[Theory] [Official]The Giant Tobi Discussion/Theory Thread

[Tartarus]

Re: 3 prime Tobi suspects

Please stop with the obito nonsense.Obito would have never been skilled enough to reach the heights of tobi in the time since he die during the 3th great shinobi war to the time he fought the 4th hokage.Obito wasn't even a shinobi of Kakashi level when he died.Are we suppose to believe that a lesser genin somehow got the 1st hokage dna, develop a s-rank S/T ninjutsu, came up with highly complex plan to rule the world, set that plan in motion, while manipulating a two hand full of powerful shinobis, running the hidden mist village,plotting revenge on the leaf village,developing a mangekyo sharingan and learning to control bijus.

Stop, just stop

as you can clearly see, this isn't a Tobito thread and I didn't even say that. There are two other characters whom Tobi could be, unless you came here to deduce Tobi's identity, don't come on this thread.

 

[Gaarafan12]

Re: 3 prime Tobi suspects

I guess I must have missed/forgotten the episode where we are introduced to Kagami. I need to find out more about him!! So many questions, I think we all suspected it was Madara, but didn't expect it if that makes sense now we have so many more questions!! lol I love it

 

[brymeister]

Re: Whos the guy with the mask?

what i thnik is tobi is not madara because it contradicts how impure world resurrection works

 

[Awesome Face]

Re: 3 prime Tobi suspects

lol r u have ther mugshots

 

[Kisaragi]

Re: Whos the guy with the mask?

hmm....ughh same thread as the other. :\

 

[laxus]

Re: The Ultimate proof that Tobi is indeed Madara

yea knew that tobi wasn't really the full madara you may be right if tobi can be an essence of madara because he has fooled people with his face so he can be like a zetsu clone that took personality and everything from madara to his chakra nature so you may be right as tobi being madara in a way so you may not be wrong.

 

[Manzai]

Re: As I Said (Yes I know who Tobi Is)

so in your theory your saying tobi has shisui's body but is not shisui? so who is he?

 

[zombiejesus]

Re: Poll for the man behind the mask lets see if NB gets it right

sage of six path

 

[Sarutobi Sasuke]

Re: Tobi is a Zetsu Clone

A regular Shadow Clone has the memories of the person they are a clone of. & if Madara did make a Zetsu clone of himself he would have made sure he remembered what happened before. So that he would continue his plans.

& I never said Tobi's Sharingan was a copy he could have easily of had Madara's Sharingans transplanted . Madara's Soul wasn't transferred because he wouldn't be able to be Summoned by Kabuto. But he does have his memories & his will.


& I just thought of a way that a Zetsu clone of Madara could have his memories is he put a part of him in the clone like the 4ht did with himself & Kushina when he sealed himself in Naruto

White Zetsu has always seemed quite uninformed with...well...everyting. I dont know about Black zetsu but I dont think white Zetsu would have inherited any knowledge from the real Madara. That is one reason why I doubt that Madara is a White Zetsu clone. He might be a completely different Zetsu. Like a Grey Zetsu, for example.

 

[sakhee]

Re: if tobi is not madara after all then why bother pretending to be madara?

I had to Lol at all the idiots who thought Tobi was Madara just because he said he was.
And congrats to those who refused to call Tobi Madara, but by the name 'Tobi'.
At last the obvious has been revealed!

 

[eyesofthekyuubi44]

Interesting point about Tobi and Madara.

When Madara blew his coffin out, which was badass, he said, "So it finally happened. It would appear that brat Nagato managed to grow".

You must be registered for see links

As seen on that page.

BUT, about two years ago, when we were reading Tobi (I will try my best to refer to "Madara" as Tobi until this matter is cleared up), we saw that he said...

You must be registered for see links

He said that Edo Rinne Tensei was supposed to be used "for him".

If Tobi IS Madara, and by some stupid reason Kishimoto decided to have Kabuto revive a "past" Madara, then that would make sense.

The fact that the Madara that appeared out of the coffin and made a reference to Nagato states to me that Madara may have indeed, given Nagato the Rinnegan. If that is true, then Tobi may be some other incarnation of Madara. Remember, Madara is NOT made of skin and bones, but out of Zetsu like tissue.

If Tobi is NOT Madara, I haven't ruled out the countless possibilities as to who he could be. Uchiha Kagami being one, as he'd be older, experienced, and could have even been CLOSE to Madara at one point.

My question is, do you guys think that those two pages I linked are related to each other somehow? Some connection just popped in my head there. It seems as though Madara expected to be ressurected...

 

[PandaMan.]

Re: 3 prime Tobi suspects

out of those 3 kagami seems more likely, out of those 3

 

[JCW]

Re: Poll for the man behind the mask lets see if NB gets it right

HOLY SHIT LIKE WTF i was oooooo whattt

i say Uchiha Kagami

 

[Protozoid]

Re: Poll for the man behind the mask lets see if NB gets it right

Really obviously Izuna.

 

[Itachi2304]

Re: Poll for the man behind the mask lets see if NB gets it right

where did u get this picture from? was it said that uchiha izuna died? if so then how did they say he died?

Very unlikely.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

And again. Madara (long hair) was still alive when he met Kisame. That would explain why he knows Nagato.

 

[Manzai]

Re: Tobi is a Zetsu Clone

well it would kinda seem pointless plot wise if it would be a simple white zetsu clone because he would just turn to a tree if km naruto got near him. lol but he does have something to do with zetsu

 

[MaNnY17]

Re: Poll for the man behind the mask lets see if NB gets it right

Very unlikely.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

And again. Madara (long hair) was still alive when he met Kisame. That would explain why he knows Nagato.

well then where is izuna now??...why didn't kabuto just summon him too???

 

[~The Norwegian~]

Re: Interesting point about Tobi and Madara.

Yes, I do. I most certenly do. I said this earlier today btw... It's what I think is right.

Madara has two bodies (Tobi and Madara), and one mind.

Therefore Tobi said he was a "formser shell of myself", and not complete.

My god.... He was supposed to use moon eye, to get Kabuto to revive his body.... I see now, I see...

And he just acted that he didn't know Edo tensei...

 

[Gunther]

Re: 3 prime Tobi suspects

For me, there is a possibility that Tobi is something similar to Zetsu. Body with ability to regeneration, 1st dna and uchiha eyes(this could be implanted, why is he collecting so many eyes of uchiha members?! ), mask which show type of eyes, it's a little freaky for me(1st-sharingan and 2st-sharingan&rinnegan). On the other hand, it can be Izuna Uchiha. If Tobi is not Madara, he could lie about death of Izuna too. There is many options, I think that ressurected Madara will tell us something about Tobi's mystery.

 

[~WastelandSociety~]

Re: Interesting point about Tobi and Madara.

Well said.