[Discussion] Old Garp Vs Old Rayleigh

-Akuma-

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
5,277
Kin
958💸
Kumi
9💴
Trait Points
65⚔️
You guys amuse me Lol. First @Zhoom is saying Smoker can beat Zoro mid diff yet I am the one that is not thinking clearly are you sure you are alright in the head mate? XD. And @TheHokage please explain to me what is so illogical about Zoro beating Smoker high diff? please elaborate how smoker outclasses Zoro in everyway that it is so illogical Zoro could beat him high diff and don't give me that pirate & marine rival bullshit???
Smoker has superior feats and portysl and if you read my post it says med-high meaning it would be on the higher of meg dif damn near border lining high dif......Take off Zoro's bandana and stop D riding.
 

Zorø

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Oct 24, 2012
Messages
11,729
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Smoker has superior feats and portysl and if you read my post it says med-high meaning it would be on the higher of meg dif damn near border lining high dif......Take off Zoro's bandana and stop D riding.
The funny thing is Zoro hasn't even went all out yet and when he does all hell is gonna break loose in the OP section y'all haters will be quiet Lol. Name a feat that Smoker has done post time skip that is way more impressive than 1080p cannon???
 

TheHokage

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jul 10, 2011
Messages
3,014
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
You guys amuse me Lol. First @Zhoom is saying Smoker can beat Zoro mid diff yet I am the one that is not thinking clearly are you sure you are alright in the head mate? XD. And @TheHokage please explain to me what is so illogical about Zoro beating Smoker high diff? please elaborate how smoker outclasses Zoro in everyway that it is so illogical Zoro could beat him high diff and don't give me that pirate & marine rival bullshit???
Well for one Zoro has no feats that put him over Smoker...

Also why can't the whole marine rival thing be used it's called portrayal same way how you Zoro fanboys put Zoro as Vice captain of the crew because he's the second strongest or how Luffy is the strongest because he's the captain you can't just pick and choose when this rule applies because it disfavors your favorite character...of course portrayal isn't everything however Smoker has shown greater CoA than Zoro and greater speed than Zoro this is fact.

Common sense: Smoker is stronger than Zoro otherwise what would be the point in having Oda make him chase after the head of the Strawhat crew and he could beat Zoro with high/extreme difficulty and would probably lose the same difficulty to Luffy.

Zoro fanboy sense: Derp Zoro High diffs Smoker because he's Zoro and he's beaten fodder he hasn't lost post time skip his feats are far more impressive.

The funny thing is Zoro hasn't even went all out yet and when he does all hell is gonna break loose in the OP section y'all haters will be quiet . Name a feat that Smoker has done post time skip that is way more impressive than 1080p cannon???
You confuse destructive capability for overall strength...that's why your argument is ridiculous. If that's the case Whitebeard far outclasses Roger and Garp in strength. Enel also had a far more destructive capability than the majority of the characters stronger than him would you base his strength purely on his destructive capability?.

Zoro's 1080 cannon didn't even win him the fight.
 
Last edited:

Bogard

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
21,914
Kin
8💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Everytime someone tells me Smoker has superior feats it makes me Lol. And no i'm not even talking about the difference in their opponents here or how much better Zoro was handled comparatively to Smoker since the timeskip, but the actual feats in terms of actual physical stats/abilities showed since then. What does Smoker have besides his punches? He possess arguably the weakest logia devil fruit whose only advantage is giving Smoker the ability to fly and great manoeuvrability. Became even more useless since the apparition of haki, making his smoke body expansion actually a weakness against AOE attacks. So a Smoker only having his punches and great manoeuvrability versus a powerhouse and armament specialist with great reflexive/striking speed, much greater fire power and mainly durability/endurance beast like Zoro. Assuming he somehow even gets the upperhand, what would do to defeat him? Punch him to death? Zoro on the other side has too many options to finish off Smoker. I don't see how Smoker has any chance featwise, let alone being put at such a higher pedestal to be capable to win after a moderate difficulty fight. Hype/portrayal-wise is the only debatable thing and judging by the current hype/portrayal, i'd bet on Zoro over Smoker any day

That said i'm out of this thread before this one becomes once again another Zoro boring discussion thread. You guys seem to like doing this very often. Remain on topic at least
 

