[Discussion] One Piece Top 20?

[Avinash012]

He's fleet admiral dude. He will be Luffy's final fight too.

Anyone from WG that can match Roger(PK) exept Garp a Vice Admiral......?

I agree with the fact that he plays a crucial Role but I don't think he will be the Final one to be defeated by Luffy...IMO it'll be whole WG & he is just a part of it ..a top Dog though....

 

[LitzSabr]

It took both Garp and Sengoku to fight and defeat Shiki (before his capture when afterwards inside of his cell he would've withered. If Kidd is supposed to mirror him then Shiki is definitely up there with Roger and WB (Mirrored by Luffy and Law).

So Shiki not only weakened due to age but also a loss of both legs doesn't exactly help , nor does starvation and being locked up.

I accept being Shiki being weak (his head). But about the thing that It took both Garp and Sengoku' to defeat them, it's not true. Garp IMO could've taken him down 1 on 1 (had almost killed Roger many times). Also only half the marineford was destroyed in that fight(3 people of that Caliber should've done more), that means the fight was finished in a short amount of time (even WB alone did that much damage), so the less amount of damage says that Shiki didn't stood upto/do much against Garp and Sengoku but was rather pulverized easily, so it doesn't make this feat a good of a feat for him so as to say that it took both Garp and Sengoku to defeat him.

And Roger = WB, that's the main point. Both should be on 1. About Garp we don't have a confirmation, he may be a little stronger or a little weaker than Roger as both nearly killed each other several times (and no ratio available too )

 

[Ahmed1993]

This top 20 is about alive ( not retired ) people and based about their hype :

1/2 Dracule Mihawk (Mihawk > Shanks because Shanks lost an arm)
2/1 Monkey D. Dragon
3 Shanks
4 Black Beard
5 Kaido
6 Big Mom
7 Akainu
8/9 Kizaru
9/8 Aokiji
10. Rayleigh.
11/12 Fujitora
12/11 Green-Bull
13 Doflamingo
14 Kidd
15/16. Law
16/15. Luffy.
17 X Drake
18 Smoker
19/20 Kuma
20/19 Boa Hancock

 

[kibainuzuka]

This top 20 is about alive ( not retired ) people and based about their hype :

1/2 Dracule Mihawk (Mihawk > Shanks because Shanks lost an arm)
2/1 Monkey D. Dragon
3 Shanks
4 Black Beard
5 Kaido
6 Big Mom
7 Akainu
8/9 Kizaru
9/8 Aokiji
10. Rayleigh.
11/12 Fujitora
12/11 Green-Bull
13 Doflamingo
14 Kidd
15/16. Law
16/15. Luffy.
17 X Drake
18 Smoker
19/20 Kuma
20/19 Boa Hancock

mihawk first? lol

 

[Ahmed1993]

mihawk first? lol

Just wait until he goes all out

 

[YellowFang]

Well, at least my fav. Zoro makes it in top 20...

 

[YellowFang]

This top 20 is about alive ( not retired ) people and based about their hype :

1/2 Dracule Mihawk (Mihawk > Shanks because Shanks lost an arm)
2/1 Monkey D. Dragon
3 Shanks
4 Black Beard
5 Kaido
6 Big Mom
7 Akainu
8/9 Kizaru
9/8 Aokiji
10. Rayleigh.
11/12 Fujitora
12/11 Green-Bull
13 Doflamingo
14 Kidd
15/16. Law
16/15. Luffy.
17 X Drake
18 Smoker
19/20 Kuma
20/19 Boa Hancock

I'd never place Mihawk above any Admiral or Yonko straight away... But to put him above everyone else is LOOL...

 

[Ahmed1993]

I'd never place Mihawk above any Admiral or Yonko straight away... But to put him above everyone else is LOOL...

Keep telling yourself that

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Akainu never reached his prime yet. IMO near EOS he would be at top 3 for sure.

He's passed it....

My all time top 10 would be this

1.Roger
2.WB
3.Grap/Dragon
4.Shanks/Dragon
5.Rayleigh
6.Mihawk
7.Shiki
8.Kong
9.Sengoku
10.Akainu

All are in their Prime

LOL! Grap...

He's fleet admiral dude. He will be Luffy's final fight too.

He passed his prime. Sengoku was much stronger in the past than at MF.

I accept being Shiki being weak (not because of starvation but about the legs). But about the thing that It took both Garp and Sengoku' to defeat them, it's not true. Garp IMO could've taken him down 1 on 1 (had almost killed Roger many times). Also only half the marineford was destroyed in that fight(3 people of that Caliber should've done more), that means the fight was finished in a short amount of time (even WB alone did that much damage), so the less amount of damage says that Shiki didn't stood upto/do much against Garp and Sengoku but was rather pulverized easily, so it doesn't make this feat a good of a feat for him so as to say that it took both Garp and Sengoku to defeat him.

It didn't take the two of them. But I feel Shiki would have defeated either in a 1v1. And you don't consider that there were two marines fighting (they would try to avoid destroying MF unless absolutely necessary).

