[VS] Minato vs. Itachi: Let's settle this once and for all.

[Barrath]

As you all know, one of the most debated versus battles discussed on NB is Minato vs. Itachi. I have a propositon. We pick two of the the NB communities most well known and respected arena battle role players. One will represent Minato, and one will represent Itachi. They then will RP 5 - 10 battles. Best of the 5-10 wins respectively. Does anyone like my idea? Did I even put this thread in the right place? Keep feed back contructive. Thanks guys

-Barrath

 

[Lilt]

Blaze Release is the best Itachi poster imo. I'm not sure about Minato posters.

Though the debate won't put anything to rest, honestly. Here's a thread from years ago, long before Edo Itachi.

You must be registered for see links

Yet Itachi vs Jiraiya is still debated endlessly lol.

 

[Ψ Veritas Ψ]

EQUAL EQUAL EQUAL

End.

 

[Minator93]

Minato wins this,he has all the answers to Itachi's attacks and can come out as the victor if the two of them were to face each other in ideal conditions.

Read the following

Minato vs Sharingan Itachi :

Spoiler

Minato can beat Sharingan Itachi.

Minato has more speed,raw strength,chakra, powerful summons, seals.

Further he did beat Sharingan Tobi [MS Obito].

Minato vs Amaterasu :

Spoiler

A Few thing from wiki :

Spoiler

A using his Lightning Release Armour enhanced Body Flicker Technique avoided a short-range Amaterasu launched at him by Sasuke in an instant.

The only thing that the flames have failed to burn into or through is Gaara's chakra-infused sand. However, the flames burn fairly slowly, sometimes allowing anyone struck by Amaterasu an opportunity to remove whatever clothing or body parts have been caught ablaze. Nagato was able to deflect the flames from his body using Shinra Tensei. Use of the technique also puts a great deal of strain on the user, usually causing their eyes to bleed.

Minato dodged A's FULL speed the picture is in the Susanoo section below.
We've seen that A who wasn't even using his full speed dodged Sasuke's Amaterasu [Which according to Shee was better than Itachi's] at very close range. So Minato can do the same with more ease.

So even if Minato gets hit by Amaterasu he being the fastest of them all and thanks to s/t can save himself by teleporting himself back to his safe house. He did this when Tobi had bombed new-born Naruto.

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Plus Itachi can't use Amaterasu very often it affects him badly because he lacks the Eternal

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

One more thing Jiraya sealed Amaterasu. So its safe to assume that Minato being the sealing master he is can do the same with more ease.

Minato vs Tsukuyomi :

Spoiler

Tsukuyomi requires eye contact to be performed. Its a short Ranged Genjutsu and to my knowledge the root knew about it and It hasn't killed a single soul.

Guy was confident to go up against Itachi w/out Eye contact a Jounin os his calibre can fight w/pot eye contact. Further its common knowledge that when fighting a Sharingan user avoid eye contact and that can be done.

For Itachi to trap Minato in tsukuyomi Minato need to look directly into hie eyes and that to at a cllose range which Minato will never do.

In fact Itachi can't afford to keep Minato at a close range because Minato is bad close range match up.

I mean look at all his fights all he does is to get close to the opponent, All those fodders, Tobi even A the raikage...all those pictures are posted below.

Minato vs Susanoo :

Spoiler

Minato can get past Itachi's complete Susanoo -

Here are some photos that shows that Minato can teleport in a radius of few meters around the FTG Kunai

Look at the distance

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Appearing directly above Tobi

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Marked Tobi's Back but attacked from the front

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Teleporting himself to the Kunai

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

This is the width of Itachi's Complete Susanoo

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

From the above data its pretty clear than minato can get past the susanoo via FTG Kunai i.e. Teleporting Inside of it.

Further once Minato's done that Itachi's end is fixed because his body is under enormous amount of pain He won't be able to defend himself.

There are other ways as well such as marking the ground or stones etc.

Minato can attack the susanoo itself :

Spoiler

Here we can see that Danzo used his Summon against Sasuke's Offensive, long Ranged Complete Susanoo

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

And it reduced the Susanoo to the incomplete state, the only reason it failed becasue Fire worked against the wind.

In Minato and Itachi's case Minato can use this on Itachi's Defensive Susanoo

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

Don't forget Gamabunata has water style that has advantage against Fire style.

Also this is the same summon that went up against Strong Rinnegan summons held its own against a tailed beast Shukaku and restrained a complete Kurama

Plus Minato can use this as well

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

The three most powerful toads :

Spoiler

Also before saying BS like Itachi can control them via genjutsu Consider Itachi's state and the Chakra being drained from his body [used for maintaining MS and Susanoo]. He can't do **** against them. He is not Nagato!

In fact now that I think about it Itachi cant put up a descent fight if he has to go through all these summmons.

This could also be the thing why Jiraya was so confident when we was up against Itachi and Kisame

Spoiler

You must be registered for see images

I mean yeah Itachi never intended to fight but I have 1 question, Has Jiraya ever underestimated his opponent or boasted that He would kill someone who's power would be greater than his ?

