[Theory] Marshall.D.''Theif'' [The Future of the BB Pirates Theory!!]

Uchiha Samater

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Aug 29, 2012
Messages
2,037
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Hey Guys


Most of us are aware of many of the different theories regarding Blackbeard, and how he is able to wield two Devil Fruits.


The most popular are, [in short] :

1. The Ceberus:

That Blackbeard has a Mythical Zoan fruit based on the three headed beast ''Ceberus'', which would allow him to consume multiple fruits.

2. The Chimera:

That Blackbeard's body is made up, atypically, a sort of fusion if you will that allows him to consume multiple fruits.
[some suggest that ability is also a Zoan fruit]



I disagree with these, [although not entirely]


I would like to discuss my opinion and theory on what the future holds in store for Blackbeard and the BB pirates:



Blackbeard as we know has become a Yonko, and Jinbei updated us that :

You must be registered for see images


That's quite weird, Blackbeard hasn't been using the most threatening weapon in his arsenal to take over places, why do you think that is?

I reckon its both of the following:

1. To not kill of the majority of Pirates he encounters until he assesses them
2. To not cause more and more attention on his self until he amassed an army



Let me discuss these points.


I believe Blackbeard was not using the Gura Gura no Mi, because he did not want to reach a stage where something would have had to have been done about him by the WG prior to reaching his target of creating an unbeatable army.

Now, that begs the question how would he do this?

Take a look at what Jinbei also said:

You must be registered for see images


The BB Pirates have been ''Power Hunting'' powerful devil fruit users, and have the ability to take the fruits.

I wonder who was doing that:

You must be registered for see images


That's right the good old mystery on how BB manages to steal the fruits ability.

I mean we do know that Blackbeard has a weird body to begin with even marco noticed:
You must be registered for see images



That brings me back to my point of Blackbeard amassing an army:

Jinbei said; they were power hunting and that they could take the ability of a Devil Fruit user .


Let me pose you a question:

HOW LOGICAL WOULD IT BE THAT BB HAS BEEN GIVING DEVIL FRUITS TO HIS PIRATE CREW, ATTRACTING STRONG FIGHTERS AND CREATING AN ARMY OF DEVIL FRUIT USERS!!!


That good old Blackbeard :
You must be registered for see images




Now moving on, why would BB be after such an army,, [ i mean besides being the head of a pirate war machine].

How about attaining the final stage of his plan prior to attaining One Piece.


Which is :
Getting the most powerful Mythical Zoan Fruit !!!



Take a look at Blackbeard's Jolly Roger:
You must be registered for see images


The way i see this, is a clever forshadow by Oda to mean:
You must be registered for see images


And which Devil Fruit would be ideal for someone who uses the Gura Gura no Mi, and Yami Yami no Mi?

How about :
You must be registered for see images


That's Insaaaaaaaane right!!


But wait one second, why would BB, someone who has the Yami Yami no Mi and the Gura Gura no Mi, want an army of devil fruit users to help him take on Kaidou?


Maybe because Kaidou has something similar:
You must be registered for see images




So i believe the following will happen:

1. BB will create an army he feels big enough to take on Kaidou and his Army

2. Kaidou ,[who in another theory i wrote will make way to Dressrosa], will be intercepted by Blackbeard and his army

3. EPIC clas of yonko's, where BB will be successful

4. Blackbeard takes the Zoan ability of Kaidou


Giving him :

The strongest Paramecia,
The most dangerous Logia,
The most powerful Zoan

and his Jolly Roger will actually match up.


What do you guys think
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sherlock. and zamki

Fireplay

Active member
Elite
Joined
Mar 9, 2013
Messages
5,974
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I doubt Kaido will come to Dressrosa and die to BB right when we get to see him. If anything BB wont take Kaido's DF until after Lufffy's alliance beats him.

Overall nice theory.
 

Uchiha Samater

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Aug 29, 2012
Messages
2,037
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I doubt Kaido will come to Dressrosa and die to BB right when we get to see him. If anything BB wont take Kaido's DF until after Lufffy's alliance beats him.

Overall nice theory.

Nice way of looking at it.

