[Discussion] MF Garp Vs TS M3

[Legend Slayer]

Who wins on what diff?
Restrictions : None

 

[A v i]

Garp beats them around mid or high dif.

 

[Kiri Starstalker]

Roronoa solos neg diff lol

 

[I'm stupid real stupid]

Garp wins

 

[Tomato God]

Garp mid diff

 

[Yusuke Urameshi]

What makes Garp so strong? Genuine question.

 

[jiraiya lives]

From what we've seen, I don't even believe that the M3 can defeat someone like Doflamingo let alone Garp :|

 

[Legend Slayer]

From what we've seen, I don't even believe that the M3 can defeat someone like Doflamingo let alone Garp :|

Your honestly saying that M3 together cant defeat mingo? Isn't luffy alone fairly near his level?

 

[OG sama]

I guess Garp wins. But theres more to this battle then him being stronger. There teamwork should come into consideration and Garp doesn't seem very agile. And his abilities seem straightforward, but I guess I give him the benefit of the doubt.

 

[Legend Slayer]

What makes Garp so strong? Genuine question.

He rivaled Whitebeard and Roger in their prime. That speaks for itself.

 

[silmarill]

What makes Garp so strong? Genuine question.

His prime is top 3 strongest in OP verse
Age decreases prime but look at WB, he was still a monster, same with Rayleigh , he could still rival an admiral in pure strength alone, he got tired faster though.
Now Rayleigh was inactive spending his day gambling and drinking , just imagine what Garp could do as a very active marine.

 

[kageking]

Garp can probably still beat all M3 1v1 but 3v1 may be too much. I see no reason why M3 loses this. M3 high diff.

 

[Hexuze]

Garp mid-diff., ofc my opinion can possibly change once we see how the Zoro vs Pica fight & Luffy vs Doffy fight ends.

 

[Bogard]

Garp high difficulty, maybe higher

 

[Ridoku X]

Garp mid-high diff v_v

 

[A v i]

Garp high difficulty, maybe higher

I'd like to know your reasons for thinking this. Just curious.

Your honestly saying that M3 together cant defeat mingo? Isn't luffy alone fairly near his level?

If Law who's on the same level as Luffy gets easily beaten by Joker then same thing will happen to Luffy in a fight which doesn't involve plot. From what we have seen, Joker should be able to solo M3.

 

[IPulseZz]

Your honestly saying that M3 together cant defeat mingo? Isn't luffy alone fairly near his level?

No lol luffy got pawned on his own against doffy. Plus doffy tanked one of luffys most powerful attacks and came out unharmed or anything lmao it didn't even affect him, kinda like when sanji attacked doffy and nothing happened to him...

And Garp pawns them so easily lmao

What makes Garp so strong? Genuine question.

He rivalled Roger & WB in his prime. I know he is out of his prime but he is still healthy unlike Whitebeard and is active unlike Rayleigh (who hasn't fought for like 20 years)

Garp would actually beat them so badly lol, everyone is overestimating the M3

 

[Bogard]

I'd like to know your reasons for thinking this. Just curious.[/FONT][/I]

Imo Doflamingo is the bridge between upper high tiers and top tiers. He is above vice-admiral level while being weaker than admiral level, capable to give an admiral level fighter a mid difficulty fight before losing. Luffy will defeat Doflamingo, maybe with plot help or not, but he'll at least prove that he can defeat a plot restricted Doflamingo, which would put him in the range of at the very least pushing a healthy Doflamingo to high difficulty and thus i see a serious Luffy capable to push an admiral in the range between higher end of low difficulty and mid end of medium difficulty.

Zoro shouldn't be much weaker than Luffy at this point, so i think he can push an admiral to the higher end of low difficulty especially when on the contrary of Luffy, he is more serious in fights. Sanji should probably push an admiral between the lower end of low difficulty and the medium range of low difficulty. Combining their powers, i see them giving an admiral a difficulty ranging between higher end of medium difficulty fight and mid end of high difficulty, especially when you know that when they attack together, they are stronger. I also consider MF Garp to be slightly weaker than an admiral, especially in the long run and because of this, the difficulty in my opinion will be between medium end of high difficulty and above the high difficulty range

 

[Pirate King]

Garp extreme high dif

 

[Dęvîa Puęrî]

Garp should be able to solo them mid diff while he doesn't seem as agile he has speed as he was able to intercept Marco rather easily and hurt him despite him being intangible none of main three have intangibility to help them blunt off garps attacks like Marco did who still got hurt

Also playing in character .. zoro is gonna try to tank ... Tht will be his down fall nothing else really needs tto be said lol

Luffy is in middle when it comes to dodging or tanking but after bellamy broke his haki have no reason to think mediocore attacks shouldn't break his haki as garp is one of the most physically strongest chars in OP ..

Sanji will be most tricky because of him being agile and really fast but tht doesn't mean nothing cuz if he tries to go up to garp like he did doffy his leg will get snapped (as well as zoro swords for the matter forgot to mention tht luffy is safe cuz of rubber lol)


Also doffy tanked one of luffy best attacks no damage .... And I believd at best doffy would push mf garp to maybe mid-semi high diff (only due to fighting style tho not exactly sure leaning towards mid)
Have no reason to believe luffy can really hurt this guy until other things have shown otherwise and also garp can dodge ..