[Theory] [Official]The Giant Tobi Discussion/Theory Thread

Who is the man behind the mask


  • Total voters
    386
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Cyborg

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jan 13, 2011
Messages
1,767
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Re: Tobi is Fugaku (Sasuke and Itachis father)

Minato soul was sealed but yet a remnant of it was in Narutos conscious. Kushina died but a part of her was also in Narutos mind.

If Minato can seal part of his conscious in Narutos mind than it's not impossible for Madara to have sealed his own into the body of another. Tobi has knowledge that nobody but Madara would have had. Fugaku would not have recalled accounts of sage of 6, history of the clan, kyuubi attack, Uchiha conspiracy and personal feelings towards the 1st.

Tobi said that he hate the 1st an respected him more than anyone. Who else but Madara would say that?

You have a point with the Uchiha curse and Uchiha are after power but it's a stretch to say Fugaku would have gone to the lengths of killing his clan. Fugakus proved the Uchiha curse by planning a civil war. That is evident but him staging to be Madara and killing the clan he worked hard to plan to gain respect is a big stretch.

Edit- it just came to me. Another example to prove 2 souls of the same person can exist is the fact that Half of Mu soul was sealed and the other half is standing besides edo Madara.
Minato did seal part of himself in naruto, but as we all saw he was not allowed to be summoned with IWR.

Why would Tobi be scared of the sixth coffin if it was himself inside it? Obviously Tobi is not Madara, but he needs everyone to believe he is for his plan...that's the whole reason he was scared.

Your muu example is invalid. His other half is PHYSICALLY sealed inside sand and covered in tags.

We saw him trying to remove the tags and free his other half but he could not. Sealing something inside the death god is a totally different type of seal like Titania sword. Your not even in this world anymore.
1 you may not fully understand the points im making

or 2. you are just ignoring them.

nobody is saying minato jumped in or out of reaper god. i said that before being sealed in reaper god, minato sealed part of himself in naruto. madara could have done the same thing where he sealed himself in another body before dying to the 1st.

thats one very good possibility.

mu is not just a clone. and he didnt remove the seal on his other half. mu split himself into 2 identical beings. its not a shadow clone. so in other words basically 1 half of mu is sealed the other is besides edo madara.

madara could have somehow used the jutsu mu used to split himself before fighting or dying to the 1st (but obviously madara may have had to learn it from mu which is possible since onoiki claimed that he fought madara once. mu may have been in the fight also.)

thats possibilty 2. not very good but still possible.

the biggest and best possibility is inazagi. i dont think i should have to explain. madara fights 1st. during fight madara knows hes losing but gets hashirama cells during fight and use inazagi to make tobi madara.

now i can find possible reasons to there being a tobi madara and edo madara co existing but how do you explain fugaku being tobi?

you made a point that the uchiha curse makes uchihas power hungry but fugaku proved that by planning a civil war. from what has been shown fugaku loved his clan, nothing shown that he would be motivated to help kill them or kill his own wife.

nothing proves that zetsu was even present to fake fugakus death.

tobi throughout the manga has shown significant knowledge that nobody but madara would have. not fugaku. madara would have known about the sage because of having the ems and rinnegan. fugaku was never shown to have either.

when edo madara was revived he said something that resembled exactly what tobi said, that nagatos power was supposed to revive him. if madara said it and tobi said it its a good indicator that they are one of the same.

tobi talked about the history of the leaf and history of senju and uchiha. it is more probable that madara would have this knowledge, not fugaku. madara talked about hashirama and told naruto that he hated him and respected him more than anyone in the world. madara most likely would say that, not fugaku.

despite madara being revived by edo tensi all the evidence still points to tobi being madara. you said it yourself we are talking about a world where by making hand gestures a clothed man can become a naked lady. it is very possible for tobi to still be madara while madara is ressurected, especially when we have seen a ninja who is sealed in death reaper still appear in narutos conscious, a dead mother appear in her sons conscious and a ninja who can split himself.
@Naruto vs Goku: good points, but Fukaku(not Fugaku lol) does have a chance of being the masked Tobi. About your nobody having enough knowledge argument, well Tobi speaks of even the Sage of the 6 paths, his 2 sons and all that happened between them, which was waaaay before Madara's time......so even if Tobi=Madara, how does Madara even know all this? By having MS? Its just as likely that Fukaku activated it too by killing off a close relative and then read it off the uchiha tablets, which is what Madara would also have to do too.
But more importantly, Tobi has space time, and its not known if the original Madara did. Hashirama never used space time, but the 2nd and the 4th hokage's did. Any uchiha with sharingan can copy techniques perfectly, and can even work to improve them, but they have to see the tech in action first.
Madara did'nt have the opportunity to do that as probably no one in his time used time space nin techs. But Fukasaku probably grew up hearing of the exploits of the 2nd hokage and minato and might have seen them in action and copied their abilities and improved them, just like first Oro and then Kabuto copied the 2nd's IWR jutsu.
It might be a stretch, but then how do you explain Tobi having space time...?