TBH Oda has a knack of going against predictions and being very creative, so here's hoping
 

sravan

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Dec 6, 2011
Messages
2,159
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
good theory but i think he is op as he is now and if he gets another df can SH's defeat him?????as they are now i don't think its possible
 

SSS12

Active member
Regular
Joined
Mar 29, 2012
Messages
834
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
If he does get Kaoido's, it's either after he is defeated by SH or while he is recovering from some fight. But I don;t think (and want) BB to posses all abilities of DF we have already seen. It would be less interesting that way.
I do agree that BB will most likely have 3 DF.
 

Uchiha Samater

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Aug 29, 2012
Messages
2,037
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
good theory but i think he is op as he is now and if he gets another df can SH's defeat him?????as they are now i don't think its possible
You have to remember BB will probably need time to master his use of the fruits

If you remember post marineford when he captured Bonney, he fled the island when his crewmate saw Akainu was coming

Not that he feared he would lose, but BB has a plan, and i reckon this plan has the flaw that it takes time, giving Luffy the time for progress and further development
 
  • Like
Reactions: Waindo

Waindo

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Apr 17, 2014
Messages
18,259
Kin
869💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Mindblowing theory! If he gets Kaidous zoan he will probably n1 yonkou on par with Akagami's crew.
+ rep for the effort mate, amazing job!
 

Roronoa Solos

Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2014
Messages
129
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I like your theory especially the army of devil fruit users going against Kaido's army. Luffy definitly has his work cut out for him if he plans on beating Teach, I mean what can luffy do against a yonko level fighter with the power to negate his devil fruit abilities that is so heavily intergrated into his style of fighting and possibly a list of other devil fruit abilities he's just waiting to show us.
 

jazza1017

Member
Joined
May 1, 2014
Messages
112
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Great theory, and I definitely see parts of this happening. I think one thing that you have neglected is Doflamingo's involvement in this whole thing though. If you think about it, he also has goals of becoming pirate king. If this was the case, why would he supply Kaido with smile fruits if its only going to make Kaido stronger? If you look back at when Doflamingo seemed to have controlled momonosuke back at Punk Hazard, it foreshadows that Doflamingo will play a huge part in Kaido's downfall. He could possibly be trying to make Kaido amass an army so large, that there will come a point in time where he will manipulate his army, and over throw him, possibly asserting himself as a Yonkou. Imagine a guy of celestial descent, who is a Yonkou and has the World Government at his fingertips. He suddenly becomes the most powerful character in the series. But yeah, we will have to see how this plays out, but Blackbeards motives besides stealing powerful devil fruits is still a mystery to me.
 

Grim

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Feb 17, 2010
Messages
4,493
Kin
1💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Parts of it match up and this theory is based on old theories made before... and over all it's possible because someone neesd to pick up Burgess whos locked in the cage.

there is more theories about how/who BB actually is and how he can posses 2 FD's

This is an analysis of Blackbeard to get a better understanding of his character

I wanted to start this analysis off by pointing out just how important the idea of "Inherited Will" is to this story:
  • Chopper inherited to create a cure for all diseases (Symbolized by his hat)
  • Zoro inherited the (Symbolized by her sword)
  • and Iceburg inherited regarding Pluton and protecting Water 7 (Symbolized by the Thousand Sunny)
  • Sanji inherited to find all blue (Symbolized through Zeff's fighting style)
  • Brook inherited the to meet with Laboon
  • Robin inherited the
  • Luffy inherited the and the Pirate King himself
In fact, inherited will was mentioned on the very by Gold Roger himself. It is also mentioned by Whitebeard . Pretty much every major arc in one piece deals with inherited will in one form or another. Obviously, this is a very important aspect to the series as a whole which needs to be delved into.

Here is my theory regarding Inherited Will:
I believe that there are two types of inherited will. The Unaccomplished Dream and the Grudge. I believe that Luffy and Blackbeard are . Luffy embodies life, protection, and accomplishing dreams, while Blackbeard embodies grudges, destruction, and bringing death to his predecessor's persecutors.

One of the reasons why I believe that Blackbeard embodies the grudge is because we have met another character who embodies it as well: . Hody has also been designed to look very similar to Blackbeard including the pot belly and the hair style.

