[Theory] New theory about Raftel

[Hori]

Actually this theory most of it is not my idea, so credits to luckyroo.

I believe Raftel island has mirage properties in which enables it to move from its position from there to there in maybe about 5mins - 10 mins. This is because if it was stationary then the world government would have did a buster call on in already. Even worse dispatch a few Admiral ranked soldiers.

If you wanna oppose this; then acknowledge these facts first.

1. You don't need an archaeologist to get to Raftel; simply because the pirate king's ship they had no archaeologist and yet they reached Raftel.

2. I believe sea demons worse then the Kraken protect the island or maybe they are the island itself, protect this Island. The same sea demons are the ones that create or grant devil fruit eaters their power.

3. Having the will of D is not necessarily a requirement to get to the treasure, because if it was then Law, kid and all worse generation pirates are wasting their time.

Yeah thanks for reading.

 

[Uzamki Seerar]

maybe its a giant turtle or beasts back or maybe even a big bird lol nice theory though

 

[Frikid]

1. Proof that roger had no archaelogist in his crew?
2. Proof???

Can you back up those statements which you call "facts" .

 

[reizon]

I dint even think about raftel until I read some thread in nb about raftel.!! maybe it was your thread...

but im pretty impressed and it does make sense since that place is very difficult to get to.!!

raftel does need to have some sort of twist to get..!!

I like to see luffy figure out a way to get to raftel despite his unparelleled stupidity.!!

lol, wont happen, I guess.!!

 

[The Sach]

Actually good theory, I agree that Raftel must be a moving island, and many things indicate that including the buster call thing you talked about.
Edit:Would like to add about will of D thing, and that is whether One Piece is related to will of D or not, frankly speaking we don't have sufficient evidence to give yes or no as answer.

 

[Hori]

1. Proof that roger had no archaelogist in his crew?
2. Proof???

Can you back up those statements which you call "facts" .

1. Rememberer Skypia Arc when Nick Robin was reading the poneplyph she saw where Roger words printed in the gold next to the poneglyph. Later Robin asked Reyleigh how they wrote that in the Sabaody arc and Rayleigh said its because Roger could hear the voice of all things.

2. I admit that is just my opinion on the island on how it might be, so can you proof I'm wrong on this point too?

 

[Hexuze]

#1 Yes I agree.
#2 Of course
#3 I hope so and this is getting slightly off topic but I don't want Luffy to be the reincarnation of Roger either.

 

[marijuanna]

I agree with 1 and 3, number 2 you just have nothing to back up what you're saying. But lot of sea monsters should be a given, I like to play around with the idea that since on the new world we have 3 log poses which give a hint at how dangerous the next island is, 1 of the pre-requisites to reach raftel is always take the most dangerous route, which luffy will most definetly do. You might need Uranus as well since the weapons surely have a part to play in the OP secrets

 

[Hori]

I agree with 1 and 3, number 2 you just have nothing to back up what you're saying. But lot of sea monsters should be a given, I like to play around with the idea that since on the new world we have 3 log poses which give a hint at how dangerous the next island is, 1 of the pre-requisites to reach raftel is always take the most dangerous route, which luffy will most definetly do. You might need Uranus as well since the weapons surely have a part to play in the OP secrets

1. Well if the log poses record magnetic fields like campuses do which I think they do, what does the magnetic field have to do with the danger of the island?

2. I dunno about Uranus; maybe we will have another arc where Cipher Pol Division is involved. From that arc perhaps the Uranus will fall to the WG hands this time.

 

[Caliburn]

Actually this theory most of it is not my idea, so credits to luckyroo.

I believe Raftel island has mirage properties in which enables it to move from its position from there to there in maybe about 5mins - 10 mins. This is because if it was stationary then the world government would have did a buster call on in already. Even worse dispatch a few Admiral ranked soldiers.

If you wanna oppose this; then acknowledge these facts first.

1. You don't need an archaeologist to get to Raftel; simply because the pirate king's ship they had no archaeologist and yet they reached Raftel.

2. I believe sea demons worse then the Kraken protect the island or maybe they are the island itself, protect this Island. The same sea demons are the ones that create or grant devil fruit eaters their power.

3. Having the will of D is not necessarily a requirement to get to the treasure, because if it was then Law, kid and all worse generation pirates are wasting their time.

Yeah thanks for reading.

This is not really a theory unless you define a theory in a very broad sense of the word. To me this is just a random possibility that has absolutely nothing backing it up (which is for me a fundamental requirement to call something a theory, but that's just me), but nothing that disproves it either. The chance that Raftel would be a sky island, an island at the bottom of the sea, an elevator island that goes from the bottom of the sea to the sky, an island turtle, an island that sends out hypnotic rays confusing everyone that comes near it etc. are as much possible as what you are suggesting. The possibilities are endless and there is nothing that even remotely backs up your specific statement.

