Nagato vs Itachi

[Orochimaruwantsyourbody]

Come on. Itachi paneled Nagato with Amaterasu when the fight began. Then he paneled him again him with the Totsuka. The only time he didn't panel Nagato was when he had to save Bee and Naruto. And he cut off Nagato's arm, buried kunai in his Rinnegans, and forced him to use Chibaku Tensei in that instance.​

 

[Raito]

You cant compare a Sound genjutsu with a visual genjutsu itachi himself would of prob gotten hit with the frog song. we have no proof nagato would get caught tsukuyomi.

No one can break through Tsukuyomi. Yo have to be an Uchiha with Sharingan, that's the only way. Also Itachi doesn't have only visual genjutsus. In addition, it does not matter which kind of genjutsu it is, sound, visual, etc., Genjutsus are Genjutsus and manipulate the chakra flow in the brain. During the Sharingan has the specific ability to see through illusion, the Rinnegan hasn't it.

 

[Myno0on]

itachi owns nagato
itachi owns nagato mother
itachi owns nagato father
itachi ownd nagato family
itachi owns anything related to nagato

just sick and tired of how most ppl overate him if i listen to ppl in here nagato>everyone together except so6p
-.-

 

[Raito]

Yes. The users don't have arguments against Genjutsus. Although they can say: "We don't know how Tsukuyomi work on Rinnegan and we cannot compare visual Genjutsus with sound Genjutsus".:flaw:

 

[Raito]

every itachi fanboy here thinks the same thing woould happen if naruto and bee wasn't there..

Nagato would look into Itachis eyes and then bear several days of worse torture.

itachi can;t destroy CT alone. that is a fact.

U_U
If it's like you say fact, then show me the prove. Otherwise you can't call your statement "fact". Always have to explain it to people like you.

 

[Mante]

Nagato ftw!!​

 

[pensilol]

Nagato would look into Itachis eyes and then bear several days of worse torture.



U_U
If it's like you say fact, then show me the prove. Otherwise you can't call your statement "fact". Always have to explain it to people like you.

Nagato don't need to look in Itachis eyes, he have enough summons which can do it for him.

 

[Saiyan Kammy]

Itachi

 

[Ryuu..]

Oh lord, this isn't a difficult choice, Nagato owns Itachi all day, every day.

 

[johnny335704]

Nagato alone wins with high difficulty
6 paths of Pain win with normal difficulty.

 

[Avani]

Posting one word replies is considered spamming and such replies will be infracted. Global forum rules apply here as well. If you have an opinion you should be able to expalain your reasoning.​

 

[EdoMadara]

Itachi oneshotted nagato. that's fact.
give me a chapter on manga with itachi get a scratch from nagato??

Nagato ruins the rinnegan , while itachi make MS so IMBALANCE . that's why i like Itachi , the way he battling is unrivaled. same as minato.

 

[Itachi Uchiwa]

Exactly what the title says i want to know everyone's opinion who you think would win. i no theres a thread for this already but there pretty old so i decided to start a new one. As my name suggest's I'm in favor of Nagato. I love both of them but i just don't believe Itachi would be able to pull it off. I'm not saying its impossible but highly unlikely. Ever since Itachi sealed away Nagato every Itachi fan believes Itachi is more powerful. But that's not the case, for one Nagato was under Kabato's control and couldnt think for himself. Kabuto doesn't know Nagato's power's like Nagato himself knows them. If he was under his own control he wouldn't of been as careless. And it also took Naruto, Killer Bee, and Itachi to defeat Nagato. People say Itachi could of done it himself but he wouldn't of asked for help if he didn't need it. He wouldn't of wanted Killer Bee and Naruto to waste their chakara if it wasn't absolutely necessary. And people have been saying Nagato has no speed feats. He may not be fast on his feet but his reaction speed and attack speed makes up for that. They say he has no speed feats just cause the sword struck him. For one the dust cloud was blocking his view and once again was being controlled by that a-hole Kabuto and couldn't react on his own. He was able to keep up with Killer bee and Naruto and overpower them when they are clearly faster in V2 and 9 tails chakara mode. He can also fly which increases his speed and also has the power to use Asura path's Chakra Propulsion technique to greatly increase his speed if needed. Itachi doesn't have many jutsu that can hurt Nagato. His only options are Amaterasu, Tsukuyomi, and Susanoo while. But Nagato can repel Amaterasu, we don't know if he could defend against Tsukuyomi all we can really say is maybe, maybe not. You can't compare Frog Song which is a Sound Genjutsu to Tsukuyomi which is a visual Genjutsu. Visual Genjutu's may not work on the rinnegan. It also states Nagato is adept at genjutsu as he placed mental barriers inside the path's mind so no one could invade their mind and access secret information. Susanoo is his best option. Many people over hype the Yata Mirror and the sword of totsuka. I've read alot of post's claiming the Yata Mirror could deflect Shinra Tensei, while we don't know if it could exactly but from what Narutopedia says about it it seems it can only block nature transformation techniques and Shinra Tensei is not a nature transformation so from that it seems like the attack could get through. And as for The Sword of Totsuka i admit it could work on Nagato but not as easy as everyone's saying. If the 2 were fighting one on one without kabuto controlling nagato i dout it would of worked on him right away like that. Nagato could just keep his distance from susanoo till it wore off cause Itachi can't hold it for very long cause it causes strain on his body and eyes and drains his life force and chakra. Or another option is to fly above and stay out of range of Susanoo so itachi has no way of getting to him. As for Itachi's intellect i admit hes somewhat smarter than nagato but not all that much that it would affect the battle. Nagato has more battle experience. As naruto even stated Nagato is much more powerful with his own body then the six paths as his attacks are more powerful and faster. Killer Bee and Naruto could probably defeat Itachi together while Nagato overwhelmed Naruto and Killer Bee without a problem. If they all 3 didnt attack the celestial sphere they would of died. Even tobi has stated that Nagato was invincible and hes one of the six paths and was considered by all the most powerful akatsuki member by them all. Even zetsu was shocked by his defeat saying he never thought he could be defeated. Itachi even stated he would be killed by jiraiya and nagato defeated him with ease. Nagato has gotten alot of praise from Tobi and Zetsu while know one in the Akatsuki praised Itachi's power's as much as he was a powerful shinobi but doesnt possess the powers Nagato does. Also his rinnegan is more powerful than the sharigan. Its not a fact that nagato could beat itachi but everything points to nagato. Im not counting itachi out just think its highly unlikely itachi could win against someone with nagato's powers. please give reasoning's for your decisions who would win and not just say "nagato would win" or "itachi would win cause he's awesome". and please be respectful towards eachother. Thanks

