Plot Hole Kakashis MS?

TaBaYo

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
Aug 22, 2012
Messages
641
Reaction score
43
he did not just know about it. He just hadnt train on how to use it because he isnt an Uchiha. So he had to train to master it little by little.
The eyes activated also because the two eyes came together. Obito appearing at where kakashi is also initiated the activation of the MS. But in all, it activated in Obito and affected kakashi, thats why he could not control it and fainted.
 

Ravufuru

Member
Joined
Mar 13, 2014
Messages
164
Reaction score
8
This is all incorrect, Kakashis eye didnt develop until long after Obitos did. They both experianced the loss of a loved one. but since Kakashi isnt an Uchiha it took longer for his to activate.
But the eye is the eye, and the eye has powers, regardless of you being an Uchiha, if you have the eye you have its powers.

Actually if you read the manga, it shows kakashi's sharingan evolve at the same time then he passed out. The scan has half of obito's and kakashi's face (like a mirror) evolving at the same time right before obito goes crazy on the anbu. I'd post the scan but I'm on my phone
 

rollin

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jan 30, 2012
Messages
8,793
Reaction score
1,000
That's probably why he passed out when he first awakened it
And couldn't activate his ms til after the time-skip when he built up more chakra
 

Kakashi Hatakeo

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
Joined
Dec 4, 2011
Messages
2,294
Reaction score
170
More importantly why is kakashi jot evil psychopath like sasuke
 

shelke

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Messages
22,716
Reaction score
2,495
It isn't a plot-hole. It's clearly explained through images and Tobirama's analysis. The manga showed that Obito could see through Kakashi's eye, as if they were a pair. Which means, since Obito was close, the eyes began acting as a pair for Obito.

Kakashi's Sharingan cannot evolve. He lacks Uchiha Blood and Chakra - both things explicitly required for sharingan mutations and its usage at optimum level. Both of these are canonical facts. Since he lacks the Blood and chakra, his Sharingan cannot mutate.

It's just that simple. Any other statements are just fanboy ramblings and self-serving misinterpretations.
 

apsri

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
May 20, 2013
Messages
645
Reaction score
36
Maybe that special chakra sprouts inside everyones brain, but only affects Uchiha because of their Doujutsu.

@everyone saying things about Obito: That wouldn't explain why Kakashi's eyes evolved. The special chakra anatomically affects the eyes of the host, so, unless Kakashi and Obito's anatomy is "linked" somehow, that'd be impossible.

Eh, it is linked. Kakashi can see what Obito does, and Obito can see what Kakashi does. Obito gaining MS caused Kakashi to gain MS. He later passed out, though, due to the strain.
 

slyvixen

Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
117
Reaction score
14
Why can't I see the second image?

Tobirama was explaining how the Uchiha's change their eyes into sharingan. It doesn't mention getting mangekyou.

Obito commented about Kakashi getting his mangekyou. Being an Uchiha, Obito didn't seem to think that he was the one who activated his own eye or that they are connected like that. He just couldn't believe Kakashi has gotten so good with it
 

shelke

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Messages
22,716
Reaction score
2,495
Why can't I see the second image?

Tobirama was explaining how the Uchiha's change their eyes into sharingan. It doesn't mention getting mangekyou.

Obito commented about Kakashi getting his mangekyou. Being an Uchiha, Obito didn't seem to think that he was the one who activated his own eye or that they are connected like that. He just couldn't believe Kakashi has gotten so good with it

Tobirama was talking about Sharingan mutation. How is MS or EMS not a part of it?

Obito had no idea Kakashi had even awoken MS back when he stabbed Rin. Obito's words hold no value, as he doesn't know the intricacies behind Sharingan Mutations.
 

slyvixen

Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
117
Reaction score
14
Tobirama was talking about Sharingan mutation. How is MS or EMS not a part of it?

Obito had no idea Kakashi had even awoken MS back when he stabbed Rin. Obito's words hold no value, as he doesn't know the intricacies behind Sharingan Mutations.

Yeah, I have no proof Obito knows the intricacies behind the sharingan. But he was Madara's pupil and he had a rinnengan that can read the tablet fully so there is a chance he might know. It doesn't say anywhere that he doesn't know for sure either. So i guess I can just interpret his words at face value.

Kakashi is non-Uchiha but he can still use the Sharingan. He cannot use it fully - it drains his chakra - but it's not a dead organ. If he can use it, I am inclined to believe that Kakashi can develop it further. Tobirama explains you need to experience trauma to change your eye into sharingan. You need to experience trauma again - particularly the death of a loved one - to change it to mangekyou. I agree with you on that.
 

shelke

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Messages
22,716
Reaction score
2,495
Yeah, I have no proof Obito knows the intricacies behind the sharingan. But he was Madara's pupil and he had a rinnengan that can read the tablet fully so there is a chance he might know. It doesn't say anywhere that he doesn't know for sure either. So i guess I can just interpret his words at face value.

