[Discussion] My One Piece Read Through Thread

[24 12 11 to troll]

Just drop the hints, the let me tell you this, i'll just reveal a bit.., or this character will be so much stronger in the future.

It's f'ing annoying when you're trying to read or watch something and you're constantly bothered with this. This guy does his best to name every chapter and page he is on yet you find it necessary to talk about future stuff. Why would you do that ?

Now drop the victim act and stop pointing at me, because you're the dickhead here.

Well considering my "spoiler" wouldn't have changed a thing, nothing groundbreaking. The only spoiler content in there was the name of some characters which would've been revealed or already been revealed by the point in the manga he was reaching (we're talking pages here), since there was nothing spectacular or story changing mentioned; I still fail to see why you had to go on your frequent tantrums.

Spoiler

But drop the argument about the names, it's completely fine. The spoiler could have been much, much worse, so like 3 names weren't that bad

I respect that this guy is making a HUGE effort. And I appreciate it, on the otherhand you and your hateful comments directed towards me and attempting to persecute me will only ruin the thread, discussion and fun of things. So I suggest you simply leave it be. It's not an act if the substance which my statements are based on are real.

On topic:
CCV... which of Enels priests do you like the most and why? Also : which one do you think is the strongest?

 

[TheCCV]

CCV... which of Enels priests do you like the most and why? Also : which one do you think is the strongest?

The guy with the pointy spider hair. I like him most because he was funny and did things hilariously backwards. The one I think is the strongest... is probably him as well. He's just like the Flash, he has the potential to be the absolute most powerful, but had to be dumbed down so he could be beat.

And now, onto 274.

Spoiler

2: *Not their treasure.
Never was their treasure.
The island was never theirs to begin with.
What don't they get.

3: Because they don't WANT to ****ing compromise their land that belongs to them. Once again, they're acting like they're ****ing obligated to what doesn't belong to them. Just because it's within reach doesn't mean it's yours, what don't you *******s understand about that.

God these people make me so angry. They have no right to feel angry that the owners of that land don't want to share. And 'compromise'? Really? Gtfo. YOU deserve no pity.

5:

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

8: So... he's from the ground earth?
What a twist. But he's twisted as hell if he thinks that's where god lives.

14: If you have time to sweat and have a flashback, you have time to react.
Dodge, Gan

15: Damn...

16: Water, of course.
Drive him to the edge of the island and expose him to water. He'll not only lose his power, but then 'malfunction' and shock himself.

20: GOD DAMMIT PEOPLE!
DOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOODGE!

 

[Skylar Knight]

The Naruto equivalent of what I said was "Naruto is stronger in Part 2 than in part 1" its not really even a spoiler its just manga logic

You pretty much revealed the power scaling in One Piece by saying Roger was "so and so" much stronger. You didn't just reveal the strength of the main character, but also Roger, the Pirate King. It was obvious that Roger was stronger than our heroes, but not by so many inches. I'm not saying I'd be bothered by such a minor spoiler, but some people would, and I think you should respect that.

VM me if you're at all interested to discuss this any further.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

You pretty much revealed the power scaling in One Piece by saying Roger was "so and so" much stronger. You didn't just reveal the strength of the main character, but also Roger, the Pirate King. It was obvious that Roger was stronger than our heroes, but not by so many inches. I'm not saying I'd be bothered by such a minor spoiler, but some people would, and I think you should respect that.

VM me if you're at all interested to discuss this any further.

May I just point out that the power scaling in One Piece is still unclear now.

 

[Olorin]

You pretty much revealed the power scaling in One Piece by saying Roger was "so and so" much stronger. You didn't just reveal the strength of the main character, but also Roger, the Pirate King. It was obvious that Roger was stronger than our heroes, but not by so many inches. I'm not saying I'd be bothered by such a minor spoiler, but some people would, and I think you should respect that.

VM me if you're at all interested to discuss this any further.

Scaling of power in OP is completely unclear, we have no idea how powerful each tiers will be

Naruto in the Chuunin exams is 0.1 to Madaras 1000 now ... Goku in the Saiyan arc is nothing compared to ssj3 goku

OMG such spoilers, complete twist, it defies manga logic

Anyways this post will be last on on that matter, have a nice day mr knight

Special thanks @ Love Cook, nice tantrum

 

[crono0929]

dont stop reading BRO!!!

stick it out until the end, you wont be disappointed.

and using roger to scale power does not make sense, since we dont even know how strong he was...even now..

 

[Lili-Chwan]

Okay, for once and for all, yes, Love Cook is right. Anything that hasn't been revealed yet is a spoiler. There are varying degrees of spoilers, but that degree is not something you get to decide, it is something every reader figures out for themselves. No one has the right to say anything that could potentially ruin any part of a story. What constitutes as something important to you is not the same for everyone else. Having been spoiled already with stuff that people thought was unimportant, I can relate to the frustration. So yes, pay attention to what you say in this thread. TheCCV is being very clear about where exactly he is in the story, so there is not excuse to deviate from that, even if you consider it unimportant information, or even if you're just correcting him on something that will be corrected in 1 or 2 chapters.

