One Piece or Naruto?
- Thread starter Astar
- Start date
LeafSpirit 20
Active member
Lol alright old man can't take one piece being criticized it's just too much for him... You call me children yet you are making a fool of yourself and loosing your head. I stated what I think of one piece and I'm not changing it
Uchiha seeker
Active member
Awards
Haruno Hyuuga Yamanaka
Member
No clue as regards what? I watched over 20 animes (yes, this includes Naruto) and I still prefer One Piece over anything.
Please define what you mean by a true anime. It just doesn't make sense what you say.
I'm not asking you to like One Piece. I'm asking you not to talk bad about it if you haven't watched it completely, just like I won't talk badly about Bleach or Hunter x Hunter since I haven't finished either one of them. It's just pointless.
Don't go around yelling "the animation sucks" or "the beginning's horrible". I didn't like Naruto at the beginning and still didn't like it until I reached the Chuunin exams arc. And of course the animation at the beginning isn't good, it started in 1999 for God's sake!
LeafSpirit 20
Active member
Lol, well I think fighting is completley useless, and specially on the internet, so ill be a man and leave it at that. I didnt mean you guys hated bleach in this thread, but some do in this forum alltogether, I read post hating on bleach, but did I take the ofensive and try to bite their heads off? No, i respected their opinion, as some people dont like or hate anime like bleach which I love, I dislike one piece, and im not changing my opinion. I really dont like the animation and character design in either the manga or the anime, plus the plot and characters dont interest me in one bit either. Haruno Hyuuga Yamanaka
I respect your point of view, but sadly, I cant say that about all members who clearly lack education and talk like they dont have a mother. The conclusion that lead me to say that one piece is childish is that I used to like it back when I was 13 years old, but now at the time it just seems childish altogether. Anyways in MY OPINION one piece could have been great, a journey to find a treasure called one piece was a great layout, but the direction just wasnt right
I respect your point of view, but sadly, I cant say that about all members who clearly lack education and talk like they dont have a mother. The conclusion that lead me to say that one piece is childish is that I used to like it back when I was 13 years old, but now at the time it just seems childish altogether. Anyways in MY OPINION one piece could have been great, a journey to find a treasure called one piece was a great layout, but the direction just wasnt right
LeafSpirit 20
Active member
I stoped fighting.. I f you didnt realize and that comment I made was directed to Norman jayden who edited my post to something nasty and childish that deserves a ban, read it for yourself. Doesnt seem that youre contributing either as you too are carring these argument along. Lets all be men and now leave it alone. We all have our opinions and mine was clearly stated, respect it and take it, as I respected and took it like a man when they insulted bleach
Everything else below is nothing but nonsense than Mr. Man
Mr. Man, leave it at that already
:flaw:
:flaw::flaw: That's 2
Childish
OP: You can't prove it
Naruto: Too many for 1 reply.
Be a Man and leave it at that. Go on Mr. Man
Haruno Hyuuga Yamanaka
Member
Italic part: Yes, and I liked Sakura Card Captors when I was 8, yet I don't see it as childish now that I'm 18, specially after reading the manga.
Bolded part: This is what people usually say about OP before reading it. "Uh, gay pirates looking for treasure, stupid, hate, hate, childish". Sorry, but again, try watching before commenting. I don't mean to offend, but you do realize calling an anime childish when it's not and you know practically nothing about it does offend me to, right? And specifically, my favorite anime? As I stated earlier, I dislike people who comment on an anime/manga before completing it, hence the reason why I won't comment on what you said about Bleach, I'm still at the part where Tatsuki meets Aizen.
OP doesn't revolve all around the treasure (much to Nami's dismay), just like Naruto doesn't revolve all around becoming the Hokage. What about Absalom trying to rape Nami? What about the government corruption? The anihilation of Ohara? Human slavery?
And answer me: if it's so childish, why was it censored so much in the US? Please.
Haruno Hyuuga Yamanaka
Member
I'm not because I'm a woman ^.^
And I'm still having an argument here with you. Leaving just proves how right I am.
LeafSpirit 20
Active member
oh man,lol.. Ill just pay attention to Haruno Hyuuga Yamanaka as youre the one with a valid argument and the one that is making more sense.. You know when an anime is childish because as a kid, it was very high in your standards, and now as youre older you realize from a different perspective that a lot of the things that seemed exciting when you where 13, now they just arent.. And im not talking about all anime, I can still view with the same eyes and excitement anime like dragonball z and saint seya, anime that when i was a kid where really exciting, and up to this day even after rewatching the series a couple of times you are still amazed as you were as a kid. And I did watch/ read one piece, and I was almost forcing myself to enjoy this, but you just cant force yourself to enjoy an anime/manga. And to the people that say i dont know anything about one piece, I know that luffy is made out of rubber as he ate the forbidden fruit,and cant swim because of it, I know he got a squad consisting of zolo, the chef, and naomi, then later usopp, who is now fat, then defeated buggy the clown, and I know luffy reunited with his brother ace, who is not his borther by blood, and the war broke out, whitebeard in the end wass defeated after putting a hell of a fight against the marines, and now blackbeard has gotten overpowered and luffy got traumatized by his brothers death, is now on an island triying to recuperate. And I didnt just look all of this up, if you dont want to bealive me , its up to you
Last edited:
Jack Spicer
Active member
Awards
Forget this bickering.
Gary Oak is slowly taking over all stupid threads and/or threads regarding to said threads. Gary oak says that on Naruto base you shouldn't compare manga, no matter how different or similar they are. It always results in arguments, and let's face it, One Piece fans destroy Naruto fans. We all like different manga. Everyone respect it, yes even respect those who don't deserve it, because we all have different tastes.
Now....GTFO.
You must be registered for see images
You must be registered for see images
Gary Oak is slowly taking over all stupid threads and/or threads regarding to said threads. Gary oak says that on Naruto base you shouldn't compare manga, no matter how different or similar they are. It always results in arguments, and let's face it, One Piece fans destroy Naruto fans. We all like different manga. Everyone respect it, yes even respect those who don't deserve it, because we all have different tastes.
Now....GTFO.
Haruno Hyuuga Yamanaka
Member
First, put a spoiler tag around that, please.
Second, I know you either looked it up or knew only this data because:
1) Their names are Zoro (not zolo) and Nami (not Naomi). Anyone who watched OP up to the war knows that clearly.
2) Usopp doesn't come later than the chef, and Buggy the clown was defeated way before meating up with these two.
3) War didn't break when Ace and Luffy met again, since this was in Arabasta, as you may or may not know.
4) The crew consists on more than the five members who entered Grand Line (captain, swordsman, sniper, chef, navigator; in order of joinage). There are members you're missing. If you had watched the whole thing, I'm sure you wouldn't forget about some characters so easily...
But oh well, I don't believe you but if you don't want to keep watching it it's up to you. It's not like I'm forcing you to watch it or read it. I'm trying to force you not to call it childish, which it isn't.
Define childish. Because I don't think rape, murder, suicide, trauma, human slavery, murdering 10 year olds on-screen, racism and stuff like that classifies as childish.
The very reason why 4!kids heavily censored the series was because it wasn't childish. They got the rights to OP together with other animes, but it wasn't on their plans. Due to lack of shows to air, they gave OP a shot. They didn't notice it's not intended to the child public 4!Kids aims towards, and they began censoring it like mad until they finally quitted (can't remember if after Arabasta or after Skypiea though) and Funimation took over, trying to make up for the mistakes by starting all over again.