[Predictions] One Piece Manga Chapter 1056 Discussion and 1057 Predictions

[Caliburn]

You must be registered for see images

"Cross Guild"

One Piece Manga Chapter 1056 Discussion and 1057 Predictions

Discuss One Piece Manga 1056 here and predict the next chapter, One Piece Manga 1057

BEGIN READING ONE PIECE NOW!!

Please remember to rate this week's chapter!
1 is worst, 5 is best.​

 

[WhistleBlower]

Alright, leaving an island chapter.

I assume that the man with burned scar is an ex-Roger crew member, otherwise why would he know anything about the one piece? And if I'm right about it, then there are two candidates: Scopper Gaban and Crocus. Crocus is too obvious, plus he's not important in the grand scheme of things, so I assume that it's Scopper Gaban since Oda has to at least show us him once. Plus, we already saw him drinking with Crocus in the cover page, there's no point in Oda showing us Scopper Gaban drinking with Crocus if he's not gonna appear in the story.

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Considering the fact that Scopper Gaban uses axes as his weapons, then there's a mild possibility that the strowhats might meet him in Elbaf with another Roger crew member who looks like a giant.

You must be registered for see images

Wouldn't be surprised if the giant from Roger's crew invited Scopper to Elbaf where he lives right now.

 

[Love Cook]

Yessss Sir Crocodile is back ! So happy, called it in last weeks discussion too. I willed it into existence.

Please I hope the OG voice actor is still able to voice him, he's 70 but still active now. He voiced Momo's granddad.

I do wonder what kind of construction the Cross Guild is. Both Warlords don't seem the type to follow someone, especially someone like Buggy.

Can't wait for the Impel Down reunion with Jinbei and Luffy.

 

[chopstickchakra]

What do you guys think odds are Yama actually joins SH's?

Luffy and co. are on the ship and ready to leave yet Yama wasn't asked to join.

Her phrasing also doesn't outright say I'm going to sea with Luffy it's more ambiguous-ly phrased as I'm gonna tell them I'm gonna live as Oden.

What do you guys think? She joining or staying for the day Pluton needs to be unleashed?

 

[Love Cook]

What do you guys think odds are Yama actually joins SH's?

Luffy and co. are on the ship and ready to leave yet Yama wasn't asked to join.

Her phrasing also doesn't outright say I'm going to sea with Luffy it's more ambiguous-ly phrased as I'm gonna tell them I'm gonna live as Oden.

What do you guys think? She joining or staying for the day Pluton needs to be unleashed?

Before this chapter it was 99%
After this chapter it is 100%

I have no idea how you can interpret that last panel any different. Her staying on Wano goes against everything her and Oden's character stand for.

There is a little skip in time where all the supernova's packed up and said goodbye to everyone but Momo. We might get a little flashback with Luffy and Yamato later on when she get's her dedicated chapter next. "The eleventh member"

I'm more curious to what happened to the two yonkou that haven't been addressed. Did someone slap some seastone cuffs on them ? Are they in jail ? The navy can't be trusted with them, they might set em free. The left two craters behind that could open up Wano earlier than Momo wants to, might play a part in releasing Pluton.

 

[chopstickchakra]

Before this chapter it was 99%
After this chapter it is 100%

I have no idea how you can interpret that last panel any different. Her staying on Wano goes against everything her and Oden's character stand for.

There is a little skip in time where all the supernova's packed up and said goodbye to everyone but Momo. We might get a little flashback with Luffy and Yamato later on when she get's her dedicated chapter next. "The eleventh member"

I'm more curious to what happened to the two yonkou that haven't been addressed. Did someone slap some seastone cuffs on them ? Are they in jail ? The navy can't be trusted with them, they might set em free. The left two craters behind that could open up Wano earlier than Momo wants to, might play a part in releasing Pluton.

Because of the word choice. Oda could have just had her say "I'm going to join them" but instead said I'm going to tell them something. In my eyes her saying she wants to tell them something sort of implies she'll be telling them goodbye.