@ BarBoBot: You're missing one very critical point. How does the real Madara now know of Nagato...?Nagato, who was a child of about age 6 or so during the 3rd great ninja war, when the 3rd was hokage and it had been ages since the valley of the end battle. Madara wore the same clothes as he did when he fought the 1st when he was ressurrected, so this leads to an inescapable conclusion:
Although it may very well be that Tobi and Madara are 2 distinct beings, they are almost certainly connected, and its possible they may have had some form of communication, perhaps like how Minato communicated with Naruto.
What do you 2 think?
 

Rami105

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Nov 2, 2010
Messages
4,908
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
SPOILER!!! who is behind the mask?

hello everyone,
there must me tons of these threads now but still i want to make 1:lili:

The person behind the mask is kagamy uchiha that's the guy who was in the team with the second hokage the future third hokage and danzo enz.

If you are thinking why would he be in it? well i made a similair thread like this one few month's back but let me explain once more!

Why would kishi put a uchiha in the group when danzo got a flash back that guy didn't had any lines! en you saw that he had a sharingan and he new alot about danzo! and if we learnd anything about naruto it's that if you something that doesnt click in the scene it will come back eventually and it will be explaind like the gift from itachi to naruto!

So it's pretty obvious that kagamy uchiha told every body he was madara because he wanted to be recognized by every body and how better to do that with the name that feared every body MADARA UCHIHA!

hope you guys liked it! Questions ? just ask me or the forum here below!:)
 
Last edited:
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
386
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Re: Why The F*** do people think that tobi is obito

To be honest, the only hole in the Obito theory is that it is not known if he has a brother to take an eye from and receive EMS and Tobi needs EMS to complete his plan. It is however possible That his intent originally was to provide Sauske with an EMS and obtain Shishui's eye that was in possession of Danzo to control him into doing the Mooneye Plan. At least until it was destroyed anyways. Otherwise it all makes sense.

the fact is:

Tobi's eye has the same ability as Kakashi's

Until he implanted a rinnengan his only visible eye was his right which would make sense sine Obito gave Kakashi his left

Tobi and Obito are almost anigrams

They have the same hair

Its possible the whole dying and having his eye crushed by a rock was a genjutsu to fake his on death

It is a very viable option despite its unpopularity when people mention the possibility. Its really the simplest answer as to who he really is and it fits. I don't want it to be the case because of its simplicity.

(possible spoiler)

I would much prefer tobi to be a creation from an Izangi prodoced by Madara himself. This would make sense since he could have instructed Tobi to give Nagato the Rinnengan and instruct him to revive Madara. This is why he would have pointed out Nagato's growth upon his resurrection and surprise that is was the world resurrection that brought him back
 
Last edited:

chike22trans

Member
Joined
Jun 4, 2011
Messages
16
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Re: The possibly connections of Kagami Uchiha.

you are kinda right but the fact here is that i have no clue who Kagami Uchiha is So please any link to the page on the manga where he was first seen?
 

Sliding Ghost

Member
Joined
Oct 13, 2011
Messages
60
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Re: Poll for the man behind the mask lets see if NB gets it right

I want to elaborate/refine on what I said earlier.

Suppose Madara was sealed the night he helped Itachi? We know that Nagato was sealed by Itachi. Madara mentions Nagato. Itachi seemed to know about Tobi Madara and he didn't want Sasuke to see him.

I'm willing to bet that the answer is in Itachi's words that he said to Sasuke when they had their final fight.
 

NamkazeNaruto

Banned
Regular
Joined
Nov 17, 2010
Messages
1,099
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Re: who is madara behind that mask?

You must be registered for see images


You must be registered for see images







NOTICE THE SIMILARITIES ?




ignore tobi in the background in the 1st pic
 

Tosen

Active member
Elite
Joined
Sep 13, 2011
Messages
8,903
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
If Tobi is Izuna

Why did he masquerade has Madara?, what benefit would he have by claiming to be Madara then his own. Am sure he was somewhat famous back in his day especially since he was said to be equal to Madara in every way
 

'Kurapika

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Feb 27, 2011
Messages
10,266
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Re: If Tobi is Izuna

he wanted to restore his brothers pride by making everyone think that he didn't really lose to the first
and that's why he was really touched when he said that madara didn't take izuna's eyes by force
i assume the only two people that would be that touched are madara and izuna
 

Tosen

Active member
Elite
Joined
Sep 13, 2011
Messages
8,903
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Re: If Tobi is Izuna

he wanted to restore his brothers pride by making everyone think that he didn't really lose to the first
and that's why he was really touched when he said that madara didn't take izuna's eyes by force
i assume the only two people that would be that touched are madara and izuna
hahaha so Tobi is a good boy after all :D hahah but this makes sense since even evil brothers care baout each other.
 

'Kurapika

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Feb 27, 2011
Messages
10,266
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Re: If Tobi is Izuna

hahaha so Tobi is a good boy after all :D hahah but this makes sense since even evil brothers care baout each other.
i was really touched when tobi said , "no izuna gave me his eyes for the sake of the clan" it felt like he was really hurt by how they talked about madara U_U
 
  • Like
Reactions: Manzai
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top