Your argument of the Buster Call is extremely flawed as that's based on the assumption that the Marines even have the ability to send an armada to Raftel, which they do not have. If that was possible, then the Yonkou wouldn't have had free game for such a long time. You make it appear like that everyone can just waltz in there, but that the only tiny problem they have is that they do not know the specific location of Raftel. If that was actually the case, mirage or not, Raftel should already have been found several times unless it even loses its physical substance. The entire end of the Grand Line is simply uncharted territory with God knows what kind of things lurking there, it's that what made Roger the Pirate King as no one succeeded in what he did for probably centuries.

I don't get either what the point is in mentioning those 3 'facts' as they have little to no relevance whatsoever to that island being a mirage. Not to mention these 'facts' are quite flawed or simply weird. That entire archaeologist stuff comes pretty much down to someone having knowledge about the poneglyphs and based on the assumption that Raftel, the poneglyphs and the Void Century are connected, a scholar who knows about it would be very helpful, but there isn't anything that says this is an absolute requirement. Same thing with the Will of D thing, even if that somehow would be a requirement, how is the world supposed to know that? You make it sound that somehow the entire world knows exactly everything about what is necessary to reach Raftel. Whether it's needed or not, it's not like that they know that, so there is nothing holding them back. Even assuming the highly unlikely case that they would know they need the Will, what is stopping them from trying regardless? The sea demon thing is even more random than the rest, it might be, but likewise a pink killer bunny is guarding the island that poops out DF every time it's constipated.

I find this all just some random things thrown together and quite lacking in depth considering that this is something that was thought up by two persons.

 

[Hori]

This is not really a theory unless you define a theory in a very broad sense of the word. To me this is just a random possibility that has absolutely nothing backing it up (which is for me a fundamental requirement to call something a theory, but that's just me), but nothing that disproves it either. The chance that Raftel would be a sky island, an island at the bottom of the sea, an elevator island that goes from the bottom of the sea to the sky, an island turtle, an island that sends out hypnotic rays confusing everyone that comes near it etc. are as much possible as what you are suggesting. The possibilities are endless and there is nothing that even remotely backs up your specific statement.

Your argument of the Buster Call is extremely flawed as that's based on the assumption that the Marines even have the ability to send an armada to Raftel, which they do not have. If that was possible, then the Yonkou wouldn't have had free game for such a long time. You make it appear like that everyone can just waltz in there, but that the only tiny problem they have is that they do not know the specific location of Raftel. If that was actually the case, mirage or not, Raftel should already have been found several times unless it even loses its physical substance. The entire end of the Grand Line is simply uncharted territory with God knows what kind of things lurking there, it's that what made Roger the Pirate King as no one succeeded in what he did for probably centuries.

I don't get either what the point is in mentioning those 3 'facts' as they have little to no relevance whatsoever to that island being a mirage. Not to mention these 'facts' are quite flawed or simply weird. That entire archaeologist stuff comes pretty much down to someone having knowledge about the poneglyphs and based on the assumption that Raftel, the poneglyphs and the Void Century are connected, a scholar who knows about it would be very helpful, but there isn't anything that says this is an absolute requirement. Same thing with the Will of D thing, even if that somehow would be a requirement, how is the world supposed to know that? You make it sound that somehow the entire world knows exactly everything about what is necessary to reach Raftel. Whether it's needed or not, it's not like that they know that, so there is nothing holding them back. Even assuming the highly unlikely case that they would know they need the Will, what is stopping them from trying regardless? The sea demon thing is even more random than the rest, it might be, but likewise a pink killer bunny is guarding the island that poops out DF every time it's constipated.

I find this all just some random things thrown together and quite lacking in depth considering that this is something that was thought up by two persons.

There is one thing that you just made clear to me. You are not a physics or a maths learner; because if you were you would know that a theory can also be classified as a statement that is unproven to be right or wrong because if it has it changes and gets to be called a law, principle..... My point is I will admit my 2nd statement is more of a prediction and no proof of it, and yes you can't prove that its wrong and I can't prove its right either.

Now back to number 1 it's actually a fact that archeologists are not required to able to find Raftel. Actually this is due to the fact that on Roger's ship Rayleigh confirmed that they had no archeologists on their ship; I'm not gonna explain this again.

When I referred to the buster call was that since Marines don't want pirates to find the one piece it actually occurred to them that to stop all this we must destroy that Island. So if they tried and were unable to story it or even got owned using buster call would also be necessary. Also this is just my opinion that actually has some sense and logic behind it. You should realize that by how Sengoku reacted when Newgate said he piece is real.

If there is one thing good about the will of D is just the motivation to never give up. You know there is something you are forgetting.. or rather not including when you re thinking. If one piece is really treas..... nah let's leave this one for another day.

 

[Olorin]

There is one thing that you just made clear to me. You are not a physics or a maths learner; because if you were you would know that a theory can also be classified as a statement that is unproven to be right or wrong because if it has it changes and gets to be called a law, principle..... My point is I will admit my 2nd statement is more of a prediction and no proof of it, and yes you can't prove that its wrong and I can't prove its right either.

