Petra Path vs Onmyouten (Obito black chakra)? (Discussion)

[The Grand Pubba]

Lets state some facts about each first

Petra Path
-Can absorb any ninjutsu thrown at it and make it useless. It is not limited to a single element either seeing as it could absorb Dust Realase( Fire,Wind,Earth) no problem.
- It can absorb chakra itself, doesn't have to be only ninjutsu. Shown by Nagato absorbing Killa B's cloak.
- Only con is if it absorbs to much Senjutsu then the user becomes a statue if they cant handle it.

Onmyouten (Black Chakra)
- Negates all Other ninjutsu cept for Sage chakra.
- When Hiruzen was analyzing it, he sated that it was bassically a better Dust Release with more elements and having the ability change its shape so it can be used for offense and defense.
- Once he gets control of juubi, Tobirama states that its Yin-yang release jutsu. Its safe to say that "Sage" Obito added Yin-yang to the elemets that already exsited to the charkara that took out Hiruzen.
- Still Nujutsu.


SO here is the Question.

If Obito was to lunge at Nagato (or Edo Madara) with like a lance version of the chakra, Would the Petra path Absorb it or Would the Onmyouten negate the tech.

AS always thx for reading!

 

[AllomnisymbolsparttwoT]

obito wins :I

 

[Touken]

You've got something negating ninjutsu against something that gave birth to ninjutsu.

Only Kishi can clear this up.

 

[Umari Senju]

Obito wins this in one of two ways:

As you stated too much Senjutsu and its stone city. All Obito needs to do is (as you said) create a lance of out of his Onmyouten then apply enough Sage Chakra into it. When Preta path attempts to absorb it BAM statue time!

Or

Since Onmyouten can negate all ninjutsu and Preta paths absorbing technique is still concidered Ninjutsu, the lance wouldn't be effected as it negates all ninjutsu. This would included Preta Path's ninjutsu absorbing ability...at least in theory anyway. So if he tried to absorb it it wouldn't work and preta path would be impaled.

 

[The Grand Pubba]

You've got something negating ninjutsu against something that gave birth to ninjutsu.

Only Kishi can clear this up.

Of course, but what do U think.

I dont think that right now there is wrong or right answer. Just what you think

 

[Touken]

Of course, but what do U think.

I dont think that right now there is wrong or right answer. Just what you think

I think Onmyouten wins but Preta Path has more advantages when going up against other techs.

Btw, Preta Path can absorb senjutsu (sage techniques), it just can't absorb raw natural energy. That's another advantage of Preta Path.

 

[The Grand Pubba]

Obito wins this in one of two ways:

As you stated too much Senjutsu and its stone city. All Obito needs to do is (as you said) create a lance of out of his Onmyouten then apply enough Sage Chakra into it. When Preta path attempts to absorb it BAM statue time!

Or

Since Onmyouten can negate all ninjutsu and Preta paths absorbing technique is still concidered Ninjutsu, the lance wouldn't be effected as it negates all ninjutsu. This would included Preta Path's ninjutsu absorbing ability...at least in theory anyway. So if he tried to absorb it it wouldn't work and preta path would be impaled.

1. Nowhere is it stated that Obito can use sage chakra. I would highly doubt that Obito can use the one thing that is weak against. If he could, wont he be able to counter sage charkra with hs own sage cahkra? Anyway going on what has been shown and stated, Obito cant use Sage chakra, so thst first argument is invalid.

2. But the lance is Ninjutsus itself. Its isnt tiajutsu, not an illusion so no genjutus. Petra can absorb any and all ninjutsu so why would it not be able to absorb the lance?

 

[Aya San]

Against super strong SM user preta has advantage as seen Obito's black shield got obliterated from a few rasengans

 

[Young Thug]

Against super strong SM user preta has advantage as seen Obito's black shield got obliterated from a few rasengans

Why are you treating the Rasengan as if it's some low tier academy jutsu? Although it's overused it's still one of the top jutsus.

 

[- J AV -]

i believe preta path wins,, it absorbs chakra.. so obito's black stuff will be of no use, and obito never used sage jutsu so i am going with preta path

 

[Shinobi2012]

Omyoudon is not ninjustu ninjustu is made up by molding yin and yang into chakra

Omyoudon is mastery of yin-yang.

Omnyoudon is not affected by preta path.

So if you foolishly pull out preta path while obito uses Omyoudon.....you die.

Come one people what and how chakra forms was the first thing kishi taught us.

Does anyone remember iruka lessons ?

 

[amarusboobs]

Both get ****ed up by Senjutsu.

 

[Sunagura]

It like immovable object vs unstoppable object clash

 

[Shinobi2012]

Omnyoudon is not ninjustu.

(YIN)Spiritual energy + (YANG)psychical energy is molded together and forms chakra.

Chakra is utilized to perform ninjustu

Omnyoudon is mastery of your inner forces your (YIN)Spiritual energy & (YANG)psychical energy.

Preta path doesn't absorb Omnyoudon

///////////THREAD

 

[SasoriOfTheRedSaand]

Shino's bugs one shot.

 

[Shura]

Shino's bugs one shot.

Oh no.. Did you watch FT's bug porn?

OT: Sasori 1shots.

 

[Europa]

Preta path is technically ninjutsu. But doesn't ohmaigumball use chakra? I'd go with Preta path.


But Samehada trumps both.

 

[genii96]

Preta path will absorb it

 

[Bronze]

Preta path is clearly superior. It will absorb the black sh1t with no sweat.