, decent order tho

 

[Sasukenumberonelover]

Oh this is One Piece.. I thought it be bout Naruto but .. I do kinda agree with your list Broo !

 

[Hexuze]

What's wrong with drum island arc? It was very emotional.

 

[kmrasengan]

What's wrong with drum island arc? It was very emotional.

Ah yes this one too, put it in the amazing arcs.

 

[Skylar Knight]

Wouldn't miss anything during the Fishman Island arc? We got to know Luffy had the Voice of all things, find out that Princess Shirahoshi is the current form of Poseidon, seeing a prediction of Luffy destroying Fishman Island, hearing of the unknown man Joy Boy, and being given information of the New World by Jimbei.

 

[xxSasukEkUnxX]

Wouldn't miss anything during the Fishman Island arc? We got to know Luffy had the Voice of all things, find out that Princess Shirahoshi is the current form of Poseidon, seeing a prediction of Luffy destroying Fishman Island, hearing of the unknown man Joy Boy, and being given information of the New World by Jimbei.

Could've swore knowing luffy had the voice of all things was even before that. Joy Boy will just be big in a later arc, fishman island didn't even tell us what happened, though he's probably a D. and the King of the AK

 

[jiraiya lives]

God Tier:
Enies Lobby
Water 7
Skypiea
Amazing Tier:
Whitebeard War
Arlong Park
Alabasta
Thriller Bark
Sabaody
Good Tier:
Baratie
Orange Town
Little Garden
Jaya
Impel Down
Punk Hazard
Go ahead and skip it you won't miss anything tier:
Drum Island
Fishman Island
Yours?

god tier
whitebeard war
enies lobby
sabaody
alabasta

amazing tier
impel down
water 7
punk hazzard

good tier
arlong park
jaya
fishman island
little garden
orange town
bartarie
drum island

I disliked tier
thriller bark (felt like a bad filler)
skypiea (after the awesomeness of crocodile, enel just felt lame)

 

[jiraiya lives]

Wouldn't miss anything during the Fishman Island arc? We got to know Luffy had the Voice of all things, find out that Princess Shirahoshi is the current form of Poseidon, seeing a prediction of Luffy destroying Fishman Island, hearing of the unknown man Joy Boy, and being given information of the New World by Jimbei.

and luffy's beef with big mom and how he's gonna take over fishman island....I enjoyed that arc

 

[ajflash]

Wouldn't miss anything during the Fishman Island arc? We got to know Luffy had the Voice of all things, find out that Princess Shirahoshi is the current form of Poseidon, seeing a prediction of Luffy destroying Fishman Island, hearing of the unknown man Joy Boy, and being given information of the New World by Jimbei.

Don't forget big mom