[Suggestion] NB award suggestion

[Sagebee]

Hello some users shown interest in faciliting awards for certain users to revitalize the site would this be possible. Thanks.

 

[Legendary Broly]

Like what awards? >_O

 

[ChicagoJhawk]

Lol most of the awards would be troll ones. Not sure the mods would like that

 

[iNotorious]

Lets award the trolls, got it :sdo:

 

[Sagebee]

Like what awards? >_O

Well could open a thread allow members put in award title options poll to see which ones users are interested in while mods find acceptable

 

[Legendary Broly]

Well could open a thread allow members put in award title options poll to see which ones users are interested in while mods find acceptable

Could be a good way to cut down the options. It would be cool if there were awards to incentivize quality discussion in the Naruto Discussion section.

 

[Sagebee]

Could be a good way to cut down the options. It would be cool if there were awards to incentivize quality discussion in the Naruto Discussion section.

Agree

 

[Оdin]

I think this site has enough

You must be registered for see links

to offer.

 

[Sagebee]

I think this site has enough

You must be registered for see links

to offer.

It's not a bad idea to establish awards to facilitate fruitful discussions

 

[Оdin]

It's not a bad idea to establish awards to facilitate fruitful discussions

Mods claim they don't have enough time for regular contests. What makes you think they would even bother reading some lame ass Naruto discussions or the recycled race/religious crap in GD?

 

[Sagebee]

Mods claim they don't have enough time for regular contests. What makes you think they would even bother reading some lame ass Naruto discussions or the recycled race/religious crap in GD?

Like I said I think having awards that reward users for either ideas or character would cut much of that down and if we allow users to vote for candidates it puts less work on mods plate.

 

[suki]

Could be a good way to cut down the options. It would be cool if there were awards to incentivize quality discussion in the Naruto Discussion section.

Not a bad suggestion at all. There are male and female of the month awards which could also cover this category. So if I see anyone that really meets the requirements of a quality contribution to that section, I'm more than happy to recommend them for an award.

 

[Anduril]

Not a bad suggestion at all. There are male and female of the month awards which could also cover this category. So if I see anyone that really meets the requirements of a quality contribution to that section, I'm more than happy to recommend them for an award.

Good Idea!

 

[ROHAN]

Not a bad suggestion at all. There are male and female of the month awards which could also cover this category. So if I see anyone that really meets the requirements of a quality contribution to that section, I'm more than happy to recommend them for an award.

I once made a suggestion on this aspect :-

We can have two to three contributors for each manga section. They would have the responsibility to make new threads and participate in discussions. At the end of each month, they submit the number of threads and posts made in a one month period in an analysis thread. Based on thier success in encouraging discussion, all contributors get one Month Premium.

The top Contributor of NB (Based on staff observation) will get the member of the month award.

This ensures :-

1) Members get prizes for thier contribution.
2) Activity increases

It's a win situation for all.

Will it work ? Of course. There's a forum out there which uses such a system. It was so successful that mangas which are not that popular are having lots of discussions.

kun:

 

[Donald J Trump]

The last 3 years, I have not seen the administration impliment anything that would really change the base.

The peasant mods are taking orders to decline all ideas. It's either that or its a game where you find minor bumps in the idea and then close the thread before we find a solution to it.


So far they're all winning in the game. And watch one of these scrubs run out of the bushes and say some defensive ****.


I don't know what you're talking about but I'm sure it's not good enough. :elmo:

 

[Legendary Broly]

This ensures :-

1) Members get prizes for their contribution.
2) Activity increases

It's a win situation for all.

Will it work ? Of course. There's a forum out there which uses such a system. It was so successful that mangas which are not that popular are having lots of discussions.

kun:

That is a cool idea imo. The role of contributor should rotate between users though so members have something to look forward to and also to ensure fresh ideas can come to surface.

However, why limit it to only 3 contributors whose task it is to come up with good threads? Wouldn't it be better if everyone was encouraged to make better quality threads? Why not have an award for Manga discussion thread of the week (I know competitions are monthly, but I feel like weekly will help liven this base up more) that was judged on quality, uniqueness and how well thought out it was as well as engagement from the community. Now days we get threads like "Z negs Y" which aren't thought out at all. I remember the days when NK, Derp, Proof and many other members used to post the most detailed theories and debates. Obviously that was back when Naruto was ongoing however, we still have Boruto to debate and theorize about. Although it has started out slowly, it will hopefully pick up soon and ignite quality discussion so awards like so can be feasible. Not to mention there is a tonne of other manga out there still which brings me to how I like how your idea would liven up the other manga sections.