Hexuze

Active member
Supreme
Joined
May 19, 2011
Messages
20,359
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
You guys amuse me Lol. First @Zhoom is saying Smoker can beat Zoro mid diff yet I am the one that is not thinking clearly are you sure you are alright in the head mate? XD. And @TheHokage please explain to me what is so illogical about Zoro beating Smoker high diff? please elaborate how smoker outclasses Zoro in everyway that it is so illogical Zoro could beat him high diff and don't give me that pirate & marine rival bullshit???
What feats has Zoro displayed post-TS to put him above Smoker? At least Smoker pulled off some impressive feats, like harming Vergo a lot more than Law (before the one shot) & Sanji did. The marine rival stuff isn't BS. You and I both know how much emphasis Oda loves to place on his writing, Oda established a rivalry between Luffy & Smoker ever since loguetown and I don't see it miraculously changing over a couple of beatings at PH. People love to discredit Smoker during his fight with Vergo because of how "easily" he lost due to a "disadvantage", when little do they know that Smoker wanted to retrieve Law's heart. Ofc Smoker would of still lost to Vergo.

Luffy pretty much told Smoker, I'll face you again once you get your body back (this was when he was in Tashigi's body). This implies that the rivalry is still there and they're pretty much still close to being equals. If Zoro can high-diff. him, what would that mean for someone like Luffy? A mid-diff. fight? That would be stupid... so Oda created a rivalry between Luffy and Smoker only to have him get mid-diff'd?
 
Last edited:

TheHokage

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jul 10, 2011
Messages
3,014
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
What feats has Zoro displayed post-TS to put him above Smoker? At least Smoker pulled off some impressive feats, like harming Vergo a lot more than Law (before the one shot) & Sanji did. The marine rival stuff isn't BS. You and I both know how much emphasis Oda loves to place on his writing, Oda established a rivalry between Luffy & Smoker ever since loguetown and I don't see it miraculously changing over a couple of beatings at PH. People love to discredit Smoker during his fight with Vergo because of how "easily" he lost due to a "disadvantage", when little do they know that Smoker wanted to retrieve Law's heart.

Luffy pretty much told Smoker, I'll face you again once you get your body back (this was when he was in Tashigi's body). This implies that the rivalry is still there and they're pretty much still close to being equals. If Zoro can high-diff. him, what would that mean for someone like Luffy? A mid-diff. fight? That would be stupid... so Oda created a rivalry between Luffy and Smoker only to have him get mid-diff'd?
It's pointless man...

TBogard, Zoro, and Aqueel are the biggest Zoro fanboys on this forum they refuse to believe that Zoro is weaker than Smoker and refuse to believe Sanji is almost relatively equal to Zoro. TBogard believes Zoro is close to Law in strength as well.

Bold: This is common sense and logic something Zoro fanboys refuse to acknowledge.
 
Last edited:

Zorø

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Oct 24, 2012
Messages
11,729
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
What feats has Zoro displayed post-TS to put him above Smoker? At least Smoker pulled off some impressive feats, like harming Vergo a lot more than Law (before the one shot) & Sanji did. The marine rival stuff isn't BS. You and I both know how much emphasis Oda loves to place on his writing, Oda established a rivalry between Luffy & Smoker ever since loguetown and I don't see it miraculously changing over a couple of beatings at PH. People love to discredit Smoker during his fight with Vergo because of how "easily" he lost due to a "disadvantage", when little do they know that Smoker wanted to retrieve Law's heart.

Luffy pretty much told Smoker, I'll face you again once you get your body back (this was when he was in Tashigi's body). This implies that the rivalry is still there and they're pretty much still close to being equals.
Plot twist Coby was Luffy's marine rival all along Lol. Ok jokes aside maybe the Portrayal thing isn't complete Bs and maybe Smoker has shown more haki feats and speed feats than Zoro but the main fact here is Zoro hasn't gone all out yet. I rest my case U_U.
 

Zorø

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Oct 24, 2012
Messages
11,729
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
It's pointless man...

TBogard, Zoro, and Aqueel are the biggest Zoro fanboys on this forum they refuse to believe that Zoro is weaker than Smoker and refuse to believe Sanji is almost relatively equal to Zoro. TBogard believes Zoro is close to Law in strength as well.

Bold: This is common sense and logic something Zoro fanboys refuse to acknowledge.
So I am a zoro fanboy for saying he can beat smoker high diff? Lol. and you are the one who refuse to acknowledge that smoker isn't all that his feats are not even that impressive to put him above Zoro. Luffy outclasses him and Zoro and Luffy are close in strength if anything Zoro is more of a rival to Luffy than Smoker.
 

