question about rin

[KakuzuSan95]

hey guys so obviously we kno that rin is dead, and obviously it had a huge impact on Obito, so now my question is why can't obito just bring her back with edo tensei, i mean thats what the jutsu does right? bring dead people back to life, and im positive some of her DNA can be found such as some of her strands of hair, or some of her blood from blood tests? if kabuto can obtain DNA from Madara and kages that lived decades ago he shouldn't have any problem obtaining some of rins DNA!!! is this a huge plothole or what!?

 

[Souji]

It's not a plothole, it's plot. If that happened Naruto as a series would have just ended right there.

 

[godzillard]

i like the way Rin looks better in black/white in the manga
not the anime so much..guess i dont care ...
but i know what happend to the base.....
i wish she had more stuff to do in the manga with her death and all..
But Edo Tensei isnt an ideal way to see the person you loved revived..
its not like she is a good fighter or anything..
but it would be pretty omnious if she was brought back edofied...
she would look like a zombie...
Obito wants her brought back with Rinne Tensei...
thats what he was going to use Nagato for at the end.
after Akatsuki dominated the ninja world...
plans changed..
he wants her brought back in a safe genjutsu world where
she doesnt have to worry about being killed again..
dying violently is not fun i bet

 

[Aertes]

Nah edo tensed Rin would still ditch him for Kakashi.
Genjutsu the world sounds like a better plan

 

[boh]

Kabuto had the kage dna because they were strong, I don't think anybody would collect the dna of a random young leaf shinobi, and then , as Ausar said, the plot is based on Rin death, without that this war wouldn't have happened.

 

[Animaeon]

Bringing back someone from the death with Edo Tensei is not exactly the best case scenario for anyone. The person you love is turned into a living zombie, with a somebody else's corpse as vessel. But more importantly, Obito doesn't know how to use Edo Tensei. He knew this jutsu existed, but needed Kabuto to tell him how it worked. And even then, Kabuto gave him the wrong hand seals.

And this is just a personal belief, but the impact Rin's death had on him was that Madara's words were proven right. Even if she is brought back to life, it wouldn't change the fact something cruel happened to her and Kakashi in the first place. So it wouldn't solve anything either.