[Discussion] my top 40

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Love these lists things, idk why but it takes lot of prep to make etc. these are my list of top 40 in One Piece (excluding Whitebeard, rodger, shiki because they are legends and theres no way to see more of them except through flashback and weevile because idk what to do with him.) note this list is Personal opinion and I've based it on portryal, feats , hype (note if some things such as hype and feats clash, they affect the character negatively in my eyes for example your ranked in this order but you got beat by this guy etc..)

top 40

My first 10 Note: if they are next to each other that means they are in same league or its not clear whos stronger. However they are in order who I feel would have edge overall

Kaido

Akainu/Shanks/Big mam/Dragon

akoiji/kizaru/Ben Beckman

Mihawk/Blackbeard


Numbers 11-20


fujitoria/Marco (by feats of keeping admirals busy for period of time, hype character comparison on teach)

Garp/Sengoku/Rayleigh (hype)

Dofflamingo (Hype feats portryal)

Jack/Sabo/Kuma (did not know how to seperate this but jack and sabo is here because of hype though neither of them has the feats to beat those said above.. thier feats and or abilities (for example mammoth against anything flying is ... not productive)

Shiliew (seems very important member to BB)


Numbers 21-30


Jozu (feats against a admiral akoiji)

Ivankov (hype as important officer to Dragon.. as well as tutor to sanji one of main fighters etc.)

Luffy/Vista (luffys feats PTS.. Vista feats against Mihawk)

Law/Hancock (Laws feats PTS, Hancock hype and feat on how she took the pacficstas down so easily)

Kidd (Luffys main rival along with law)/Lucci

Vergo (not exactly sure if above zoro but def feel like stronger haki and is faster whereas zoro might potentially be a little bit physically stronger without vergos muscled powerup and zoro asura.)

Zoro (Mihawk training hype, mountain slash feat)

Enel (destructive feats to anyone who isnt rubber but got beat pts luffy)


Numbers 31-40


megllagan (same thing as enel just poison)

Xdrake (dont know where to place him)

Ace (needs haki)

Sanji (needs phsycial feats his speed feats post timeskip however has been very impressive)

Crocodile (needs feats)

Jinbe/Smoker (both feats made thier hype signifcantly lower)

Pica

Robin

Cavendish



Have at it guys lol want to get some debating going and please do not make this a this guy vs this guy thread lol
post yours if you want
that was hard

You must be registered for see images

 

[Kingu]

Fujitora's DF is stronger than Kizaru's, since gravity can bend light.

 

[Venomous Cobra]

Dont see how either Xdrake or ace beat sanji. Also why are aokiji and kizaru below the yonko? same with BB

Ivankov shouldnt be that high, it is implied that most of sanji;s improvement were due to self-training. But yeah he might be, he seems the closet to dragon.

 

[WoldOfFingo]

Ben Beckman with Aokiji and Kizaru? U believe Ben Beckman , Shanks's first mate could fight Akainu for 10 days?
Also Ben Beckman is > the greatest swordsman??

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Dont see how either Xdrake or ace beat sanji. Also why are aokiji and kizaru below the yonko? same with BB

Ivankov shouldnt be that high, it is implied that most of sanji;s improvement were due to self-training. But yeah he might be, he seems the closet to dragon.

for yonko admiral i feel like akoiji is getting pretty old so his stamina could potentailly affect him (which is why he acts so lazy) and akoiji lost to akainu and akainu is fleet admiral so thought they if anything have the power to combat yonko most

ivankov i do not feel is weak ppl think he is but his portryal suggest that hes important to dragon he had never been hurt by anything until he took a magma punch from akainu who is a fleet admiral.. he was able to square off against robot kuma and was virtually immune to meglgellan etc

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Ben Beckman with Aokiji and Kizaru? U believe Ben Beckman , Shanks's first mate could fight Akainu for 10 days?
Also Ben Beckman is > the greatest swordsman??

he should be able to the real reason shanks hype is so real is because Shanks is mentor to main char yes but you have to realize shanks has crew like luffy so max like 10 people.. so hes only one of yonko to maintain amount of territory without having army which is why i see beckman being strong as **** also kizaru did portray recoginition to beckmans presence (not fear but recognition)

as for mihawk ... hes very hard to place until see more of them tbh BB is only up there due to two devil fruits and hype

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Fujitora's DF is stronger than Kizaru's, since gravity can bend light.

dont think OP will go to far but could be wrong but fuji needs more better feats againsts stronger chars

 

[YellowFang]

Nah, lists are flawed and spark more controversy than any other thing...
Tier lists are good though, where few characters are real close to each other's level and you don't have to specify who is stronger and who's weaker, avoids flame wars.