And yes, Love Cook threw a temper tantrum. Big deal, you did too, and so did Rinnemaki, and so did everyone who perpetuated this stupid conversation. Just chill out, and stop spamming.


Anywho, hope you're having fun, TheCCV, ignore these setbacks

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Yeah you're the epitome of perfection, mother theresa of NarutoBase, Ghandi and Mandela have nothing on you. You are the greatest user ever, too bad that you have a bad short term memory about you behavior in other threads and even in this thread just a page ago. You're the spoiler guy, you get out.

When did I say I was? I simply said that you're a fragile being.

Okay, for once and for all, yes, Love Cook is right. Anything that hasn't been revealed yet is a spoiler. There are varying degrees of spoilers, but that degree is not something you get to decide, it is something every reader figures out for themselves. No one has the right to say anything that could potentially ruin any part of a story. What constitutes as something important to you is not the same for everyone else. Having been spoiled already with stuff that people thought was unimportant, I can relate to the frustration. So yes, pay attention to what you say in this thread. TheCCV is being very clear about where exactly he is in the story, so there is not excuse to deviate from that, even if you consider it unimportant information, or even if you're just correcting him on something that will be corrected in 1 or 2 chapters.

The thing is... what I said wasn't really a spoiler. Even if it was TheCCV didn't really mind or care.

And yes, Love Cook threw a temper tantrum. Big deal, you did too, and so did Rinnemaki, and so did everyone who perpetuated this stupid conversation. Just chill out, and stop spamming.

I don't think a tantrum and a initially courteous response to a tantrum are the same thing.

 

[Olorin]

Okay, for once and for all, yes, Love Cook is right. Anything that hasn't been revealed yet is a spoiler. There are varying degrees of spoilers, but that degree is not something you get to decide, it is something every reader figures out for themselves. No one has the right to say anything that could potentially ruin any part of a story. What constitutes as something important to you is not the same for everyone else. Having been spoiled already with stuff that people thought was unimportant, I can relate to the frustration. So yes, pay attention to what you say in this thread. TheCCV is being very clear about where exactly he is in the story, so there is not excuse to deviate from that, even if you consider it unimportant information, or even if you're just correcting him on something that will be corrected in 1 or 2 chapters.

And yes, Love Cook threw a temper tantrum. Big deal, you did too, and so did Rinnemaki, and so did everyone who perpetuated this stupid conversation. Just chill out, and stop spamming.


Anywho, hope you're having fun, TheCCV, ignore these setbacks

I wasnt referring to LC in this thread

 

[TheCCV]

I just read like 2 sentences of this page after my post. Contained something on Rogers strength. Luckily I didn't finish it.
And from now on, no spoilers. none, nada, zilch, smell me. It'll be different if I ask a question that's totally up for answers, that's different.

But still do your best to refrain from giving away too much in your answers... just hint at it. But not too obvi. And if that's too hard, just don't both answering. Thanks all.

And I DID IT!!!
I REACHED CHAPTER 300 YESTERDAY!!!
Sadly, I wasn't here to let you in on all of my reactions, because some family stuff happened and got me really, really mad. So I'll just review it.

So...

Most memorable quotes were-
'Who are you?'
'God.'

'She was a girl!'
'I noticed.'

And 'If you want to live, then why are you so weak?'

Loved those two.

Favorite characters were
Enel.

Spoiler

Loved his design. Loved his personality. Loved his sarcasm. Loved his whole God complex and fitting powers.
To elaborate on design, look at him.

You must be registered for see images

Despite looking like an anime-esque Eminem, he's very well designed, everything about him is distinct from the eye brows to the nose-bars to the due-rag (which is probably called something else in their culture), to the barrel inspired baggy shorts, which I am also a fan of. I myself have a habit of wearing baggy, long shorts but that's just cus they're comfortable and I don't wear them all crazy. But that's beside the point. Everything about him just appeals to me. He is a very well designed character.

Next, personality. He's not a 'dark corner sitting' ******* who tries to be edgier than razor-blade factories. He's humorous, nonchalant, calm (except for that 1 page), almighty powerful, and like I said before, isn't as 1-dimensional as 'kill *****es get money', he had genuine knowledge on his goal and was educated on the history behind his motives. His humor also came from his ego and narcissism which was also very standoffish, but attractive as well. To elaborate on that razor-blade statement as well, I liked that he was a very social character. I didn't realize that I liked these types of things until this arc, but I like characters who are social and 'out there in the crowd'. What I mean by that, is that he's not afraid to get his hands dirty. He was out there in the battle field with his ex-army (you know... before he killed them and all), and fighting off the Strawhats and heroes. Better than other main-course villains who sit in the background until push comes to shove and then head out for battle. But... to be completely honest, that may be a tad bias of me, since to an extent other villains would eventually step out on the arena, but idk. Enels approach to it just stood out to me more.