Now back to number 1 it's actually a fact that archeologists are not required to able to find Raftel. Actually this is due to the fact that on Roger's ship Rayleigh confirmed that they had no archeologists on their ship; I'm not gonna explain this again.

When I referred to the buster call was that since Marines don't want pirates to find the one piece it actually occurred to them that to stop all this we must destroy that Island. So if they tried and were unable to story it or even got owned using buster call would also be necessary. Also this is just my opinion that actually has some sense and logic behind it. You should realize that by how Sengoku reacted when Newgate said he piece is real.

If there is one thing good about the will of D is just the motivation to never give up. You know there is something you are forgetting.. or rather not including when you re thinking. If one piece is really treas..... nah let's leave this one for another day.

you just made it clear that you are not a scientist. A scientific theory is derived from calculations, proof, simulations, models, years of scientific research ... it is not a vaguely put together tale of nonsense that has absolutely nothing backing it up but the possibility that it can't at the moment be directly disproved

for a theory to be even considered by the scientific community one needs much more than what you did, theories with much more complexity with much more of what you call proof and with years of work behind them even get shunned to the side if it is not a properly laid out and presented hypothesis with sufficient research, ... backing it up

one example of a scientific theory for instance is the theory of evolution, or gravity (that's technically both a law and a theory, but still) ... please do tell me that I misread your argument and you did not just compare your ''theory'' to a real scientific theory

 

[Lili-Chwan]

There is one thing that you just made clear to me. You are not a physics or a maths learner; because if you were you would know that a theory can also be classified as a statement that is unproven to be right or wrong because if it has it changes and gets to be called a law, principle..... My point is I will admit my 2nd statement is more of a prediction and no proof of it, and yes you can't prove that its wrong and I can't prove its right either.

Now back to number 1 it's actually a fact that archeologists are not required to able to find Raftel. Actually this is due to the fact that on Roger's ship Rayleigh confirmed that they had no archeologists on their ship; I'm not gonna explain this again.

When I referred to the buster call was that since Marines don't want pirates to find the one piece it actually occurred to them that to stop all this we must destroy that Island. So if they tried and were unable to story it or even got owned using buster call would also be necessary. Also this is just my opinion that actually has some sense and logic behind it. You should realize that by how Sengoku reacted when Newgate said he piece is real.

If there is one thing good about the will of D is just the motivation to never give up. You know there is something you are forgetting.. or rather not including when you re thinking. If one piece is really treas..... nah let's leave this one for another day.

You described an hypothesis. That only turns into a theory when you find facts and arguments to back it up.

 

[Olorin]

You described an hypothesis. That only turns into a theory when you find facts and arguments to back it up.

actually what she wrote would in science be closer to a ''thought'' than a ''hypothesis''

 

[Hori]

you just made it clear that you are not a scientist. A scientific theory is derived from calculations, proof, simulations, models, years of scientific research ... it is not a vaguely put together tale of nonsense that has absolutely nothing backing it up but the possibility that it can't at the moment be directly disproved

for a theory to be even considered by the scientific community one needs much more than what you did, theories with much more complexity with much more of what you call proof and with years of work behind them even get shunned to the side if it is not a properly laid out and presented hypothesis with sufficient research, ... backing it up

one example of a scientific theory for instance is the theory of evolution, or gravity (that's technically both a law and a theory, but still) ... please do tell me that I misread your argument and you did not just compare your ''theory'' to a real scientific theory

Clearly now you are being optimistic you know I can't spend years of my life trying to make up a theory about one piece you know I have a life to live. Also if you are going to make an example about a theory at least make one that is true.

Now if you ignore the theory part and talk about what I wrote below you wouldn't be talking like this because now it seems to me you didn't read all of it to which was not meant for you XD. Or maybe you did read but since I was flawless you chose to ignore it..... which is it?

 

[Hori]

You described an hypothesis. That only turns into a theory when you find facts and arguments to back it up.

Fine I get it I described a hypothesis but that doesn't mean this is still not regarded as a theory (narubase wise).

 

[Olorin]

Clearly now you are being optimistic you know I can't spend years of my life trying to make up a theory about one piece you know I have a life to live. Also if you are going to make an example about a theory at least make one that is true.

Now if you ignore the theory part and talk about what I wrote below you wouldn't be talking like this because now it seems to me you didn't read all of it to which was not meant for you XD. Or maybe you did read but since I was flawless you chose to ignore it..... which is it?

I know you can't waste that much time, so you agree that your argument against Caliburn is invalid since this is in no way comparable to a scientific theory?

one that is true?

no, I simply ignored the rest of your post, which I already told you, are you trying a void argument by saying something that you know is not true but want to gain credibility from everyone reading your post?

 

[Dr Strangelove]

I really like your idea
Don't really agree with the 'Will Of D' part, but t I love the rest of it.

 

[SAHAN1993]

You must be registered for see links

 

[Hori]

You must be registered for see links

Yeah that was pretty plausible.