Does it really stand against everything Oden stood for? Oden already went on his adventure and in his final years his goal was to get Wano ready to support "Joyboy" when the walls needed to be destroyed.
If Yamato truly believes she's Oden reincarnate shouldn't she be focused on carrying out his will from where he left it behind not recreating his old adventures for her own sense of adventure?

Oden's purpose when he died was preparing Wano, if she wants to live like Oden it would seem leaving Wano now would go against what Oden was working towards in his final years. That's just how I see it and I could be wrong none of this might matter to Oda but, if she wants to join it'll have to be as her own person or if she wants to be Oden she needs to fulfill his desires otherwise she's not Oden(I mean we know she's not but for sake of the argument)

I agree with you about the Yonko and possibly causing the collapse of the walls. I saw someone make a fan overlay of the tunnels and the staircase to the secret chamber and they're close. I don't think the Navy got them yet, I believe Green Bull was the only Marine who set foot on Wano, at least that's the implication I got. At the same time they shouldn't be KO'd still and I'd be a little shocked if they killed two Emperor's at the same time especially arguably the 2 hardest ones to kill.

Another fun thing from this chapter that seems to be getting overlooked is Buggy putting out bounties on the Marines. Such a boss move.

I wanna see the bounties they put on people. Wonder where Garp and the Admirals fall?

 

[WhistleBlower]

Before this chapter it was 99%
After this chapter it is 100%

I have no idea how you can interpret that last panel any different. Her staying on Wano goes against everything her and Oden's character stand for.

There is a little skip in time where all the supernova's packed up and said goodbye to everyone but Momo. We might get a little flashback with Luffy and Yamato later on when she get's her dedicated chapter next. "The eleventh member"

I'm more curious to what happened to the two yonkou that haven't been addressed. Did someone slap some seastone cuffs on them ? Are they in jail ? The navy can't be trusted with them, they might set em free. The left two craters behind that could open up Wano earlier than Momo wants to, might play a part in releasing Pluton.

I reckon Oda is saving for what happened to kaidou and big mom till AFTER all the pirates LEAVE wano

 

[Caliburn]

I reckon Oda is saving for what happened to kaidou and big mom till AFTER all the pirates LEAVE wano

It seems I'm a minority on this, but I simply think that they are indeed dead.

Oda doesn't like killing off characters, whether they are good or bad, and I think almost all of the antagonists Luffy fought, eventually survived despite the fact that it were pretty much all life or death battles. The problem here is that BM and Kaidou are really not the kind of existences you can just let go afterwards; just beating them once is really not enough.

So, the whole falling into a magma chamber feels kind of like a deus ex machina as it allows Oda to get rid of two rather problematic characters without having to turn Luffy into an actual killer.

 

[Skull Knight]

It seems I'm a minority on this, but I simply think that they are indeed dead.

Oda doesn't like killing off characters, whether they are good or bad, and I think almost all of the antagonists Luffy fought, eventually survived despite the fact that it were pretty much all life or death battles. The problem here is that BM and Kaidou are really not the kind of existences you can just let go afterwards; just beating them once is really not enough.

So, the whole falling into a magma chamber feels kind of like a deus ex machina as it allows Oda to get rid of two rather problematic characters without having to turn Luffy into an actual killer.

Does DF ability works after the user is dead?
If BM is dead then how come Zeus is still alive?

Post automatically merged: Aug 17, 2022

I wanna see the bounties they put on people. Wonder where Garp and the Admirals fall?

Garp is retired. Why will he put a bounty on his head?

Post automatically merged: Aug 17, 2022

What do you guys think odds are Yama actually joins SH's?

Luffy and co. are on the ship and ready to leave yet Yama wasn't asked to join.

Her phrasing also doesn't outright say I'm going to sea with Luffy it's more ambiguous-ly phrased as I'm gonna tell them I'm gonna live as Oden.

What do you guys think? She joining or staying for the day Pluton needs to be unleashed?