let's talk Reasonably ! Nagato has No immunity ! just NO immunity against Tsukuyomi or any others of itachi's Genjutsu in general ! against Itachi ; Only few may have A chance IF itachi didn't use Tsukuyomi ; but Only One can break the Tsukuyomi : sasuke
Nagato is One of those few : Nagato can Win Only If itachi Didn't use Genjutsus including Tsukuyomi or susanoo ; wich is hard to believe ; Itachi is a genjutsu Specialist ! and a sealing master with totsuka no tsurugi! (it was prooven in their edo battle there was nothing Nagato could do !! ) (Rinnegan don't give immunity against Visual Genjutsu)

 

[Lankeysob]

Itachi oneshotted nagato. that's fact.
give me a chapter on manga with itachi get a scratch from nagato??

Nagato ruins the rinnegan , while itachi make MS so IMBALANCE . that's why i like Itachi , the way he battling is unrivaled. same as minato.

Just like Itachi one shotted nagatos chibaku tensei.... Oh wait...

 

[Lankeysob]

let's talk Reasonably ! Nagato has No immunity ! just NO immunity against Tsukuyomi or any others of itachi's Genjutsu in general ! against Itachi ; Only few may have A chance IF itachi didn't use Tsukuyomi ; but Only One can break the Tsukuyomi : sasuke
Nagato is One of those few : Nagato can Win Only If itachi Didn't use Genjutsus including Tsukuyomi or susanoo ; wich is hard to believe ; Itachi is a genjutsu Specialist ! and a sealing master with totsuka no tsurugi! (it was prooven in their edo battle there was nothing Nagato could do !! ) (Rinnegan don't give immunity against Visual Genjutsu)

Do you have proof to support this claim? If you do I'd love to see the scan where Itachi traps nagato in a genjutsu.

 

[EdoMadara]

itachi outsmarted nagato.
totsuka stab and the end. dont recall it again it'll do the same thing.
even on the blindspot itachi cant blind rinnegan share vision, that's insane.

 

[pensilol]

let's talk Reasonably ! Nagato has No immunity ! just NO immunity against Tsukuyomi or any others of itachi's Genjutsu in general ! against Itachi ; Only few may have A chance IF itachi didn't use Tsukuyomi ; but Only One can break the Tsukuyomi : sasuke
Nagato is One of those few : Nagato can Win Only If itachi Didn't use Genjutsus including Tsukuyomi or susanoo ; wich is hard to believe ; Itachi is a genjutsu Specialist ! and a sealing master with totsuka no tsurugi! (it was prooven in their edo battle there was nothing Nagato could do !! ) (Rinnegan don't give immunity against Visual Genjutsu)

Shared vision is a kind of immunity. He have 8 different summons + he can multiply the dogs. And every dog must be killed by Amaterasu or sucked up by Totsuka, all of this cost tons of chakra.

And if all the summons runs after him he wont even have enough time to cast a Genjutsu, while Nagato can prepare his techs.

 

[Itachi Uchiwa]

Do you have proof to support this claim? If you do I'd love to see the scan where Itachi traps nagato in a genjutsu.

Same goes for you ! I'd love to see the scan where nagato got away from a genjutsu ; (NONE) BUt i Give you the evidence of sword of totsuka ! the blade holds hypnotic that get the victim in an eternal genjutsu ; (eventhough no one got away from it ;that makes Itachi having the upper hand) and as it's said above ; Itachi is way Smarter than nagato !

 

[Mygenjutsu]

Draw cause theyre deemed as equals.

You must be registered for see images

nagato was auto proof to be at a high level.Pain wrecked konoha solo then unwreck it back.
but itachi is still busy getting to show us more proof. he showed some good effective resistance against nagato.While nagato didn mean to hurt them. lol
i mean he will wreck kabuto somehow and then maybe you finally understand the manga pic above ^^.

i mean pain is wrecking people of hatred lol
and itachi is wrecking people for peace and preventing wars lol.

lol simple explanation ever :flaw:xdxd

 

[Itachi Uchiwa]

Shared vision is a kind of immunity. He have 8 different summons + he can multiply the dogs. And every dog must be killed by Amaterasu or sucked up by Totsuka, all of this cost tons of chakra.

And if all the summons runs after him he wont even have enough time to cast a Genjutsu, while Nagato can prepare his techs.

Susanoo with Sword of totsuka to seal the caster would be a good choise for itachi to make in this case ! the summons vanishes when the caster is down : btw susnoo will protect itachi the second he needs to stab Nagato
the shared vision : Itachi stroke the rinnegans with his Shuriken Jutsu ! he abused that Field of Vision !