Naruto mastered SM meaning he's physical stronger, faster, have more chakra, plus endurance, agility and sensory ability should be higher. Jiraiya had an imcomplete SM but was able to fuse with Ma and Pa toad making SM usable for longer from Ma and Pa toad absorbing natural chakra and balancing it with Jiraiya's chakra. Jiraiya was able to combine attacks with them to make stronger ones (fire+wind+oil= a burning oil). So unless Naruto somehow already learned the SM jutsus Jiraiya used I say I like Jiraiya's SM more, one of his cool jutsus is turning anyone into a toad (with hand seals) while Naruto only let pain absorb his SM chakra and turned into a toad stone. That jutsu alone can beat edo, turn them into frogs and they can't fight anymore.