[Photoshop] Rate and CnC my Sigs

[Inch]

Been working on a new sig style today.

You must be registered for see images

Made this one for practice purposes.

You must be registered for see images

Someone posted on my VM requesting a sig so I made them this.

I feel that they both are a little bland and that this particular method would probably be better used on a more colorful render.

What do you guys think?

 

[Rihari]

obito is really good 7.5/10
garaa is good as well 7/10

 

[-Haku Yuki-]

obito is really good 7.5/10
garaa is good as well 7/10

what he said

 

[sixSageNaruto]

Nice plain and simple HD feel to it, I like it alot.

 

[Daruny]

That's pretty good. =3

 

[Sonne]

I like the Obito one more,it seems to have better blending.
But I don`t like the text on both.
It's just text with Outter Glow.

 

[Sin]

I like this, I used to do a similar style of these.

There simple and nice.

6.5/10

^ ^

 

[Alternative]

The Obito tag is actually quite nice if you ask me. Only complaint is that it looks a little simple for my liking. Also the text is bad, and seems all over the place. Use a better font, and put it closer to the focal, like maybe just underneath his kunai.

 

[Inch]

The Obito tag is actually quite nice if you ask me. Only complaint is that it looks a little simple for my liking. Also the text is bad, and seems all over the place. Use a better font, and put it closer to the focal, like maybe just underneath his kunai.

Took your suggestion and changed the text slightly.

You must be registered for see images

It's a simpler text style, but I feel it plays into the sig better. Thanks for the suggestion.

 

[Viole]

Nice 8.5/10 overall but first one is better

 

[Escorpiius]

Nice, neat, eye-pleasing, soothing and simple tags.

Gaara's is a bit blank. I don't know why there's something amiss there. Perhaps something should be added like a more attractive text and readjustment of the focal.

Obito's one is better. Perhaps it's the efficient blending which makes it better. The new text is indeed better.

I'll say simplicity got the job done overall though. I'll say, all-in-all, 7/10

 

[Karmolo]

1st: 7/10
2nd: 6/10

 

[Inch]

Nice, neat, eye-pleasing, soothing and simple tags.

Gaara's is a bit blank. I don't know why there's something amiss there. Perhaps something should be added like a more attractive text and readjustment of the focal.

Obito's one is better. Perhaps it's the efficient blending which makes it better. The new text is indeed better.

I'll say simplicity got the job done overall though. I'll say, all-in-all, 7/10

I'm thinking that's because I didn't blur/sharpen the Gaara one.. It sort of lets your eyes wonder more and realize how empty this sig is. xd

 

[~ Killer S ~]

Both are good

 

[Dracule]

8 for Obito
7.5 for Gaara