 

[jiraiya lives]

Fujitora's DF is stronger than Kizaru's, since gravity can bend light.

When has Fujitora shown the level of gravity that can bend light to a degree in which will compromise Kizaru's fighting abilities?

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

This Beckman wank is getting out of control, at this rate, he's going to replace Crocodile as the most overrated character. We 've had two threads today where the OP says that Beckman is stronger than a Yonko. It should be obvious to anyone with an IQ higher than their shoe size that a Yonko is stronger than a Yonko first mate.

 

[Vandenre1ch]

1-Roger/WB
2-Garp(almost killed Roger many times)
3-Shiki(directly said he was equal to Roger & WB in a databook)
4-Kaidou
5-Dragon
6-Mihawk
7-Shanks
8-Akainu
9-Big Mom
10-Kuzan
11-BB
12-Fujitora
13-Kizaru
14-Green Bull
15-Benn Beckmann
16-Old Sengoku
17-Old Rayleigh(showed fatigue fighting Kizaru)
18-Marco
19-Jack
20-Jozu
21-Doflamingo
22-Boa Hancock
23-Sabo
24-Nekomamushi & Inurashi
25-Vista
26-Ivankov
27-Luffy
28-Kidd
29-Law
30-Jinbe
31-Ace
32-Drake
33-Hawkins
34-Apoo
35-Zoro
36-Sanji
37-Vergo
38-Caesar
39-Croc
40-Smoker

 

[Uzumaki Macho]

1-Roger/WB
2-Garp(almost killed Roger many times)
3-Shiki(directly said he was equal to Roger & WB in a databook)
4-Kaidou
5-Dragon
6-Mihawk
7-Shanks
8-Akainu
9-Big Mom
10-Kuzan
11-BB
12-Fujitora
13-Kizaru
14-Green Bull
15-Benn Beckmann
16-Old Sengoku
17-Old Rayleigh(showed fatigue fighting Kizaru)
18-Marco
19-Jack
20-Jozu
21-Doflamingo
22-Boa Hancock
23-Sabo
24-Nekomamushi & Inurashi
25-Vista
26-Ivankov
27-Luffy
28-Kidd
29-Law
30-Jinbe
31-Ace
32-Drake
33-Hawkins
34-Apoo
35-Zoro
36-Sanji
37-Vergo
38-Caesar
39-Croc
40-Smoker

1. Sabo should be above Doffy and Jozu since he is Dragon's right hand man. Saying Hancock is above the likes of Sabo is completely baseless.
2. There's no way that someone like Ivankov is above Luffy.
3. Jinbe and Ace are too high. Jinbe was portrayed as close to Sanji at FI.

 

[Vandenre1ch]

1. Sabo should be above Doffy and Jozu since he is Dragon's right hand man. Saying Hancock is above the likes of Sabo is completely baseless.
2. There's no way that someone like Ivankov is above Luffy.
3. Jinbe and Ace are too high. Jinbe was portrayed as close to Sanji at FI.

1-Just because he is Dragon's right hand doesn't mean he is god. He couldn't even scratch Fujitora even before the latter got serious, something that Luffy was able to do. Sabo also had to try against Burgess in their 10 minute fight.

Jozu had the strength to tussle with/stalemate Kuzan without getting scratched before he got distracted.

I also don't see Sabo going toe-to-toe with G4 Luffy when Burgess could keep Sabo busy and put scratches on him.
2-Iva>G2/G3 Luffy imo. Iva had the strength to hold off Akainu by himself similar to Marco. Luffy would still get swatted aside by Akainu.

3. Jinbe was also portrayed to be close to Luffy in their little scuffle. He was even disappointed with the power of Luffy's G2 Jet Stamp after he blocked it.