Personal Opinions on Yata

[lswhyte123]

So don't get mad. I know we've had a lot of these, so now all I want is a simple yes or no vote. Feel free to comment too if needed.

Yata Mirror as far as we know should be able to instantly reflect everything that hits/touches it.
It is stated on Narutopedia that it contains all nature transformations. Meaning it can mix and change nature's into all forms eg Dust,Lava etc
It has proved to be able to block physical attacks eg Sasuke
Zetsu says it has all nature types and along with the sword makes the user almost invinsable.
As it is called Mirror we have to assume it acts as quickly and effectively until proven otherwise. So hitting it with 2 different attacks makes no diff as it copies and reflects both.

Example
Use Katon-it uses Katon to nulify
Use Kamui-it casts Kamui to nulify
Use TBB-it emmits a force the same as TBB

Please vote

 

[Abyss]

it hasnt been proven wrong yet, so yeah.

 

[devil naruto]

i think it can't deflect everything

 

[Illyasviel]

it hasnt been proven wrong yet, so yeah.

yes

 

[Ultimatevirus]

So don't get mad. I know we've had a lot of these, so now all I want is a simple yes or no vote. Feel free to comment too if needed.

Yata Mirror as far as we know should be able to instantly reflect everything that hits/touches it.
It is stated on Narutopedia that it contains all nature transformations. Meaning it can mix and change nature's into all forms eg Dust,Lava etc
It has proved to be able to block physical attacks eg Sasuke
Zetsu says it has all nature types and along with the sword makes the user almost invinsable.
As it is called Mirror we have to assume it acts as quickly and effectively until proven otherwise. So hitting it with 2 different attacks makes no diff as it copies and reflects both.

Example
Use Katon-it uses Katon to nulify
Use Kamui-it casts Kamui to nulify
Use TBB-it emmits a force the same as TBB

Please vote

may be yes

 

[Gatsuuga]

I dont think it can deflect everything. To use your example what chakra element is kumai?

 

[Gary777]

even if it reflects evrythin.... it has its weaknesses

 

[lswhyte123]

I dont think it can deflect everything. To use your example what chakra element is kumai?

Kamui is not a chakra element bud. But neither is physical force and it repelled that. Same with explosive force. It's just that the idea is it reflects all damage and attacks.
I know what everyone thinks. If that's true then the user is unbeatable. But that is not the case. Yata is only used by Itachi with Susanoo, without Susanoo it will dissappear. The drain it causes on chakra is the draw back. It's a last resort defence. On the whole, I rate Gaara's defence much higher than Susanoo.

Good post though

 

[lswhyte123]

even if it reflects evrythin.... it has its weaknesses

Absoloutely buddy. It doesn't have a full spectrum of defence like say Gaara or Neji's rotation. Also the hugh outpouring of chakra is it's biggest weakness.

 

[Baldy]

They are legendary weapons after all. It can probably reflect just about any attack but there must be a weakness

 

[lswhyte123]

i think it can't deflect everything

If it can deflect phsyical attacks, match and nullify Natural attacks and also has been said to render the user almost invinsible, what can it not block?

I know that you can get round it, but that doesn't change the fact that it can't be broken through.

 

[hanothemano]

Chibaku Tensei or Tailed Beast Ball?

 

[itachi49]

orochimaru's kusanagi sword was also reputed to cut anything but it failed with enma and naruto in kyubi mode so these kind of legend aren't true in manga.

i don't believe yata mirror could deflect attacks like dust release , chibaku tensei or kamui ...
only things 100% sure are that it can deflect 1 element ninjutsu and weapons physical attacks.

 

[lswhyte123]

Chibaku Tensei or Tailed Beast Ball?

Chibaku Tensei is not exaclty an offensive, so it can't reflected. It's doesn't attack. It would just seal the entire Susanoo.

TBB theoretically could be reflected at it's power has a limit, thus can be matched.

All theory though. Nothing bar what the guy above said is certain.