She's not joining. Reason being;
1)She needs to protect Wano from threats lyk Ryokugyu n other pirates(her DF is called Guardian of Wano).
2)She doesn't fit in SHs. Even when she calls herself Oden she isn't useful lyk Oden was for Roger.

And oda already confirmed that we are now in last leg of the journey. OP will prolly finish in next 3-5yrs. I doubt he will add any new characters for the last leg of the journey.

 

[chopstickchakra]

Does DF ability works after the user is dead?
If BM is dead then how come Zeus is still alive?

Post automatically merged: Aug 17, 2022

Garp is retired. Why will he put a bounty on his head?

Post automatically merged: Aug 17, 2022

She's not joining. Reason being;
1)She needs to protect Wano from threats lyk Ryokugyu n other pirates(her DF is called Guardian of Wano).
2)She doesn't fit in SHs. Even when she calls herself Oden she isn't useful lyk Oden was for Roger.

And oda already confirmed that we are now in last leg of the journey. OP will prolly finish in next 3-5yrs. I doubt he will add any new characters for the last leg of the journey.

Garp's not really retired he's just mostly inactive, he was at the reverie as a Marine escort after all.

I knew she wasn't going to be joining for those exact reasons. I don't dislike Yama but she adds no depth to the crew so it was weird seeing people fight so hard for her to join.

 

[Skull Knight]

Garp's not really retired he's just mostly inactive, he was at the reverie as a Marine escort after all.

Garp wanted to resign after the war.

You must be registered to see images

Kong let him keep his rank for the purpose of Military Training similar to Sengoku.

Correct me if I m wrong but Garp only escorted royalty till the lift part. If i remember correctly he didn't went to Mariejois.

I knew she wasn't going to be joining for those exact reasons. I don't dislike Yama but she adds no depth to the crew so it was weird seeing people fight so hard for her to join.

To be honest i have seen good amount of hate for Yamato in various discussion. I believe it's partly bcus of the fans arguing that SHs need strong individuals and partly how she address herself as "He" not "She".
For me Yamato was a very confusing character. Her ambition, nature, character nothing matches with Oden yet she kept saying same nonsense even after the raid was over.
Just waiting for the next chapter to drop and see how the "Yamato is 100% confirmed SH" going to play

 

[Caliburn]

Does DF ability works after the user is dead?
If BM is dead then how come Zeus is still alive?

Post automatically merged: Aug 17, 2022

Garp is retired. Why will he put a bounty on his head?

Post automatically merged: Aug 17, 2022

She's not joining. Reason being;
1)She needs to protect Wano from threats lyk Ryokugyu n other pirates(her DF is called Guardian of Wano).
2)She doesn't fit in SHs. Even when she calls herself Oden she isn't useful lyk Oden was for Roger.

And oda already confirmed that we are now in last leg of the journey. OP will prolly finish in next 3-5yrs. I doubt he will add any new characters for the last leg of the journey.

BM made thousands of homies. Whether they all will disappear is rather questionable. I mean do all the people who lost parts of their lifespan suddenly receive it back? On top of that Zeus was already a special case as he somehow got attached to Nami's clima tact. So, Zeus still being alive honestly doesn't say anything about BM's current condition.

We recently had a chapter that torpedoed this whole Guardian of Wano idea. Momo was sick that everyone always have to protect him and then Yamato is going to do exactly that? What's more Luffy left his flag there, which means that everyone who attacks Wano, also declares war on the Strawhats. There is simply no need for a Wano Guardian. The fact that she told Green Bull that she's Kaidou's kid, isn't a good sign either. I really wouldn't be surprised if she's going to receive a bounty.

And from a narrative point of view it makes even less sense. Yamato was a very prominent figure during this arc whose sole motivation was Oden Kozuki. It would completely invalidate her entire character if she would just stay put and do the exact opposite of what her driving force was. She's doing what she said she was going to do: following in Oden's footsteps, which inevitably means leaving Wano. I can't say whether she's going to become an actual Strawhat, but there's little doubt she's going to join with them at one point. You also seem to forget she is in the possession of the only known record that documented Roger's final voyage.

