Narrative does not work as a argument to determine who would win

Bob74h

Active member
Regular
Joined
Feb 13, 2021
Messages
1,016
Kin
3,569💸
Kumi
210💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
You cant argue narrative, When the two characters exist in different stories
what are you narratively comparing, deity status or story relevance

like if you argue on those frameworks
zarbon loses to spike spigel from cowboy bebop



the reason
why the buster tiers exist, Is so we arent resorting to retard tier arguments and instead can actually nymber which character would win
like if you can number their power by calcing the damage, that's more objective

then muh god status or muh concepts
im sorry but that shit just aint consistent whatsoever, By that logic puss in boots beats all of naruto cause he beat death, a concept



what alot of the lore scaling arguments boil down to
Is assumptions on higher dimensions and if it means you scale to insane strengths

There is the new power scaling bs of going off ''lore'' and then the classic way of feats
im in the feats camp obviously


lifting a temple and calcing the actual power that would take is always gonna be more reliable as a method of comparison then just stating he beat a god of death bro.

Somebody needs to make a tiering chart to explain how these tiers work
What is the concept lv compare to being a deity lv or does the various concepts have different lvs of power, what of higher dimensions or whatever where does that compare to the concepts or the embodiments

and dont bloody say, we can just use the old tiering list
when your reasoning does not go based on it, wither or not character destroy city,country,planet or whatever

it's based a subjective lore system, that im sure anybody who argues it cant actually define how it works

And here's why it cant work, if you use the classic power scaling method, feat scaling
you would say dante moved faster then rain could fall so easily faster then light or some other speed scale based on whatever calcing it would give you

a lore scaler, would go dante scales above concepts so super strong and higher dimensional as a result

This line of reasoning does not fall within the tier system, jesus
even vs wiki's tier system does not allow for this reasoning

and ofc they sometimes lore scale in their articles but that's because they are hypocrites
regardless point still stands, you cant follow the tier list as it's laid out here and then go muh concepts cause the tiers strictly deal with measurable tiers not abstract bs
Post automatically merged:

Here's the most comical thing
these people would laugh at multiverse lv captain america

but he represents truth,justice and the american way
those are concepts

so if went by the logic of the lore scaler
you would literally have it so that steve rogers can blow up infinity
 
Last edited:
Top