naruto 631 the most controversial chapter?

[Itachi75]

in this chapter we had.
1. the pairing wars explode.
2. minato mastering the kyuubi's chakra, even though he was dead.
3. a 4-way sealing jutsu that is nothing short than plot no jutsu.
4. sakura going from failing to dodge a kunai wiht the kyuubi cloak saying she will fight on equal footing with Sasuke and naruto, meaning that she is well above kage leve.
-
so after all this can we safely say this is the most controversial chapter?

 

[Steaktacular]

It´s definitely a funny one and I don´t mind saying that I liked it, specially because it angered people Lol

 

[Cosman]

Chapter 599 will always go down as the most controversial chapter in my books.

This is a close second.

 

[Itachi75]

what was so controversial in 559? MAdara being reborn and Naruto telling Hinata she was strong? that wasn't that confusing, but then agian i wasn't around the base at the time can you please inform me?

 

[Makoto]

Chapter 599 will always go down as the most controversial chapter in my books.

This is a close second.

Agreed. People were in denial even weeks after the chapter on what happened, and were trying to explain away Tobi being Obito and no one believed it for WEEKS.

 

[IzAnAgI4200]

Just why does sakura have to get such a power up? They don't need her IMO.

 

[FreakensteinAG]

1. the pairing wars explode.

Simply playing upon reminiscence of Naruto part1.

2. minato mastering the kyuubi's chakra, even though he was dead.

Naruto didn't master the kyubi's chakra either. He trained to get to the part of forcefully obtaining it from kurama, but when he actually got the chakra, it was instantaneous for him too. Now training to be more flexible with the chakra, that's a better question.

3. a 4-way sealing jutsu that is nothing short than plot no jutsu.

You should revisit Part1 when several jutsus were being explained at once that we had no clue about existing. No one complained then, but I guess this is just another double standard.

4. sakura going from failing to dodge a kunai wiht the kyuubi cloak saying she will fight on equal footing with Sasuke and naruto, meaning that she is well above kage leve.

I won't talk about the first half of it--that was pretty weird by itself. I also recognize it as a fact, as I'm a fact checker!

so here's the second half:

saying she will fight on equal footing with Sasuke and naruto, meaning that she is well above kage leve

It's like you dabble in fallacies for a living. Maybe it's how your neural pathways are wired. But this is also a clever trap, whether you know about it or not! If I say no, it's not like that, that gives clever leeway to suggest Sakura is nowhere near this level at all! I would have to say "yes, that is true, she is not near kage level". You want what's at the bottom.

But that is not the point of Sakura's revealing dialogue. She has stored up chakra for her full power. She wants to use it to help out with her allies. Is this not a noble act?

P.S. I swear we've gone over half this information yesterday in different threads, OP. Did you forget?

 

[CJ Mac]

I don't think its too controversial. Rather Kishi is tying up loose ends and moving the story along very quickly. This made everything that happened a little overwhelming. Essentially, everything in the series has pushed the story to these points, but instead of spreading everything out over a number of chapters, Kishi put it all in one.

1. The war arc is coming to an end soon. It is down to the entire world versus Madara and the Juubi with Kakashi and Obito fighting in another dimension. This is just the natural progression of the story.

2. Minato hasn't mastered anything. He merely is using the chakra that he took from Kurama on the night Naruto was born. The Reaper death seal sealed the chakra inside of him with a similar seal to the one he used on Naruto. I'm sure there are differences between Naruto and Minato's use of the chakra. One that I am almost sure of is that Minato's cloak is a one-time use technique, and once done, Kurama's Yin chakra will not re-accumulate in Minato. Kishi had to explain where Kurama's other chakra went, and he did that with Minato's cloak.

3. The barrier jutsus used by the Hokage aren't new at all. The Sound Four used a similar barrier to contain the battle between Orochimaru and Hiruzen, and Darui's unit used one to contain Tsunade's boyfriend. The extra part is just a Ten-Tailed version of the jutsu Naruto used in his internal battle against Kurama.

4. I'm gonna give this one to you. Sakura's development as a character and a shinobi just doesn't make sense. She can barely function in combat when compared to the other heavy hitters in the series, and yet she is now standing there with Sasuke and Naruto, ready to square off against the most powerful enemy in the series so far. She may be planning on using some sort of supporting technique, but that wouldn't explain what she said and did in the chapter. She still needs to build up chakra to release her new technique, and if it was some supporting role, she would just sit back and do so. It seems as though her new technique is offensive in nature. This is a huge change in Sakura's role in the series. From day one, she was a supporting character with little to no combat potential, and now she is being compared to Naruto and Sasuke. It just doesn't make sense.

 

[JustSomeRandomGuy]

I have a feeling that Kishi was feeling like a comedian while drawing this chapter.

 

[Fanta]

Pretty much

 

[Ludicrous]

Kishi trolled everyone on that chapter...