Norland.

Spoiler

He was a very dedicated and caring man with the strength to flip over a battle ship, and was motivated by his own tragedy to assist and prevent it from happening to other communities, even though he was ridiculed, threatened with death, and even had his whole entire crew held captive. So in other words, he didn't just have the cheese or the peppers, but the whole enchilada to say 'screw this' and high tail it out of there. But he didn't. He suffered the agonizing pain of being crushed by 2 cliffs and still convince his murderer to let him save his island. And then after a number of events, he ended up being hated but still loving him as a brother. I can confirm that takes tons of humility guys, I have the utmost respect for him for that.

I love his story. Was a real tearjerker. He was a real sailor who remained faithful to his words and reports, refusing to pierce his pride with the false convictions of being a liar. Explained the crying snake and it's history with the island how the war started, the significance of the bell, and why exactly Waipa was so determined to ring it, which brings me to my next character.

Waipa.

Spoiler

He was a walking tank with a edgy design, as well as the personality to back it up. I liked his weapon and everything about him. What really stuck out most to me was his determination and persistence to stand up. It actually showed that he has a more powerful body than Zoro, Gan-fall and even his comrades.

Favorite parts were the flashback of Norland, and the first round of Luffy and Enel.

My biggest gripe with the final battle was what I couldn't tell what the **** was going on, the inking was really hard to see through. It's probably just my bad eyes, but there's 3 levels of detail as I see it. 1) Lightly detailed, where everything is very easy to see and make out at the cost of detail, 2) Perfectly detailed, pages that perfectly communicate actions and the detail to make them pop, and 3) Too detailed, where it all clusters together. On a scale of 1 to 3 of the final battle, I give it a heavy 4. I had a really really tought time seeing what was going on, unlike the Alabarna arc with Crocodile. I could clearly see what was happening between Luffy and Croc, probably due to the locations and junk, but still. Hopefully the next big battle is less cluttery.

So yeah, that was my review. Next up, 301.

 

[TheCCV]

301

Spoiler

2: LUFFY! I'm appalled.

3: Not even gonna lie, this is the most piraty thing they've ever done.

10: Next up: 'Nico... you are our descendant.'

12: Next up: 'Nico... you are Gold Rogers.'

I KNEW IT! I KNEW IT WAS ROGERS!! From the first moment he mentioned being friends with a pirate, there was nobody else I could think of but him. Meels food gan.

16: And the paralleling begins.

I guarantee Sanji and Zoro are also a part of the lost history as well.

19: I wonder where Nami was in all this. At the ship prob.

 

[Hexuze]

Just shut up man, why would you post this when he is only chapters away from finding this out himself. It's not like they're groundbreaking spoilers, but that makes it even more senseless. Why post this ? can't you contain yourself or do you like to be the guy in the cinema who tells what's going to happen 5 seconds before it actually happens. This is a review thread so just talk about your guerilla friends when he reached that part himself. If he thinks Enel is the island let him think that and let him find out on his own

rofl omg man :')

Funniest analogy I've seen in a while...

 

[kibainuzuka]

who's your favorite till now?

 

[TheCCV]

Its a toss up between Captain smoker and Enel.
Leaning more towards Enel though.

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Its a toss up between Captain smoker and Enel.
Leaning more towards Enel though.

I like those two characters myself!

So what arc is your favorite arc so far?

 

[kibainuzuka]

Its a toss up between Captain smoker and Enel.
Leaning more towards Enel though.

Smoker all the day,then comes a guy named Marco,dont want to spoil you anything you will find him out by yourself

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

Smoker all the day,then comes a guy named Marco,dont want to spoil you anything you will find him out by yourself

I feel sorry for you... Now Skylar will neg you and Love Cook will throw a tantrum and direct all of his spite towards you...

 

[crono0929]

dont say any names of characters tho...."you going to find out yourself"....then let him...

 

[TheCCV]

Well, before this thing starts up again, I've decided to make my own 'crew' of supporters, for those who kept me on their tab the whole way. To join the crew, simply answer all the questions in OP, credit to Frikid for making them.

Thanks all and happy posting!

EDIT: Wait, what the heck? Why can't I edit the OP?

 

[Shinichi Izumi]

I haven't posted on this thread for a while, sorry. Just read through your recent reviews, very interesting! Your opinions on power levels are way off though lol. The next arc is one of my least favorites, but the one after is one of the best in one piece. Hope you keep reading, GOOD LUCK!