Kakashi is non-Uchiha but he can still use the Sharingan. He cannot use it fully - it drains his chakra - but it's not a dead organ. If he can use it, I am inclined to believe that Kakashi can develop it further. Tobirama explains you need to experience trauma to change your eye into sharingan. You need to experience trauma again - particularly the death of a loved one - to change it to mangekyou. I agree with you on that.

Tablet doesn't have anything to do with Sharingan Mutation information. The Sharingan is simply used to read it.

Few people are shown using tools of other ninjas - Danzo, Ao, Nagato, and Obito. Obito outright stated that only the original owner has the perks of the Doujutsu - the one who actually awakens it : . Its chakra and power were far too taxing for even him.

Sound familiar? Kakashi had the same problem. He cannot even turn off the Sharingan, which means he lacks the capability to even stop the chakra supply to the eye. How can you say that he has the ability to mutate through a nonexistent chakra, when he cannot even control the eye that was originally transplanted?

This is further cemented by the fact that he shares the same pattern and has the same ability as Obito. The evidence is far too overwhelming to support the fact that Kakashi never awoke it. It's just kakashi fanboys denying facts.
 

Kurama999

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Sep 13, 2012
Messages
1,522
Reaction score
38
Surprise...
Naruto teach Kakashi on how open & activate his left eye, after he heal him.
Possibilities;
Since Naruto have the Sage power, he could had created a rinnegan eye to Kakashi.
Naruto had the cloak, bijuu, senju, = Sage cloak, bijuu, senju
But Naruto is not 100% Sage power, he had to combine with Sasuke.
 

Telekinesis

Member
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
72
Reaction score
10
This is unbelievable...

It's not reasonable that you are defending Kakashi can awake Mangekyou Sharingan. Uchiha have special chakra, he has not.

It's damn plothole and we know that manga crew always make mistake, even false drawing for 15 years. Especially since chapter 599 thru
 

slyvixen

Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
117
Reaction score
14
Tablet doesn't have anything to do with Sharingan Mutation information. The Sharingan is simply used to read it.

Few people are shown using tools of other ninjas - Danzo, Ao, Nagato, and Obito. Obito outright stated that only the original owner has the perks of the Doujutsu - the one who actually awakens it : . Its chakra and power were far too taxing for even him.

Sound familiar? Kakashi had the same problem. He cannot even turn off the Sharingan, which means he lacks the capability to even stop the chakra supply to the eye. How can you say that he has the ability to mutate through a nonexistent chakra, when he cannot even control the eye that was originally transplanted?

This is further cemented by the fact that he shares the same pattern and has the same ability as Obito. The evidence is far too overwhelming to support the fact that Kakashi never awoke it. It's just kakashi fanboys denying facts.

If the tablet has the secrets of mangekyou sharingan, it has information on sharingan mutation. There's no way to know for sure so it's really just a possibility that Obito might know. I just can't rule it out right away because of that.

Ao - I forgot that guy honestly. He didn't have problems turning the byakugan on and off. But Hyuuga don't awaken their byakugan; they were born with the white eyes.

I don't disagree with you that the original owner has the perks of the dojutsu. It also says the pair is stronger together. I guess I'm just confused because they eyes in Obito and Kakashi are connected. I think it was imperative for Kakashi to feel trauma for him to be able to get the MS. Hmmm... If Kakashi was far away from Obito when Obito awakens MS, then his eye automatically turns to MS too? Just because it's Obito's eye? Or if Kakashi didn't feel trauma but Obito is near when he awakens MS, then his automatically turns to MS too? Just because the eyes are proximate?

I can't explain for the same pattern and same ability. Maybe because these powers are latent in the eye and the eyes are originally a pair. They are powerful together so it makes sense that they can have the same ability or that they complement each other. I really can't make sure
 

shelke

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Messages
22,716
Reaction score
2,495
^ The Tablet speaks about what the Uchihas know in regards to the sacrifices they made. It doesn't state anything in regards to the underlying factors. Besides, how would Chakra mutation be a secret among the Clan? Obito obviously was a special case ... because he was an idiot. A dead-last like Naruto.
 

TrollKing

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
9,127
Reaction score
346
Yea the chakra in obito's brain filed to or kamui to kakashi eye to awaken ms. Yup some garbage logic I gotta say or if you prefer to use the word "pothole"
 
Top