My thoughts on if Hagoromo ever had Sharingan

[Darth AniCetuS]

Not necessarily at least i think its a possibility , not like u making it seem impossible

I was never against it, if he's indeed working then more canon for us but right now its all filler.

 

[Edogawa]

That doesn't prove anything because Sasuke has both Indra's and Rikudou's chakra. Hagoromo only has Rikudou's Chakra and nothing else.

...

You must be registered for see images

 

[NarutoX28]

...

You must be registered for see images

All right and how does that proven your point? Hagoromo has Indra's Spiritual Energy, but because it's molded with Ashura's Physical Energy, Hagoromo has a completely different chakra known as Rikudou's Chakra.

Sasuke not only has Rikudou's Chakra, but also Indra's.

Think of it like this:

Sasuke = (Ashura + Indra) + Indra
Rikudou = (Ashura + Indra)

Even if you'd argue that Hagoromo had Indra's chakra, Sasuke has the Tomoes because he has more of Indra's Yin Energy than Hagoromo does.

 

[Edogawa]

All right and how does that proven your point? Hagoromo has Indra's Spiritual Energy, but because it's molded with Ashura's Physical Energy, Hagoromo has a completely different chakra known as Rikudou's Chakra.

Sasuke not only has Rikudou's Chakra, but also Indra's.

Think of it like this:

Sasuke = (Ashura + Indra) + Indra
Rikudou = (Ashura + Indra)

Even if you'd argue that Hagoromo had Indra's chakra, Sasuke has the Tomoes because he has more of Indra's Yin Energy than Hagoromo does.

I'm not interested in your formula or conspiracy theory. Indra has the Rikudou's Chakra because he inherited it as Hagoromo's son. This is basic biology. Indra was said to have inherited Hagoromo's eyes and Asura inherited Hagoromo's body, and Indra was shown to only possess the Sharingan, thus he must have inherited it, which supports the evidence of Hagoromo's Sharingan. These are facts. Your whole yin yang formula is invalid.

 

[Floydical]

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Sasuke said that Amenotejikara was a result of Hagoromo's power. Amenotejikara is a Rinnegan technique. Sasuke's Rinnegan displayed it can use Sharingan power too, as seen when he hit Kaguya with Amatersu. Therefore, that proves Hagoromo had the Sharingan too. Truth denial doesn't help.

How does that prove Hagoromo had Shairngan? I don't think you get the definition of actual proof. Just because Sasuke can use Sharingan techs with Rinnegan DOES NOT MEAN HAGOROMO HAD SHARINGAN. All that means is that Sasuke had the new Rinnegan tech added to his Sharingan powers. If anything, it proves Sasuke's case was different than hagoromo's since he had additional jutsu. Until Hagoromo uses Amaterasu in the manga, you can't prove he had Sharingan.

I'm not interested in your formula or conspiracy theory. Indra has the Rikudou's Chakra because he inherited it as Hagoromo's son. This is basic biology. Indra was said to have inherited Hagoromo's eyes and Asura inherited Hagoromo's body, and Indra was shown to only possess the Sharingan, thus he must have inherited it, which supports the evidence of Hagoromo's Sharingan. These are facts. Your whole yin yang formula is invalid.

You are taking statements too literally. Hagoromo's eyes were a regression from Kaguya's, he didn't receive the full Sharinnegan. Indra inheriting his eyes meant the exact same thing, he received a regressed form of the Rinnegan, the Sharingan. Nothing you or fire state are actual proofs, no real evidence from the manga points to Hagoromo having Sharingan.

 

[NarutoX28]

I'm not interested in your formula or conspiracy theory. Indra has the Rikudou's Chakra because he inherited it as Hagoromo's son. This is basic biology. Indra was said to have inherited Hagoromo's eyes and Asura inherited Hagoromo's body, and Indra was shown to only possess the Sharingan, thus he must have inherited it, which supports the evidence of Hagoromo's Sharingan. These are facts. Your whole yin yang formula is invalid.

Except Indra doesn't have Rikudou's Chakra, he had his Spiritual Energy. When combined with Ashura's Chakra, it forms Rikudou's Chakra. Clearly, there is a distinction between the two.

You also shouldn't even be looking at the statement literally considering the word, Eyes are literally quoted, so it's not intended to be taken literally. He inherited the Sage's Eyes because Hagoromo's Yin Energy gave Indra access to an Ocular ability. Hagoromo never had the Sharingan because the Sharingan is a reflection of the Uchiha's Power and are considered the Eyes of the Uchiha. The Rinnegan is considered the Sage's Eyes.

Sasuke received the Tomoes on his Rinnegan because he was reflecting both Hagoromo's and Indra's chakra which was the main point. Rikudou's Chakra reflects the Rinnegan and Indra's Chakra reflects the Sharingan. When both chakras are used, both ocular abilities are reflected simultaneously. Rikudou's own chakra reflected his own Rinnegan, but he never reflected Indra's chakra in addition to it, so his Rinnegan lacked the Tomoes whereas Sasuke's didn't.