Ok, for you people who think I'm doing this for #shine you must get your read on me checked.
You wanted a full list, you're having it.
If you still scum read me after this, you're either scum or town that should really re-think his life choices that ended him into this very site because you will be tunneled to death by me and I don't give no damns
Now, alphabetically.
@Ansatsuken
Ansa had a really weird early game if you ask me, personally. Just based on where his focus was and the posts he made, it read like easy scum posts that anyone could've made. What I didn't like was his dig at me being the more likely scum even though he mentioned one hour prior to this that he doesn't think the scum checked in yet. So, I wanna ask,
@Ansatsuken, what triggered this type of read if there was nothing there?
Having modded Ansatsuken, I've noticed he becomes really frustrated with scum reads on him as scum. His #88 reflects his usual town mindset and it goes against his scum mindset, but despite that, it pinged me as a scum thing to say, because he obviously did address Rej's concerns in a dismissive way - therefore, he did care enough to give an answer - and this type of comment feels forced, as if he literally took his brain out of his skull and read what mindset he has to be faking in order to settle in, the "Many times I don't really care about people's impressions on me when I'm a good guy" on page 3 reads really LAMIST, especially early in the game where comments like that are barely paid attention to. I feel as though "I don't care about your impression, I am hunting scum" is a more appropiate response, whereas the "when i'm a good guy" just feels really out of place.
His Raunix point seems good though and matches with previous town play.
I also liked his SK read as it did feel off to me as well. But more on that when we reach SK.
My gripe with #161 is that the read is actually fairly shallow, and this is important for further points that I will make. My gripe is why is Ansa's thoughts automatically set on "She knows no people gonna vote TSQ without a concrete case" when Red's vote was pretty much RVS, and also, why does that result into a town thought process? To me, it reads exactly like parking your vote on someone that you know won't get lynched easily because that's what mostly gets people town read. I feel as though this is a shaky read from Ansa and I am struggling to parse why his brain defaults Red's RVS vote as "unpopular, and therefore town" instead of arguing about why it is scum. She obviously doesn't plan on lynching me, and when I pointed this out, AND with Red's unvote shtick at EoD, I feel as though Ansa, in retrospect, would've scum read her even more. So def not a good look here.
I liked #165.
Post #185 he acknowledges Red's suspicious behaviour but goes nowhere with it. At this point, if Red would have a partner, it would probably be Ansatsuken.
Oh he starts tying up Red to Rej although he didn't care about Red even though he had reason to, and then he drops the read later on to push me, very bad world building in hindsight.
If you say "Red could be also Rej's team mate" but then you say "I hope tsq starts talking more, not just sit on red all the time" when you have a scum read on Red, why is that a bother to you that I'm voting scum???