There is still a lot of popular ongoing manga that the Base can capitalize upon. If the other manga discussions become popular on here it will increase activity and bring in new users. *On that note, why not an award for those who can get the most members to join in a month (I know that can be abused, however, it is just an idea for now)*.
However, tbh, it is hard for the other sections to gain much traction since this site is predominately aimed at the Naruto fan base. So more advertising or a bit of re-tweaking of the site's main theme is needed to further encourage fans of other manga to join realistically.

 

[ROHAN]

That is a cool idea imo. The role of contributor should rotate between users though so members have something to look forward to and also to ensure fresh ideas can come to surface.

However, why limit it to only 3 contributors whose task it is to come up with good threads? Wouldn't it be better if everyone was encouraged to make better quality threads? Why not have an award for Manga discussion thread of the week (I know competitions are monthly, but I feel like weekly will help liven this base up more) that was judged on quality, uniqueness and how well thought out it was as well as engagement from the community. Now days we get threads like "Z negs Y" which aren't thought out at all. I remember the days when NK, Derp, Proof and many other members used to post the most detailed theories and debates. Obviously that was back when Naruto was ongoing however, we still have Boruto to debate and theorize about. Although it has started out slowly, it will hopefully pick up soon and ignite quality discussion so awards like so can be feasible. Not to mention there is a tonne of other manga out there still which brings me to how I like how your idea would liven up the other manga sections.

There is still a lot of popular ongoing manga that the Base can capitalize upon. If the other manga discussions become popular on here it will increase activity and bring in new users. *On that note, why not an award for those who can get the most members to join in a month (I know that can be abused, however, it is just an idea for now)*.
However, tbh, it is hard for the other sections to gain much traction since this site is predominately aimed at the Naruto fan base. So more advertising or a bit of re-tweaking of the site's main theme is needed to further encourage fans of other manga to join realistically.

If you make many people contributors at the same time then everyone will have to be given Premium. That will take away the uniqueness of the position.The three contributor positions can be rotated monthly. The people chosen for the contributor spots could be decided below :-

We can have other categories which will reward those people who participate and encourage discussion other than the contributors. Let's call them distinction members.
For example we can have a
Top Poster category.
Quality Poster category.
etc.

So, the system could be :-

At the end of each month,
The Three Contributors get prizes.
The distinction members who encourage discussions get the bonus awards.
The next round of contributors are chosen from the distinction members.

 

[Horus]

The last 3 years, I have not seen the administration impliment anything that would really change the base.

The peasant mods are taking orders to decline all ideas. It's either that or its a game where you find minor bumps in the idea and then close the thread before we find a solution to it.


So far they're all winning in the game. And watch one of these scrubs run out of the bushes and say some defensive ****.


I don't know what you're talking about but I'm sure it's not good enough. :elmo:

If you don't have proper posts to input in the topic at hand then kindly don't post, thank you!

---

As Nefertari said, I wouldn't mind recommending an award to someone who provided exemplary threads and had good discussions etc.
I guess if we were to go down the route then we'd need to pick from a list of recommended members (from other members) per month rather than for members to vote because people would just vote for a member because they are friends with each other and that's not fair to the other participants.
If we had to implement new awards specifically for categories like that, I wouldn't mind teaming up with Nefertari to design some new awards when I get my laptop.
Lets see what admins have to say

 

[Sagebee]

If you make many people contributors at the same time then everyone will have to be given Premium. That will take away the uniqueness of the position.The three contributor positions can be rotated monthly. The people chosen for the contributor spots could be decided below :-

We can have other categories which will reward those people who participate and encourage discussion other than the contributors. Let's call them distinction members.
For example we can have a
Top Poster category.
Quality Poster category.
etc.

So, the system could be :-

At the end of each month,
The Three Contributors get prizes.
The distinction members who encourage discussions get the bonus awards.
The next round of contributors are chosen from the distinction members.

When you say contributor you mean posters in general right

 

[ROHAN]

When you say contributor you mean posters in general right

No, it would be a special position. Whether Zise makes another usergroup to make it distinct depends on him. You can basically think of them as a little above the members as they have a responsibility to keep discussion ongoing. If you want to make it into a hierarchy it will look like this :-

Mods
Contributors
Members

Mods oversee the Contributors.
Contributors encourage members to post in certain threads or make certain threads.

An update to my previous suggestion : The Bonus Award for Distinction members could include a Contributor spot.