-Akuma-

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
5,277
Kin
958💸
Kumi
9💴
Trait Points
65⚔️
The funny thing is Zoro hasn't even went all out yet and when he does all hell is gonna break loose in the OP section y'all haters will be quiet Lol. Name a feat that Smoker has done post time skip that is way more impressive than 1080p cannon???
Going Toe to teo with Vergo and Law si better than cutting up some of Pica.....Lemme guess Kaku is stronger than Smoker because he's displayed more DC than Smoker now right :vision:
 

Bogard

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
21,914
Kin
8💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
So I am a zoro fanboy for saying he can beat smoker high diff? Lol. and you are the one who refuse to acknowledge that smoker isn't all that his feats are not even that impressive to put him above Zoro. Luffy outclasses him and Zoro and Luffy are close in strength if anything Zoro is more of a rival to Luffy than Smoker.
Hey dude, Zoro too badass. Me not like. Zoro not allowed to have fans. You're not allowed to think Zoro can win a fight. If Zoro can win a fight, then you're a fanboy. Thinking someone who didn't even remotely go all out can defeat someone else who spent his time getting humiliated is really ridiculous. Just stop stupid wanker
 

Zorø

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Oct 24, 2012
Messages
11,729
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Going Toe to teo with Vergo and Law si better than cutting up some of Pica.....Lemme guess Kaku is stronger than Smoker because he's displayed more DC than Smoker now right :vision:
You forgot to mention the part where he got neg diffed by both vergo and Law something which wouldnt have happened to a beast like Zoro U_U. Only person I admit he would lose to is Law U_U.
 

Bogard

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
21,914
Kin
8💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
You forgot to mention the part where he got neg diffed by both vergo and Law something which wouldnt have happened to a beast like Zoro U_U. Only person I admit he would lose to is Law U_U.
I actually think Zoro can defeat Law with low difficulty U_U
 

-Akuma-

Active member
Elite
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
5,277
Kin
958💸
Kumi
9💴
Trait Points
65⚔️
You forgot to mention the part where he got neg diffed by both vergo and Law something which wouldnt have happened to a beast like Zoro U_U. Only person I admit he would lose to is Law U_U.
If you think he got neg diffed by both......There is no hope for the Zoro fanbase.
 

Zorø

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Oct 24, 2012
Messages
11,729
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I actually think Zoro can defeat Law with low difficulty U_U
Bruh obviously Zoro is a better swordsman naturally but Law's ability is too haxxed man once that room is activated Zoro is doomed U_U. I say Law would win against Zoro mid/high diff depending if Zoro has intel or not U_U.
 

Bogard

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
21,914
Kin
8💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I belive Garp is stronger since he fought Roger and nearly killed him...also why is Zoro's name being tossed around here? Lel
Because Zoro isn't allowed to have fans, not allowed win fights, so even in discussions where his name is not involve, let us involve him to insult his fanbase and the character everytime we can

Bruh obviously Zoro is a better swordsman naturally but Law's ability is too haxxed man once that room is activated Zoro is doomed U_U. I say Law would win against Zoro mid/high diff depending if Zoro has intel or not U_U.
It was obviously not a serious post, but i think you're overhyping Law and his hax. It has huge limits
 

Hexuze

Active member
Supreme
Joined
May 19, 2011
Messages
20,359
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Plot twist Coby was Luffy's marine rival all along Lol. Ok jokes aside maybe the Portrayal thing isn't complete Bs and maybe Smoker has shown more haki feats and speed feats than Zoro but the main fact here is Zoro hasn't gone all out yet. I rest my case U_U.
Yeah... like we've seen all of Smoker's capabilities with his DF over a 2 year TS. We saw nothing new as well.
I belive Garp is stronger since he fought Roger and nearly killed him...also why is Zoro's name being tossed around here? Lel
Why does your gender say female, when you're actually a guy?
Lel
 

Zorø

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Oct 24, 2012
Messages
11,729
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Yeah... like we've seen all of Smoker's capabilities with his DF over a 2 year TS. We saw nothing new as well
If Smoker had any more techniques why didnt he use it in his fight with Law,Vergo or Doflamingo instead of being humiliated on PH....Imo Smoker needs to train more he is lackin mate U_U.
 
Top