Nagato vs EMS Madara

[OnPoint]

I'm interested to see what the general consensus is around here. I looked this topic up before but to be honest, those other threads were filled with complete and utter doo doo. I'm also bored and looking for a good debate.

Nagato is fully mobile and has Gedo Mazo w/o the Bijuu. This is Nagato, not Pain.

Madara has the Eternal Mangekyou Sharingan (no Rinnegan or Mokuton), Perfect Susanoo but no Kyuubi.

Both ninjas are bloodlusted.

To the idiots out there (you know who you are), refrain from posting in this thread, I won't think twice about reporting you for spamming. I just want a high quality debate.

 

[Prince of Persia TTT]

Nagato is healthy or not?

since he is healthy he wins mid diff atmost

 

[ItachiSan03]

Use the search bar, about a month ago there was a huge wave of threads about this.... It's also a highly flammable topic....

Anyways i say nagato.

 

[OnPoint]

Nagato is healthy or not?

since he is healthy he wins mid diff atmost

Healthy/Mobile, same thing.

Use the search bar, about a month ago there was a huge wave of threads about this.... It's also a highly flammable topic....

Anyways i say nagato.

Did you read the first paragraph?

 

[Forsberg]

If Nagato has Gedo Mazo it does not matter who he is up against. He will just rip their souls out with that spirit dragon

 

[SasoriOfTheRedSaand]

Nagato, high diff.

 

[Jyuubislayer]

I voted EMS by accident but I choose Nagato.

 

[SilverSlick]

Rinnegan>EMS.

 

[Naruto N. Uzumaki]

nagato

 

[markdabomb22]

I give this to nagato with high diff

 

[Hipster Madara]

Nagato would win until we see more of EMS Madara.

P.S
Wrong section.

 

[Prince of Persia TTT]

Healthy/Mobile, same thing.



Did you read the first paragraph?

yeah so he wins mid diff
ps susano can be handled by gedo mazo with the dragon soul
genjutsu is not effective as well U_U

 

[OnPoint]

:/ Need someone to give a big argument for Madara.

 

[Out Of Ctrl]

Nagato high diff. EMS Madara is outgunned as well as overwhelmed by Nagato's attacking threats. Also the fact that Madara's ninjutsu are almost rendered useless by Preta Path ability.

Its fair to say Madara wouldn't bring out PS until the very end as that would be his trump card but Nagato's answer to PS is the Gedo Mazo, which itself is quite formidable in raw power and strength.

 

[Winter Savior]

Why would you limit Nagato and make such an uneven match?

This isn't even worth discussion because EMS Madara would beat Nagato most times. Not because he is better, but because he is an Edo, but Nagato would have a small chance but very small because he doesn't have sealing and if this is a straight up fight then Madara won't be playing around like he is with the Kages. If this was Edo Nagato vs. Edo Madara, then Nagato would be very much in Nagato's favor, as would normal Madar vs. Nagato because Nagato could take Madara's soul either way.

 

[~Dream~]

Nagato wins this. Rinnegan > Eternal Mangekyo Sharingan

 

[HiddenSound]

If Nagato is fully mobile and has Gedo Mazo he can use the Soul Dragon technique he used on ROOT and the Ame ninja. So I give this to Nagato high dif.

 

[SilverSlick]

:/ Need someone to give a big argument for Madara.

Madara has....**** it, Nagato still wins.

 

[Forsberg]

Why would you limit Nagato and make such an uneven match?

This isn't even worth discussion because EMS Madara would beat Nagato most times. Not because he is better, but because he is an Edo, but Nagato would have a small chance but very small because he doesn't have sealing and if this is a straight up fight then Madara won't be playing around like he is with the Kages. If this was Edo Nagato vs. Edo Madara, then Nagato would be very much in Nagato's favor, as would normal Madar vs. Nagato because Nagato could take Madara's soul either way.

The guy can rip souls out.

 

[HiddenSound]

Why would you limit Nagato and make such an uneven match?

This isn't even worth discussion because EMS Madara would beat Nagato most times. Not because he is better, but because he is an Edo, but Nagato would have a small chance but very small because he doesn't have sealing and if this is a straight up fight then Madara won't be playing around like he is with the Kages. If this was Edo Nagato vs. Edo Madara, then Nagato would be very much in Nagato's favor, as would normal Madar vs. Nagato because Nagato could take Madara's soul either way.

He said EMS Madara not Edo Madaara. It's Nagato vs the Madara that fought Hashirama.