[Discussion] Next Straw Hat Pirate!

[kibainuzuka]

Who do you think it's going to be next Mugiwara?

I think she will be Violet,I really hope so...

Also I dont like Jinbei as Mugiwara not because I hate him or something but he just wouldn't fit them,also I would like him to get an EPIC death

Also I wouldnt like that Kinemon's son as Mugiwara because he's still a child and damn I hate that hairstyle,also Kinemon wouldnt fit them

What are your opinions?

Maybe Bartolomeo too,he's a cool pirate xD

 

[The Sach]

Nah neither Bartolomeo nor Jimbei, violet is good option though..:yeah:

 

[Ōkami]

Jimbei or That Gladiator *****.

 

[Hijey]

Violet because of her devil fruit and being a spy.

 

[kibainuzuka]

I would like to see Marco as Mugiwara too =D

 

[Ōkami]

I would like to see Marco as Mugiwara too =D

Yes that makes perfect sense.

He has one of the rarest Devil fruits.

He is currently the captain of one of the strongest pirate crews

And he's one of the few people capable of stopping Teach.

He should totally be Luffy's underling.

 

[MickNerks]

I really hope it is Bartolomeo. He seems like someone who will fit well with the crew, He is has a strong devil fruit, and im pretty sure his dream is to help luffy become pirate king already, so I really hope he joins. He would be a great help to the crew.

 

[ArabianLuffy]

Can't we say that Jinbe is already one of StrawHats... in the near future? Never mind, I guess he is already.

Monet to me was a good option, but since Punk-Hazard, I'm begging she's still alive... I hope she is.

Now, looking at the situation of Dressrosa, umm~... nope... still no one will join StrawHats... They're gonna be just allies to Luffy.

 

[kibainuzuka]

I want Violet,Marco and Bartolomeo now :O

 

[reizon]

monkey d. dragon.!!

 

[BREAKD]

I hope Jimbei,
but I think voilet and the kinemon family will join first

 

[Noni]

Jimbei, Bartholomeo, and Violet. Only those three are possible.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

To me it's obvious that Violet joins.

 

[Olorin]

Barto isn't joining that's obvious. There are 2 possibilities: 1. It is impossible for him to join 2. He actually turns out to fit into the SH crew, but for that to happen he would have to completely change as a character (and the trait you love about him, being a jackass to random ppl, would have to go away)

out of there I say Violet, but where is Rebecca? If I had to chose the next SH I would say one of those 2 and THAT'S THE LAST MEMBER, please Oda don't go over 10!!!

 

[LitzSabr]

Barto isn't joining that's obvious. There are 2 possibilities: 1. It is impossible for him to join 2. He actually turns out to fit into the SH crew, but for that to happen he would have to completely change as a character (and the trait you love about him, being a jackass to random ppl, would have to go away)

He might become a future division caption of the Straw Hat pirates though.

OT: Why would you put Vivi in the poll now? Should've been Rebecca there.

If the next member is from the current saga, it might be either Rebecca or Violet. High chances for the next member to be a female. Though it is very unpredictable. Anyhow.. For me, I want Violet to join but Rebecca has better chances of joining the crew than her. I doubt Oda will make a woman who actually showed care about Sanji a straw hat.

 

[Olorin]

He might become a future division caption of the Straw Hat pirates though.

the entire crew of the Straw Hats are the main characters and no writer can handle too many of them (that's why I think Oda shouldn't go over 10, maybe, just maybe 11) and Oda knows that very well, combine that with Luffys quote that he wants about 10 crew members + Mihawks comment about Luffy and him making allies and you can more or less clearly see that the SH's are just gonna stay a small pirate group with loads of allies and NOT a fleet and divisions like WB had + no crew has until now had more than 2-3 ''admiral'' level fighters, WB&Marco&Jozu, Roger&Rayleigh&probablyGabban, Shanks&Backman and there are the strongest crews ever right there ... I think Luffy&Zoro&Sanji with support from Cyborg Franky, Robin, Brook (and who knows, maybe even Jinbe) and even Nami, Chopper and Usopp (don't forget Yasopp) are gonna do completely fine

Luffy isn't gonna make a huge crew and go into war with the WG, allies (Barto, maybe Law, Chinjao, maybe Marco even Crocodile, Aokiji, Alabasta, FI, Dressrossa probably... and eventually the revolutionaries are gonna support him too), but Luffy is still gonna do the same thing he has always done, that's simply who he is ... he is gonna take his small crew of 10 or 11 ppl and in all that chaos storm the center of the enemy

I personally will be very pissed if there are ever too many SH's because that would ruin the story, just look at what happened to Franky at PH, Oda is very close to the point of no return and it can all quickly spiral out of control and than we get only a fraction of screen-time for each of our favurite heroes

 

[Lili-Chwan]

Doflamingo

 

[LitzSabr]

the entire crew of the Straw Hats are the main characters and no writer can handle too many of them (that's why I think Oda shouldn't go over 10, maybe, just maybe 11) and Oda knows that very well, combine that with Luffys quote that he wants about 10 crew members + Mihawks comment about Luffy and him making allies and you can more or less clearly see that the SH's are just gonna stay a small pirate group with loads of allies and NOT a fleet and divisions like WB had + no crew has until now had more than 2-3 ''admiral'' level fighters, WB&Marco&Jozu, Roger&Rayleigh&probablyGabban, Shanks&Backman and there are the strongest crews ever right there ... I think Luffy&Zoro&Sanji with support from Cyborg Franky, Robin, Brook (and who knows, maybe even Jinbe) and even Nami, Chopper and Usopp (don't forget Yasopp) are gonna do completely fine

Luffy isn't gonna make a huge crew and go into war with the WG, allies (Barto, maybe Law, Chinjao, maybe Marco even Crocodile, Aokiji, Alabasta, FI, Dressrossa probably... and eventually the revolutionaries are gonna support him too), but Luffy is still gonna do the same thing he has always done, that's simply who he is ... he is gonna take his small crew of 10 or 11 ppl and in all that chaos storm the center of the enemy

I personally will be very pissed if there are ever too many SH's because that would ruin the story, just look at what happened to Franky at PH, Oda is very close to the point of no return and it can all quickly spiral out of control and than we get only a fraction of screen-time for each of our favurite heroes

Handling too many character's IMO would be done. Oda did handled all the Whitebeard pirates perfectly in only one arc, giving good amount to screen time to each character. Yeah except for the minor characters in each division.
The thing about Luffy making allies and them supporting Luffy is True, but recently there have been some sorta hints. Like when Chinjao said that he'd put his son's Happou army under Luffy's command(permanently I suppose). Now's that's a big statement, and Oda won't write this without a purpose. Secondly, we got Bartolomew pirates, There can be two wings (divisions) for Straw Hat except the Main Crew which Luffy want to make of 10 Members (1 more needed). It's possible and the commanders, that is, Sai and Bartolomew, it won't be two hard to give them good amount of screen-time. Minor characters aren't usually given the screen time so it won't be too bad IMO even if they were given less screen-time (like Oda did with WB) pirates and the won't ruin the story. Not a bad idea in the end I guess. :yeah:

Also if Sai and Barto were to become allies (or even commanders of SH's), they won't come near admiral level. These places are for zoro, Luffy and Sanji. Bartolomew and Sai hasn't shown anything anyway near Admiral level. when the M3 would become enough powerful to face Admirals, these two would be strong, but more like on the same level as Jinbe (below Admiral).

 

[David1996]

Jinbei. He's awesome tho he doesn't suit the mugiwaraz

 

[WhistleBlower]

Why kill Jimbei off, OP?

OT: I believe, no-one will join