 

[chopstickchakra]

BM made thousands of homies. Whether they all will disappear is rather questionable. I mean do all the people who lost parts of their lifespan suddenly receive it back? On top of that Zeus was already a special case as he somehow got attached to Nami's clima tact. So, Zeus still being alive honestly doesn't say anything about BM's current condition.

We recently had a chapter that torpedoed this whole Guardian of Wano idea. Momo was sick that everyone always have to protect him and then Yamato is going to do exactly that? What's more Luffy left his flag there, which means that everyone who attacks Wano, also declares war on the Strawhats. There is simply no need for a Wano Guardian. The fact that she told Green Bull that she's Kaidou's kid, isn't a good sign either. I really wouldn't be surprised if she's going to receive a bounty.

And from a narrative point of view it makes even less sense. Yamato was a very prominent figure during this arc whose sole motivation was Oden Kozuki. It would completely invalidate her entire character if she would just stay put and do the exact opposite of what her driving force was. She's doing what she said she was going to do: following in Oden's footsteps, which inevitably means leaving Wano. I can't say whether she's going to become an actual Strawhat, but there's little doubt she's going to join with them at one point. You also seem to forget she is in the possession of the only known record that documented Roger's final voyage.

Momo being sick of needing defending doesn't change the fact that currently he still does.l though. Wano needs to rebuild it's strength right now and in order to be able to do that it needs to be able to be defended well.

The SH flag works as a great deterrent for most but for those it won't, say for instance marines, they need enough strong people there at the time of any incident because SH's have to make their way back.

Honestly her believing she's Oden but wanting to relive his experiences always seemed odd to me. Shouldn't she have wanted to pick up his life where he left it if she believed she was him? So shouldn't her goals have been opening the borders and preparing Wano to support Joyboy? Which is likely what she'll end up doing by staying there now.

Just curious what importance you see in Roger's journal to the SH's? We know key parts about Laugh Tale were ripped out and destroyed or lost and on top of that Luffy wouldn't want the information.

 

[Skull Knight]

BM made thousands of homies. Whether they all will disappear is rather questionable. I mean do all the people who lost parts of their lifespan suddenly receive it back? On top of that Zeus was already a special case as he somehow got attached to Nami's clima tact. So, Zeus still being alive honestly doesn't say anything about BM's current condition.

If DF ability works after the user is dead then Pandora should be alive n should have told what happened after Elbaf unless BM ate a ball of fire

I believe these 2Yonkos reign ended but there's something about BM that feels incomplete. Like she deserved to know what happened with Caramel and the orphans. She also got Soul transfer ability from where she can sukk the life Outta Kaido to heal herself. I do believe Kaido is dead as he wants to at the beginning of the arc but BM i m not sure.

We recently had a chapter that torpedoed this whole Guardian of Wano idea. Momo was sick that everyone always have to protect him and then Yamato is going to do exactly that? What's more Luffy left his flag there, which means that everyone who attacks Wano, also declares war on the Strawhats. There is simply no need for a Wano Guardian. The fact that she told Green Bull that she's Kaidou's kid, isn't a good sign either. I really wouldn't be surprised if she's going to receive a bounty.

And from a narrative point of view it makes even less sense. Yamato was a very prominent figure during this arc whose sole motivation was Oden Kozuki. It would completely invalidate her entire character if she would just stay put and do the exact opposite of what her driving force was. She's doing what she said she was going to do: following in Oden's footsteps, which inevitably means leaving Wano. I can't say whether she's going to become an actual Strawhat, but there's little doubt she's going to join with them at one point. You also seem to forget she is in the possession of the only known record that documented Roger's final voyage.

Why will she get a bounty? She has done nothing so far than boink-ing Ryokugyu who wanna start a genocide in Wano.
Luffy got a bounty when he take out Arlong(if i m not wrong). In Yamato's case he has never left Wano n won't leave till EOSS.
Her DF is meant for Wano's guardian and she should remain in Wano to protect it from threats lyk other Yonkos and Admiral coming for Pluton as Momo isn't a strong leader yet.