Narutos Hag Chakra + Hinata Ham Chakra=Boruto Jougan?

[salamander uchiha]

Not necessarily. Genetics can also be very random and luck based even amongst siblings and other family members. Even in the NV:

Asura didn't get sharingan or rinnegan did he? Yet Indra got sharingan.
Hamura didn't get rinnegan.
Hagoromo didn't get tenseigan or byakugan.

That's because of divison of an existing power which isn't the case with Borat's and Himawari's dojutsu. There isn't anything already existing for their to be divided.

No known descendants or siblings of Hashirama got mokuton (unless Moegi is secretly his descendant, but that still doesn't take away the fact that Tsunade didn't get it, nor did Tobirama, and probably not Itama, Kawarama, Butsuma, or Nawaki either)

Boruto didn't get byakugan.

Temari and Kankurou (and also Shikadai) didn't get magnet release from Rasa (yet Gaara apparently did).

Etc...

Flawed logic the genes exist and passed on whether they manifest or not. They may manifest within a later generation the fact is the powers still have an original established source. For Borat and Himawari neither parent possess the dojutsu to pass on or divide it between the siblings so Himawari would inherit it also if it was possible.

Do you see what I mean? When it comes to genetics, even if a child has the potential to inherit a trait (based on their parents having the trait), that doesn't guarantee that the child will get the trait. This also means that just because one sibling gets a trait, doesn't mean that the other automatically has to.

Existing traits I agree with, just as all Uchiha carried the Sharingan gene yet not all manifested it. They still possessed the ability to possess on the unmanifested Sharingan genes to the next gene. There was no random dojutsu passed on by them via ass pull for the sake of plot. I hope you see the flaw in your comparison between the two.

 

[chaos control]

That's because of divison of an existing power which isn't the case with Borat's and Himawari's dojutsu. There isn't anything already existing for their to be divided.



Flawed logic the genes exist and passed on whether they manifest or not. They may manifest within a later generation the fact is the powers still have an original established source. For Borat and Himawari neither parent possess the dojutsu to pass on or divide it between the siblings so Himawari would inherit it also if it was possible.



Existing traits I agree with, just as all Uchiha carried the Sharingan gene yet not all manifested it. They still possessed the ability to possess on the unmanifested Sharingan genes to the next gene. There was no random dojutsu passed on by them via ass pull for the sake of plot. I hope you see the flaw in your comparison between the two.

There is something existing though. There is the rikudou chakara present in both Naruto and Hinata, as well as the bijuu chakara present in Naruto and the byakugan of Hinata.

Therefore, there is something to divide between the siblings. Unfortunately for Himawari though, she only got the byakugan element of that division and none of the rikudou element.

 

[salamander uchiha]

There is something existing though. There is the rikudou chakara present in both Naruto and Hinata, as well as the bijuu chakara present in Naruto and the byakugan of Hinata.

Except it's not and has never been attributed as being the source of it. Momoshiki also dismissed Naruto passing on anything chakrawise to Boruto. Like I said before it's not a pre existing trait originating from either or both of the parents to be passed on as was the case with everybody else. Kaguya's children, Hogaromo's children etc coming down. Even RSM/chakra isn't passable as a bloodline as neither Ashura inherited it or passed it onto his descendants.

Therefore, there is something to divide between the siblings. Unfortunately for Himawari though, she only got the byakugan element of that division and none of the rikudou element.

But there isn't just as their wasn't for Ashura RSM chakra requires handout. And that doesn't equal a new dojutsu or association with one either as it didn't for others before them. So no there's no divison of genes taking place in that regard especially for Boruto.

As for the Bijuu chakra then Naruto lost it alongside his TSB so would likely need to collect it again. He didn't even have RSM to sense Sakura and had to rely on base toad sage mode failing miserably.

 

[Jinrou]

I'm thinking the same thing. It's not like Kaguya appeared out of thin air. I wonder if they separated themselves by branches like the Hyuga did...

Its like Neo says.. Its been confirmed in the new series that there's also a branch system in the Otsutsuki's.

 

[Made in Heaven]

I believe it’s a mutation

I highly doubt they'll give such a mundane explanation for the main character's unique power, especially given what Toneri and Momoshiki have said about the Jougan.

 

[Almighty Ra]

All great theories been gone for a while glad to see the base still on it