[Discussion] Nothing wrong with this list IMO

OG sama

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Oct 26, 2014
Messages
3,220
Kin
347💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
All at their peaks:
1. Gol D. Roger
2. Edward Newgate
3. Monkey D. Dragon
4. Monkey D. Garp
5. Shiki
6. Sengoku
7. Dracule Mihawk/Silvers Rayleigh
8. Dracule Mihawk/Silvers Rayleigh
9. Kaidou/Shanks
10. Kaidou/Shanks
11. Sakazuki/Kong
12. Sakazuki/Kong
13. Kuzan
14. Issho
15. Big Mom (Charlotte Linlin)
16. Borsalino/Ben Beckmann
17. Borsalino/Ben Beckmann
18. Ryukugyu/Gabban
19. Ryukugyu/Gabban
20. Marco
21. Zephyr
22. Marshall D. Teach (soon to be a top 10)
23. Magellan
24. Shiliew
25. Sabo
26. Don Chinjao
27. Donquixote Doflamingo
28. Bartholomew Kuma
29. Jozu
30. Vista
31. Jesus Burgess
32. Boa Hancock
33. Momonga
34. Onigumo
35. Stainless
36. Strawberry
37. Comil
38. Yamakiji
39. Tsuru
40. Crocodile
41. Monkey D. Luffy
42. Eustass Kidd
43. Trafalgar D. Water Law
44. X Drake
45. Vergo
46. Roronoa Zoro/Smoker
47. Roronoa Zoro/Smoker
48. Scratchmen Apoo/Basil Hawkins/Sanji/Jinbe/Ace
49. Scratchmen Apoo/Basil Hawkins/Sanji/Jinbe/Ace
50. Scratchmen Apoo/Basil Hawkins/Sanji/Jinbe/Ace

You've forgotten about so many characters
This list seriously sucks. Like wtf, Crocodile above the SNs? And a bunch of fodder VAs in between Doflamingo and Croc? And Doflamingo many many numbers ahead of Law and Luffy?
 

24 12 11 to troll

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Dec 24, 2011
Messages
11,214
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Wtf how is this even an all at their peaks list?
Because Crocodiles peak was in MF, not fooking Alabasta

Doffy is obviously way above Law and Luffy

Doffy neg diffed Law THREE TIMES, and was only harmed due to a surprise attack. He is fighting G4 Luffy whilst his internal organs are f*cked and he's internally bleeding and on the edge of death, and yet he STILL proves to be a tough opponent for Luffy
 

A v i

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Mar 10, 2014
Messages
4,396
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Since he's a part of the BBP's monster trio he has to be close to Shiliew and Blackbeard in terms of power, meaning, logically he's the strongest pirate on Dressrosa right now

Joker was far stronger than him before TS so I don't even get how exactly he can surpass him in just two years without actually having a DF. Joker is the strongest pirate at Dressrosa followed by Luffy. Burgess has nothing but hype which was pulled out of nowhere.
 
Last edited:

24 12 11 to troll

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Dec 24, 2011
Messages
11,214
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️

Joker was far stronger than him before TS so I don't even get how exactly he can surpass him in just two years without actually having a DF. Joker is the strongest pirate at Dressrosa followed by Luffy. Burgess has nothing but hype which was pulled out of nowhere.
Busoshoku Haki. Kenbunshoku Haki.

He must be close to Shiliew and BB in terms of power.

Sabo > Burgess > Doffy
 

Bogard

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
21,914
Kin
8💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️

Joker was far stronger than him before TS so I don't even get how exactly he can surpass him in just two years without actually having a DF. Joker is the strongest pirate at Dressrosa followed by Luffy. Burgess has nothing but hype which was pulled out of nowhere.
I won't say it comes out of nowhere. Burgess is the only one Sabo had some concern about before engaging himself in battle, battle in which he had some difficulties against him, to the point he was forced to break the floor as a distraction to steal the fruit instead. Koala even seems to fear him more than Doflamingo even telling that Luffy's life was in danger to the point of calling Sabo for help. Curiously as well, he is one of the only 3 in the island who doesn't seem to be worried about birdcage(the others being Fujitora and Sabo)

About the difference in strength pre and post-timeskip i won't say it's a fair comparison either. Doflamingo is a stepping stone and static character when Burgess(and the rest of Blackbeard pirates) are in constant evolution since they represent the final enemy of the strawhats in this manga, so they'd have to progress more and more during the saga

I'd also find it strange personally if Luffy was already stronger than a end of serie character unless he gets a devil fruit boosting him significantly
 

Uzumaki Macho

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
All at their peaks:
1. Gol D. Roger
2. Edward Newgate
3. Monkey D. Dragon
4. Monkey D. Garp
5. Shiki
6. Sengoku
7. Dracule Mihawk/Silvers Rayleigh
8. Dracule Mihawk/Silvers Rayleigh
9. Kaidou/Shanks
10. Kaidou/Shanks
11. Sakazuki/Kong
12. Sakazuki/Kong
13. Kuzan
14. Issho
15. Big Mom (Charlotte Linlin)
16. Borsalino/Ben Beckmann
17. Borsalino/Ben Beckmann
18. Ryukugyu/Gabban
19. Ryukugyu/Gabban
20. Marco
21. Zephyr
22. Marshall D. Teach (soon to be a top 10)
23. Magellan
24. Shiliew
25. Sabo
26. Don Chinjao
27. Donquixote Doflamingo
28. Bartholomew Kuma
29. Jozu
30. Vista
31. Jesus Burgess
32. Boa Hancock
33. Momonga
34. Onigumo
35. Stainless
36. Strawberry
37. Comil
38. Yamakiji
39. Tsuru
40. Crocodile
41. Monkey D. Luffy
42. Eustass Kidd
43. Trafalgar D. Water Law
44. X Drake
45. Vergo
46. Roronoa Zoro/Smoker
47. Roronoa Zoro/Smoker
48. Scratchmen Apoo/Basil Hawkins/Sanji/Jinbe/Ace
49. Scratchmen Apoo/Basil Hawkins/Sanji/Jinbe/Ace
50. Scratchmen Apoo/Basil Hawkins/Sanji/Jinbe/Ace

You've forgotten about so many characters
Crocodile above Luffy? Your list is full of wank.
 

