[Photoshop] My First Signature

[-Carnage-]

Nice one for a first one u.u

A few things you can fix are making sure the render is behind the border. and make the border thinner. >_>
And you may want to avoid adding text until you get the hang of adjustments, lighting, render placement, etc. Text is the devil, i still have trouble with making it look good with my signatures >_<
keep it up ^.^

 

[Voltron]

Not gonna lie. It needs a lot of work

1) it's too small
2) lighting on the render is horrible and doesn't match lighting from background
3) there's no depth.
4) render is low quality. >.>
5) it lacks fractals, c4ds and special effects
6) blending isn't the best.
7) the text is too light.

For a first attempt, it's not too bad