And Roger = WB, that's the main point. Both should be on 1. About Garp we don't have a confirmation, he may be a little stronger or a little weaker than Roger as both nearly killed each other several times (and no ratio available too )

Well Mehh I know they're equal but I feel like I'd be disrespecting the king otherwise.

 

[Avinash012]

LOL! Garp...

What's wrong with Garp.?

I think He deserves it....

About that Shiki's part I dont think he can beat Garp in a One on One match ...He is on the same level as Roger ,WB and Garp but can't win against any of them in a one on one IMO....

 

[Vandenre1ch]

1-Gol D. Roger
2-Edward Newgate
3-Monkey D. Dragon
4-Golden Lion Shiki
5-Monkey D. Garp
6-Shanks
7-Marshall D. Teach
8-Kaidou
9-Big Mam
10-Sengoku
11-Akainu
12-Aokiji
13-Kizaru
14-Silvers Rayleigh
15-Marco
16-Mihawk
17-Ace
18-Donquixote Doflamingo
19-Fujitora
20-Enel

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

What's wrong with Grap.?

I think He deserves it....

About that Shiki's part I dont think he can beat Grap in a One on One match ...He is on the same level as Roger ,WB and Grap but can't win against any of them in a one on one IMO....

His name is not Grap. It is :

Spoiler

GARP

 

[Avinash012]

His name is not Grap. It is :

Spoiler

GARP

Oops Sorry....not paying attention to the names ....I'll change it..& thank u

 

[Mephew D Kensei]

Current
Guyz who rule for now:
Dragon, Shanks

Guys just below:
Kaido, B.Mum, Akainu, Mihawk and maybe Teach
Just a bit below:
Aokiji, Kizaru, Fujitora, Teach, Ryokugyu, Marco, Ben Beckman,

A Tad lower:
Doflamingo, Kuma, Magellan, Vista, Jozu, Crocodile

Lower:
SUPANOVA(brass) some BB pitates(if they r trully worth their Impel down lvl), Some Red hair pirates, New world veteren Captains, Enel, some VA's, Ivankov

kinda on the spur thing not much thought n analysis put into into.

 

[David1996]

1. Prime (Gold Roger, WB, Sengoku, Garp, Kong, Dragon)
2. Shanks, Rayleigh, Shiki
3. Kaido, BM, BB
4. Akainu
5. Aokiji, Kizaru, Z, Mihawk, Benn Beckman

 

[LitzSabr]

It didn't take the two of them. But I feel Shiki would have defeated either in a 1v1. And you don't consider that there were two marines fighting (they would try to avoid destroying MF unless absolutely necessary).

Shiki may have defeated Sengoku but not Garp, not until Shiki is confirmed stronger than Roger(=,<,> than Garp) which he most likely isn't. And well maybe Shiki did most of that to MF, we did saw someone throw a Battleship (it's either Shiki or Garp), but still certainly didn't alone do that when his opponents were also destructive like him. Things are bound to get destroyed in a fight of that level, but it wasn't that big as it should've been .-

Well Mehh I know they're equal but I feel like I'd be disrespecting the king otherwise.

Well that's true too, but the King himself respected WB. We should give him respect too U_U

 

[Kuriboh]

top people that are alive in the series (no order)

enel
kizaru
akainu
shanks
kaido
big mom
blackbeard
dragon
mihawk
fujitora
hancock (Second strongest woman easily)
doffy

there are more, but i cant think of any right now

 

[Kuriboh]

1-Gol D. Roger
2-Edward Newgate
3-Monkey D. Dragon
4-Golden Lion Shiki
5-Monkey D. Garp
6-Shanks
7-Marshall D. Teach
8-Kaidou
9-Big Mam
10-Sengoku
11-Akainu
12-Aokiji
13-Kizaru
14-Silvers Rayleigh
15-Marco
16-Mihawk
17-Ace
18-Donquixote Doflamingo
19-Fujitora
20-Enel

fujitora and Doffy would destroy ace

 

[Vandenre1ch]

fujitora and Doffy would destroy ace

Saying "destroy" is a bit much dont you think? A fight between those 3 can either way which is why I placed Ace 1 rank higher than Flamingo. I see Ace having better chances of winning.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Saying "destroy" is a bit much dont you think? A fight between those 3 can either way which is why I placed Ace 1 rank higher than Flamingo. I see Ace having better chances of winning.

However since Luffy is roughly equal to (and quite likely superior to) Hiken no Ace ; and Doffy neg diffed both Trafalguy (Luffy's apparently his equal/slight superior , this wouldn't make a big impact if Doffy fought Luffy though) AND Sanji with no fatigue experienced.

Placing him easily above Ace (IMO He is between 31 and 38 accompanied with the M3,Law, Kidd and Killer.). Considering Doflamingo is scared of fighting an Admiral ; And that Sakazuki One Shotted Ace. And that Kuzan could still fight Ace on equal/superior terms with an elemental disadvantage proves how easily an Admiral will defeat Ace.

Also if you can't hit a Logia you're not even top 40. So Enel is out of the question, I was amazed anyone put him top 20.