Don't you remember what he did before going up against Pain?, He summoned Gerotora because Pain was the only opponent Jiraya wasn't sure about.

One more thing before posting the pic that show Itachi blocking the Rinnegan view with shuriken, The Rinnegan summons don't think for themself they just do what the Rinnegan user wishes that's why they just charge at the opponent w/out thinking or w/out any strategy.

Also Minato avoids eye-contact when he fights an Uchiha!

If you don't believe me the click on this

You must be registered for see links

 

[ItachiStyle]

I feel confident this thread won't be "ending" anything.

I am a fan of both, and can see arguments both ways. They're in a similar sort of tier. I'd probably lean to Itachi, but not by much.

 

[enditallsin]

This has always been a debatable match imo because no matter how much and how many people try and end this battle when the smoke clears with all the other character debates its always these 2 M'fers that somehow make their ways back to each, sometimes you just come face to face with the fact that some things will never end and this debate is one of em, i don't like either one of em but imma have't to say minato.

 

[Lady Luck]

*Minator posting the same BS argument.

that by the has been refuted more than 10 times.
guess what, this will never be settled. ring kishi he will proabbaly say minato.

but in terms of feats and the evidence we have itachi is stronger and will win.

 

[Bogard]

It's obvious for me that Minato wins. I don't really understand people who think they are equal. Minator93 said it all already though

 

[Katkot]

It's obvious for me that Minato wins. I don't really understand people who think they are equal

I am not fan of itachi or even minato but come on , even blind guy will know that
Itachi has upper hand and he can win the fight ..

70% itachi
30% minato

 

[Minator93]

*Minator posting the same BS argument.

that by the has been refuted more than 10 times.
guess what, this will never be settled. ring kishi he will proabbaly say minato.

but in terms of feats and the evidence we have itachi is stronger and will win.

Oh please, if you can't counter it then don't quote it or incl my name in your post.

It's obvious for me that Minato wins. I don't really understand people who think they are equal. Minator93 said it all already though

Yep they are not equals when Minato is clearly above him!!

I am not fan of itachi or even minato but come on , even blind guy will know that
Itachi has upper hand and he can win the fight ..

70% itachi
30% minato

You must be registered for see images

 

[Champ]

Tsukuyomi rapes Minato

 

[BenjerminGaye]

itachi's fastest attacks cant touch minato but minato cant get to itachi while susanno is up. its a game of chakra reserves and thats why minato wins

 

[Cpt Long Schlong]

It's obvious for me that Minato wins. I don't really understand people who think they are equal. Minator93 said it all already though

And for every person with IQ above 50 it's obvious Itachi wins

Plus Minator did not in anyway disprove Minato looked straight into Tobi's eyes, and he wouldn't know the skill of Itachi with genjutsu, and how heavily he is orientated around it

I'm not going to discuss it here, but OT: No. Awful idea, RP represents RP'ers abilities and that only.

 

[Minator93]

And for every person with IQ above 50 it's obvious Itachi wins

Plus Minator did not in anyway disprove Minato looked straight into Tobi's eyes, and he wouldn't know the skill of Itachi with genjutsu, and how heavily he is orientated around it

I'm not going to discuss it here, but OT: No. Awful idea, RP represents RP'ers abilities and that only.

Says the guy with IQ less than 20

 

[Midday]

Minator93 raised some good points against Itachi. I personally think this fight is in Minato's favour.

 

[Cpt Long Schlong]

Says the guy with IQ less than 20

Good one, how long did it take you to think of that?

Minator93 raised some good points against Itachi. I personally think this fight is in Minato's favour.

Are you serious or not? I can't ever tell if someones joking or not when they say "Minator93 raised some good points"

Anyway do tell me how he avoids Tsukuyomi or other genjutsu when he goes in to attack Itachi, and has been shown to make eye contact with a Uchiha? A Uchiha he thought was Madara, so should of been even more careful.

inb4 minator93 "i totily counterd dat poynt he neva lookd into his eye totily camera angls man"

 

[Boston Rob]

Yeah let's settle this once and for all - Itachi is a very bad machup for Mino

 

[Kusanagi35]

How is this equal? Minato has no counter for genjutsu. He gets fodderize and that's all. I'm sick of these Minato fanboys

 

[Stark]

Oh god, Itachi > Minato. U_U

 

[Minator93]

Good one, how long did it take you to think of that?

I guess no time is required to tell a fact U_U

Are you serious or not? I can't ever tell if someones joking or not when they say "Minator93 raised some good points"

Anyway do tell me how he avoids Tsukuyomi or other genjutsu when he goes in to attack Itachi, and has been shown to make eye contact with a Uchiha? A Uchiha he thought was Madara, so should of been even more careful.

inb4 minator93 "i totily counterd dat poynt he neva lookd into his eye totily camera angls man"

Dafuq is this shit. Each and everything is posted in the argument but instead of a rebuttal you are just trolling or are you really slow?