Naruto giving chakra back to the tree is not happening

[Sennin of Logic]

I'd like to address this idea. It's impossible and against Naruto's character. Allow me to explain.

This is what happens when chakra is given back to the tree.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

The anatomy of probably every living human being revolves around chakra, and having the chakra organs removed would destroy their vitals.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

The absence of chakra is lethal to a shinobi. So basically, it's saying that Naruto and the alliance are going to give away chakra to the holy tree are going to commit suicide in a strange attempt to "make things right."


It also goes against Naruto's character. One of the arguments for it is "Chakra only brought suffering to humanity." Well, do you think Naruto's the type to back down on a curse?

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

Basically people supporting this theory are expecting Naruto to become Obito. Naruto's the type to do good things with a curse, not run away from it. He's the type that would solve problems, not run away from them because they "can't handle it."


Naruto giving chakra back to the holy tree would not only be impossible, but a disgrace to Naruto's character.

 

[Draphsin]

Strong opinions, however what if naruto found a way to return the chakra without suffering any casualties because of it? That would still solve the problem & wouldn't go against his character.

 

[Gein]

May I ask where you got the idea of him giving it back?

 

[ANiMUS]

Nice work

 

[Alfred Pennyworth]

this is assuming that chakra / ability to use/mold chakra can't be taken without killing anyone

if that's the case I don't think he will do that

 

[henryred95]

I think the same

 

[Xlad]

Giving chakra back is basically only taking the guns away. That didn't stop people from

You must be registered for see links

. It's pretty much human nature; the real solution lies within the people themselves.

 

[Sennin of Logic]

Strong opinions, however what if naruto found a way to return the chakra without suffering any casualties because of it? That would still solve the problem & wouldn't go against his character.

Except that's impossible, and it's basically saying "this power is too much for us, I'm totally giving up on it because we can't handle it." That would never come out of Naruto's mouth. It's against his character.

May I ask where you got the idea of him giving it back?

Read the link in my sig, and you'll find that there's people who think this idea.

 

[DanielSturridge]

No; no, he won't. Naruto is a control freak.

 

[Alfred Pennyworth]

and now that I recall so6p wants to connect ppl via ninshuu , which is probably a goal the current naruto wants to succeed

 

[Sennin of Logic]

and now that I recall so6p wants to connect ppl via ninshuu , which is probably a goal the current naruto wants to succeed

That's what I think as well.

 

[Draphsin]

Except that's impossible, and it's basically saying "this power is too much for us, I'm totally giving up on it because we can't handle it." That would never come out of Naruto's mouth. It's against his character.

How does naruto wanting to return something his ancestors stole translate to the power being "too much" for them? He can most certainly handle the power as he's been demonstrating, but he may just decide that he wants to do the right thing by returning what was rightfully taken, in turn destroying the root of the curse itself.

& Remember when someone surviving the 8 gates was supposed to be impossible? Then remember the words naruto spoke? "I feel like I can do anything", these are indications that chakra removal without death could be possible [not true, but possible].

 

[SIX PATHZ]

due to past ppl cn live without chakra. bt also agree its gona be calling to death in present. bt naruto can regenerate anything as we saw and still didnt saw wt sasuke mark can do. simply there power combine = creation of all things.

i think its abt bijuu chakra mainly.bt still dnt think naruto give it up coz he having like a bond with them and giving them make him major powerless too.

bt this is heated circle on and this must be stop somehow. naruto got all bijuu power already so giving up there main bodys may be?
coz as long as bijuus exits ppl cn try to same thing that madara did too.