Nagato's Whole Life: An illusion?

[Punk Hazard]

I've been thinking, what if what we saw happen to Nagato didn't happen. What if Madara created Tobi using his DNA and a zetsu clone. Then, he and Tobi set out for the Uzumaki village. Once there, they put a Genjutsu. I think they chose Nagato because he was the youngest Uzumaki. Then, as they were leaving, Madara had one of his Rinnegan removed and he gave it to Tobi. Then, after finding out Nagato was taken, they went after Madara and Tobi. Tobi then transported Nagato away and Madara used the last of his power and his remaining Rinnegan to summon a meteor, which he used to destroy the Uzumaki and himself in the process.

Then, Tobi used Zetsu to clone a second Rinnegan. He then implanted them into Nagato and left him out in the ruins so he would meet up with Yahiko and Konan and inevitably form Akatsuki, all the while not remembering anything and under the illusion that Leaf Ninja killed his parents.

Also, I think Madara used Leaf Ninja in the illusion in hopes that he would help Tobi destroy the village in revenge. Itd also explain how Madara knows Nagato

 

[Michael92]

This is a good theory, I like it!
You should perhaps have chosen the "Theory" prefix beside the threads name though.

 

[TheSages456]

idk nagato doesnt seem relevant enough to the story anymore for kishi to make a background that detailed for him. my theory is madara lived long enough to meet toddler nagato then he gave him his eyes. madara then died or madara saw toddler nagato gave tobi his eyes then tobi gave them to nagato.

 

[TobisPawn]

I don't like how everyone thinks Tobi is just a Zetsu clone.

 

[Joon]

It's too much complication. Tobi and Madara had a lot planed for it to all come crashing down or tweak by a simple foolish death, such as Madara dying by his own Jutsu. Anything further is already mentioned and speculation. Nice Theory and I agree to some extent.

 

[Necron]

F*cking Sh1t!!! I was discusting the same kind of theory an hour ago with PTR!!! That's so f*cking weird O.O

...actually, on second thought, It was very different, but we still had the plot that" his whole life previous to the flashback was a genjutsu"... O.O

 

[shisuimirage42]

if his life is an illusion the how does jiraiya remembers him? and if tobi has a genjutsu that can trap a individual for years, the y doesnt he just ampliy that jutsu instead of trying to refelect it off of the moon? lol

 

[Punk Hazard]

if his life is an illusion the how does jiraiya remembers him? and if tobi has a genjutsu that can trap a individual for years, the y doesnt he just ampliy that jutsu instead of trying to refelect it off of the moon? lol

No I mean when he kidnapped Nagato, he was the same age he was as a kid when we saw his parents die

The genjutsu I'm talking about didn't remove his whole life, just what happened for a few days.
Instead of remembering that Madara and Tobi kidnapped him, they re-wrote his memory to make him think Leaf Ninja killed his parents. They then dropped him off in like a deserted town where he met Yahoko and Konan, then met Jiraiya

 

[Prince Charles]

fact still remains we SAW him awaken his rinnegan infront of his parents death idk how kishi is going to explain that.

 

[Punk Hazard]

fact still remains we SAW him awaken his rinnegan infront of his parents death idk how kishi is going to explain that.

Actually, we saw that when he was explaining to naruto what happened during his childhood. However, if I'm right about this, then that would just be what he THINKS happened, and we would still have yet to know what actually happened

 

[muang]

I agree with the Zetsu - Madara clone (not 100%).