Namekians Vs Saiyans

[Mellow]

No Super Saiyan nor Super Namek
I'm talking - Fusion namekians and Great ape saiyans

Namekians have knowledge on Saiyans and how they transform with the moon and what not so they would cut off the tails. They also have regeneration of limbs and can fuse together.

Saiyans can transform into great ape and have armor

Edit:to make it fair Super Nameks are permitted

 

[Gerkak]

If super nameks are included, then they stomp.(eg super namek piccolo>>regular ssj>>>>>great ape)

Without great ape form and ssj, saiyans and nameks are roughly comparable in power. When vegeta first saw piccolo he said a trait nameks had was their unusually high power levels. This suggests saiyans respected the power of nameks.

This also explains why piccolo was able to keep up with the saiyans in the show for a while.

 

[Kingu]

If super nameks are included, then they stomp.(eg super namek piccolo>>regular ssj>>>>>great ape)

Without great ape form and ssj, saiyans and nameks are roughly comparable in power. When vegeta first saw piccolo he said a trait nameks had was their unusually high power levels. This suggests saiyans respected the power of nameks.

This also explains why piccolo was able to keep up with the saiyans in the show for a while.

I get what you Saiyan he can Nemak us choose something which is unfair.

 

[Defence]

Nail was the strongest Nemekian and he was a fodder compared to frieza's henchmen so vs Saiyans would be an overkill. Bardock (3rd rate saiyan) did put up a good fight vs dedoria (who basically slaughtered the nemekians)

Piccolo is an exception

 

[Stant]

wtf?, most stupid thread so far.

if you seen DBZ then you see the obvious conclusion

Spoiler

namek is victorious

 

[Saiyan Kammy]

Saiyans. Toriyama's favourite Dragon Ball character is Piccolo so yes he's an exception.

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

Nail was the strongest Nemekian and he was a fodder compared to frieza's henchmen so vs Saiyans would be an overkill. Bardock (3rd rate saiyan) did put up a good fight vs dedoria (who basically slaughtered the nemekians)

Piccolo is an exception

Wtf are you talking about? He was much stronger than Dodoria and Zarbon, and is around Recoome, Berter, and Jeice level. He only minion of Frieza was was without a doubt stronger than Nail was Ginyu.

OT: Warrior clan Namekians are definitely more powerful than your average Saiyan, but I'm not sure which race is more powerful overall when you factor in Dragon clan Namekians.

 

[Zavage10]

Namek would have the edge under normal circumstances , but under a full moon the saiyans would neg then. Great ape form boosts their strenght ten fold. Plus saiyans tend to coincide their fight with the moon, but namek does have a night time.


On namek the nameks win, but on a world with a full moon saiyans neg.

 

[Dark Sonic]

If they fusion, why not let Saiyans use the temporary fusion?

 

[Itachi Minato]

I read somewhere that all the super name's died out and piccolo waste the only one left. Super nameks are stronger than super saiyans. Otherwise their powers are comparable.

 

[ultraChalk]

Posted before reading. Actually I think this is about even.

 

[EZQ]

This thread is kind of... silly

It all comes to individual power levels.

Piccolo + Nail fusion >>>> Great ape

But, a saiyan on cell saga vegeta level (for example) who still has his tail, and goes great ape, should be even stronger than a regular ssj.

Now, if we take fodder great apes vs fodder namek fusion then the namek take this. The result of the fusion between them was::

Piccolo (50000 ki) + Nail (40000 ki) = Above one million ki

While the great ape transformation increases x10 the power.

Namek wins. Their power grows too much in comparision when they fuse. Besides they have knowledge on the ape's tail, but, it's not even needed here. They would completely obliverate the apes.