[Game] Naruto Shippuden Mafia Game #43

[Stargate18]

Also, there's 7 people alive. Unless there are only two scum in a 14 player game, if I get eliminated we lose the game.

 

[Naomi_]

imo scum control this game.

I am not good at reading some of the player here, as consider first time playing with you.

I think kirk,waluigi,stargate, gutsy

have scum in this.

 

[Naomi_]

Also, there's 7 people alive. Unless there are only two scum in a 14 player game, if I get eliminated we lose the game.

the fact your still alive, over the other who had no ability.

 

[Stargate18]

the fact your still alive, over the other who had no ability.

I'm still alive because half the thread has been scumreading my slot since D1. Why waste an NK on me when they can just wait for town to kill me for them?

 

[Naomi_]

two people who claimed power roles, still alive Xd

yet town with no power role, who claimed getting picked off.,


sucks if town vig shot town at the start of night 1. so lame.

 

[Stargate18]

two people who claimed power roles, still alive Xd

yet town with no power role, who claimed getting picked off.,


sucks if town vig shot town at the start of night 1. so lame.

They were trusted by thread, and as such made sense as NKs.

They saw town devote themselves to pushing me and decided to let them finish the job.

 

[Stargate18]

I continue to insist there is a wolf between you and Kirikoe. This is my determination.

If you do not help me here, then I cannot explain why you're still alive.

There's no reason for you to be if Kirikoe is town. None.

Please check my earlier posts when you are awake. I believe Gutsy may be paired Kirikoe based on a very quick turnaround on their reads.

 

[Gutsy]

If you are so confident I’m a bettereolf then vote me off and watch town get burnt down when I’m gone

 

[Stargate18]

If you are so confident I’m a bettereolf then vote me off and watch town get burnt down when I’m gone

...If a townie gets flipped today, the game ends, unless there's only two scum in a 14 player game. Is this a slip, Gutsy?

 

[Gutsy]

How is it a slip me saying if I get voted out town loses ?

 

[Gutsy]

3 or 4 people voted for stargate last day and now none are?

and everyone focuses on Kirikoe?

why ?

everyone including pigeon and Naomi wanted you out same with waluigi

but im the sus one?

 

[Ekkologix]

If Stargate is truly town, Wolf team can use them against us by not going for the early kill - This breeds suspicion towards why, if they can engage the town to lynch instead of making the kill themselves then it wastes a lynch against ourselves AND the wolves can still night kill. I use logical thinking and critical thinking for my accusations and comments in this case. I have no special role and you claiming clear banter as facts is sus in itself. You are going for a hard push here when it matters the most. Why get rid of someone who could be attracting attention away from yourselves. It legit comes back to the chinese saying of 'Hiding beneath the tallest trees canopy'

This is the sole reason why I have been hesitant to get rid of Stargate myself and have voted the others that appeared as sus towards me. You can claim you are a role, but just because you say you are, doesn't mean you actually are.

can you elaborate on why do u think is the case as opposed to stargate being wolf doctor, the mafia's counter role to elmage's town 1x kill. how did u arrive at him being town from the thread or otherwise to kickstart this assumption

 

[Lucidus]

can you elaborate on why do u think is the case as opposed to stargate being wolf doctor, the mafia's counter role to elmage's town 1x kill. how did u arrive at him being town from the thread or otherwise to kickstart this assumption

I didn't

Quite honestly I think he is a wolf still, I merely presented the 'What if' so to speak. Which would explain 'Why' the doctor, if he is one, is still alive.

If you notice throughout the thread, I am not making absolute claims, I am presenting possible happenings and scenarios because I truly have no way of knowing the exact answer.

I use part of my knowledge from previous games, so some of my possibilities come from first hand experience.

Unfortunately, without knowing for absolutely certain I can't make absolute claims, I can strongly feel towards someone, which was the case with TBB.

The reason I didn't want to explain this much earlier is because it was possible that the wolves had not thought of using him that way, why should i present a situation in which they could use someone and give them more ideas!

I still don't know if he is truly town, or wolf. But it is true that he claimed to be the doctor. It is true that he is somehow still alive. So what are we left with? Either he is not the doctor and its a wolf using the title as a protection of sorts, OR, it is the doctor and instead of getting rid of him themselves, they provoke the town to do it. Its a hard situation to be in, this is why despite my suspicion I have always gone with my second suspicion rather than Stargate first hand.

I was hoping TBB would be a wolf, if that was the case, there pushes towards Stargate could have absolved him some, but unfortunately it didn't pan out that way

 

[Rohan]

Vote Stargate

I am willing to change my vote depending on how the game goes. For me right now, Stargate is more wolfy than Kiri.

 

[Rohan]

imo scum control this game.

I am not good at reading some of the player here, as consider first time playing with you.

I think kirk,waluigi,stargate, gutsy

have scum in this.

I do not think Gutsy is a wolf. His posts are very level headed.

 

[Michelle]

Vote count 1 of day 4 at P#1295

Naomi: Stargate
Waluigi: Kirikoe
Gutsy: Stargate
Rohan: Stargate

Votes	Voted	Voters
3	Stargate	Naomi, Gutsy, Rohan
1	Kirikoe	Waluigi

Spoiler

Vote lynch Stargate



i put kirk and gutsy on sus, waluigi not gonna get lynched even with his mega slip.

@Ekkologix

Vote: Kirikoe

Vote: Stargate

Vote Stargate

I am willing to change my vote depending on how the game goes. For me right now, Stargate is more wolfy than Kiri.

Please let me know of any mistake in private conversation

 

[Waluigi]

I see that my words have failed to persuade. I believe Kirikoe is a wolf. I laid out my evidence.

I don't have a choice here. I have to vote not divided with Naomi, because Naomi is provably town.

If Naomi is voting for a townie, then the wolves can just pile on Stargate at end of round anyway, so my vote doesn't matter.

In fact, if Kirikoe is town despite my case work, me voting Kirikoe can be the losing vote as every wolf piles on that town on town suspicion, if that happened to be the case.

So a "vanity vote" (lone vote) on Kirikoe doesn't win for town, and can sometimes lose for town.

I will vote for Stargate, with Naomi, and win or lose together with her judgment.

 

[Waluigi]

@Ekkologix

this is the critical round, you should place a vote before the round ends.

Vote: Stargate18

Kirikoe obviously isnt going to vote for themself, but technically should be placing a vote here as well.

@Stargate18

You need to be voting to self preserve in case Naomi changes her mind.

 

[Waluigi]

Anytime a townie does not vote this round, wolves can win. If you are not voting to self preserve, you lose the game.

 

[Waluigi]

Wolves don't have to place a vote, they can wait out the round if the vote is bad.

Also, they can pretend not to self preserve until the final moment of play. So they have no reason to tip their hand early.

Please place votes.