WoldOfFingo

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jul 29, 2009
Messages
1,862
Kin
8💸
Kumi
1💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Roger/WB/Garp
Mihawk/Rayleigh prime/Shanks/Dragon
Kaido/Akainu
Big Mom/Aokiji
New admiral
Kizaru/Fujitora/Shiki
Teach/Sengoku
Ben Beckman
Marco
Kuma
Jozu/Vista
first mates BM and Kaidou
Sabo
Doflamingo
Shillew
Boa Hancock
Luffy
Burgess
Kid/Law
Zoro
etc...



8206)
Smoker
You must be registered for see images
 
Last edited:

Uzumaki Macho

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
6,663
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Yeah... all your zoro wank in debates contradicts this
1. Roger
2. Whitebeard
3. Garp
4. Dragon
5. Rayleigh
6. Shiki
7. Mihawk
8. Shanks
9. Akainu
10. Kaido
11. Big Mom
12. Blackheard
13. Aokiji/Kizaru
14. Kizaru/Aokiji
15. Fujitora
16. Ryokugyo
17. Marco/Beckmann
18. Beckman/Marco
19. Sabo
20. Burgess
21. Doflamingo
22. Jozu
23. Vista
24. Luffy
25. Kuma
26. Law
27. Kid
28. X Drake
29. Zoro

Look at that, he's not in my top 20, and I even excluded some characters that should be stronger than him but decided not to add due to lack of screen time. But go ahead and complain about the Zoro fanbase even though you wank the most overrated character.
 

WoldOfFingo

Active member
Regular
Joined
Jul 29, 2009
Messages
1,862
Kin
8💸
Kumi
1💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
1. Roger
2. Whitebeard
3. Garp
4. Dragon
5. Rayleigh
6. Shiki
7. Mihawk
8. Shanks
9. Akainu
10. Kaido
11. Big Mom
12. Blackheard
13. Aokiji/Kizaru
14. Kizaru/Aokiji
15. Fujitora
16. Ryokugyo
17. Marco/Beckmann
18. Beckman/Marco
19. Sabo
20. Burgess
21. Doflamingo
22. Jozu
23. Vista
24. Luffy
25. Kuma
26. Law
27. Kid
28. X Drake
29. Zoro

Look at that, he's not in my top 20, and I even excluded some characters that should be stronger than him but decided not to add due to lack of screen time. But go ahead and complain about the Zoro fanbase even though you wank the most overrated character.
Where are ? .......
Shillew, Sengoku, Magellan, Ace sama, Jinbei ,Boa
 

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
All at their peaks:
1. Gol D. Roger
2. Edward Newgate
3. Monkey D. Dragon
4. Monkey D. Garp
5. Shiki
6. Sengoku
7. Dracule Mihawk/Silvers Rayleigh
8. Dracule Mihawk/Silvers Rayleigh
9. Kaidou/Shanks
10. Kaidou/Shanks
11. Sakazuki/Kong
12. Sakazuki/Kong
13. Kuzan
14. Issho
15. Big Mom (Charlotte Linlin)
16. Borsalino/Ben Beckmann
17. Borsalino/Ben Beckmann
18. Ryukugyu/Gabban
19. Ryukugyu/Gabban
20. Marco
21. Zephyr
22. Marshall D. Teach (soon to be a top 10)
23. Magellan
24. Shiliew
25. Sabo
26. Don Chinjao
27. Donquixote Doflamingo
28. Bartholomew Kuma
29. Jozu
30. Vista
31. Jesus Burgess
32. Boa Hancock
33. Momonga
34. Onigumo
35. Stainless
36. Strawberry
37. Comil
38. Yamakiji
39. Tsuru
40. Crocodile
41. Monkey D. Luffy
42. Eustass Kidd
43. Trafalgar D. Water Law
44. X Drake
45. Vergo
46. Roronoa Zoro/Smoker
47. Roronoa Zoro/Smoker
48. Scratchmen Apoo/Basil Hawkins/Sanji/Jinbe/Ace
49. Scratchmen Apoo/Basil Hawkins/Sanji/Jinbe/Ace
50. Scratchmen Apoo/Basil Hawkins/Sanji/Jinbe/Ace

You've forgotten about so many characters
Oh no, boy, delete your account.
 

chopstickchakra

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
12,896
Kin
4,684💸
Kumi
129💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Since he's a part of the BBP's monster trio he has to be close to Shiliew and Blackbeard in terms of power, meaning, logically he's the strongest pirate on Dressrosa right now

Busoshoku Haki. Kenbunshoku Haki.

He must be close to Shiliew and BB in terms of power.

Sabo > Burgess > Doffy
You know in your own list you put Doffy higher than Burgess.

And you saying Burgess>Doffy is the same as saying Zoro or Sanji over Doffy which is unlikely. We saw what Law did against Doffy (and a lot will agree that it was a watered down version) Also the original guys list didn't even include Magellan who has shown he's above Teach and by extension all of the BB Pirates at the same time since he just about killed Teach in front of their face and they did nothing about it.
 
Top