Naruto's hidden parentage

[lndra]

You make the assumption that she was captured because she was a Uzumaki, there are lots of other assumptions that could justify this capture.I won't try to say that one of those assumptions is better, just that it exists.
I explained why Uzumaki should be a safe name compared to Namikaze when Naruto was born.

A lot of assumptions that can't be explained though. It was stated Kushina was captured because she had 'special chakra.

Yet your forgetting that Kushina isn't just some normal Konohagakue girl, she's an Uzumaki. If she was captured for that reason, how do you think they received the information? The first Hokage's wife, Mito, was also sent to contain the Kyuubi much like Kushina. Another Uzumaki.

 

[Prince Badman]

You make the assumption that she was captured because she was a Uzumaki, there are lots of other assumptions that could justify this capture.I won't try to say that one of those assumptions is better, just that it exists.
I explained why Uzumaki should be a safe name compared to Namikaze when Naruto was born.




Your assumptions aren't impossible but let me make assumptions and tell me if you can prove that they are impossible.

There is nothing in the manga that says that Mito wasn't put in a cave like Bunpuku just after she became a jinchuriki until her death, making her existence completely unknown by almost everyone.
Kushina wasn't really kept as a secret, but the fact that she was a jinchuriki was, the fact that she was a very powerfull kunoichi may be unknown by the other villages, even by the average villagers of Konoha.
Her goal was to keep Kurama sealed in her, she may just has lived a simple life of a simple housewife of the Hokage.
It's not even said that she was known as Kushina Uzumaki, like Tsunade she could be known as Kushina.
Let's say almost nobody knew that Mito and Kushina were jinchurikis, that they were Uzumaki and even that they were kunoichis.

Her class mates gave her a nickname, it's not said that she was known around the world with that nickname, let's say she wasn't.

She is the Hokage's wife, she stays at home doing the housewife so that she can keep Kurama under control while she is under protection, she never goes out of the village.

I agree to the fact that another name would have been the best solution.

Let me combine my assumtions like I let you combine yours (an outsider+a surname that almost nobody eared about for decades or no surname at all+a nickname given and known by her classmates when she was young+the hokage's housewife), so she is a simple housewife of a Hokage, she isn't known to have ended a war, almost nobody remember her existence and her surname, like nobody remember the surname or the existence of Mary Todd Lincoln.

well still my possibilities slightly overweigh yours.....Also Kushina was like Naruto all shouting about becoming Hokage and all so i guess she would have been more popular than people think her to be....

 

[UzumakiRyu]

Can someone answer this?

What is it about Kushina's Special Chakra that those Ninja who kidnapped her wanted in order to control the 9 tails?

I would risk answering because it's the chains that are a well known Uzumaki trait ability whatever that allow her to better control Kurama which she has shown when she helped her son tame Kurama during his training with Bee.

Karin displayed those same chains using them to fight that big wooden statue with a thousand hands.

 

[davidou]

A lot of assumptions that can't be explained though. It was stated Kushina was captured because she had 'special chakra.

Yet your forgetting that Kushina isn't just some normal Konohagakue girl, she's an Uzumaki. If she was captured for that reason, how do you think they received the information? The first Hokage's wife, Mito, was also sent to contain the Kyuubi much like Kushina. Another Uzumaki.

It's not because you can't think about other possibilities (like if your mind is closed to any other idea than yours), that they don't exist.

I don't know nor do you, the fact that you can only think to one scenario isn't a proof that it happened like you think.
It's a proof than you have very little imagination.
Here is a very simple possible explanation: a spy heard that Kushina had special chakra well suited to supressing the beasts.

About Mito, why do you think everyone know her and her name?It's doesn't have to be the case, think to Bunpuku.

The fact that you have no imagination doesn't make everything you imagine truth.

well still my possibilities slightly overweigh yours.....Also Kushina was like Naruto all shouting about becoming Hokage and all so i guess she would have been more popular than people think her to be....

Funny, you judge your own self as being better, that's arrogance.
I'll let you here in that dark corner where you can only see yourself.

 

[lndra]

It's not because you can't think about other possibilities (like if your mind is closed to any other idea than yours), that they don't exist.

I don't know nor do you, the fact that you can only think to one scenario isn't a proof that it happened like you think.
It's a proof than you have very little imagination.
Here is a very simple possible explanation: a spy heard that Kushina had special chakra well suited to supressing the beasts.

About Mito, why do you think everyone know her and her name?It's doesn't have to be the case, think to Bunpuku.

The fact that you have no imagination doesn't make everything you imagine truth.

It's kind of funny how you keep saying there is other explanations but have yet to bring down one other opinion on the table.

The part about your spy theory is why would the shinobi be trailing and learning about Kushina out of curiosity? Or do you think it's because of her last name? Keep throwing them out there.

The rest of it is just meh. I've explained it a thousand times almost, and all I'm getting in return is no sense of realism.

 

[davidou]

It's kind of funny how you keep saying there is other explanations but have yet to bring down one other opinion on the table.

The part about your spy theory is why would the shinobi be trailing and learning about Kushina out of curiosity? Or do you think it's because of her last name? Keep throwing them out there.

The rest of it is just meh. I've explained it a thousand times almost, and all I'm getting in return is no sense of realism.

Again,
The fact that you can't imagine scenaris doesn't prove that they don't exist.
Why would the spy be here for Kushina?I didn't put that in my scenario.He could just be here for another purpose.You're so closed minded that you can't imagine a scenario not involving Uzumaki.
That just proves again that you're closed minded, and that you lack imagination.

I see you can't prove that my scenario is impossible. So, there are, at least, 2 possible scenaris, making your statement an assumption.
That was my point from the beginning, you claim assumptions, and that's very wrong, a smart guy doesn't do that.
In case you still don't understand, I don't say that your claim is wrong, I say it may be wrong and you're wrong claiming something that may be wrong.