Anyways some other very minor evidence includes those animated by a grudge being afraid of grudges disappearing, and Blackbeard being . This would support that Blackbeard represents the "Dark Side" of the Will of the D, while Luffy represents the "Light. It has often been speculated that the "D's" were past citizens of the Ancient Kingdom. If this were true, Blackbeard represents the grudge of resentment towards the World Government, while Luffy represents forgiveness and freedom.

I say this because on many occasions Luffy has let go of a grudge of sorts. He let go of his grudge towards Blackbeard for the sake of saving ace, he let go of his grudge towards the for beating up Usopp, he stopped listening to Jinbe almost immediately after Akainu was mentioned. He also has a major tendency to forgive former enemies like the Foxy pirates, the Boa sisters , and many others. He seems to be more concerned with protecting the living and living himself than avenging the dead and remember that Luffy and Blackbeard seem to be polar opposites.

Finally, The reason that Blackbeard was able to absorb two devil fruits. This is the only part of the analysis that I am unsure of, but I will base my opinion solely on what is presented in the manga.

First of all, look at this page here. It was stated by both Luffy and Zoro that Blackbeard is not a "He", but a "They.
You must be registered for see images
Bear in mind that Luffy and Zoro had only met Doc Q before hand and had no way of knowing he was part of Blackbeard's crew.

Secondly, is the famous "Different Body Structure" page:
You must be registered for see images

Based on these two pages, it seems to be that Blackbeard is different from a normal person. What's more, it is not in any way a secret. All of the Whitebeard pirates seemed to know about it as well. The fact that Luffy and Zoro picked up on it shouldn't be surprising then, either. So what exactly is "it"? Based on the first page, we know that Blackbeard is not a "He", but a "They". Because Blackbeard only has one body, the only possible explanation would be that Blackbeard has different entities within himself.

I believe that Blackbeard, through inheriting an ancient grudge, has also inherited the will of another person; someone who wishes to fulfill that same grudge. This will shares a body/mind with Blackbeard himself.

If Blackbeard has two different wills within himself, this would mean that:
1. They can both be sensed with Haki (Observation haki detects the will of others)
2. If Luffy and Zoro both possessed passive haki ability in Jaya, they would have sensed this
3. All the haki users in Whitebeard's crew would also know
4. It would explain the 2 devil fruits (Devil fruits work with only one person's will at a time)
5. The second Will could be one of that of the ancient kingdom seeking revenge

I believe that this is the only theory that covers that many bases at once, making it one of the more credible ones.

Finally, all of this shows that Blackbeard is not just another minor character. He is the main antagonist. As the exact antipode to Luffy, he will be the final obstacle for Luffy to overcome in order to become the Pirate King.
ALL CREDIT TO Cutty Flam from OPB

and another similar but from different person

Another Original theory by Luckyroo fanboy Enjoy :p

You must be registered for see images



Establishing the concept of Devil Fruits

Why can't two people bite a piece of the same DF and get that power?

You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images

My take:The Fruit is only a vessel for the "devil spirit" that gives the user there power. As soon as that DF is bitten and swallowed the devil in that DF is transfered to a body which becomes its host. As soon as host dies. That "devil spirit" looks for the nearest "thing". This is the main concept of my theory which is important. Also lets use another example when Pain brought everybody back to life in Naruto there were these spirits looking for bodies. Thats the same way I see DF's only thing when the user die the spirit searches for a DF to go into.

Devil Fruit funnelization process

Most people like to think that the Yami Yami is 100% the reason why BB can eat multiple DF's. I say its 40% the reason.

"Nothing escapes darkness"-Blackbeard

My point is when WB died BB funneled the "devils spirit" into body. Think of it as almost like a surgery. Blackbeard gave the "devil spirit" one place to go and that was his body. The spirit tried to escape to go into another DF but the Yami Yami wouldn't let it. Its the reason why BB needed the blank blanket. I really didn't think he has hiding what he was doing. The blanket was complimentary to his Yami Yami in the process

Vegapunk created the process of funnelization


You must be registered for see images


Why can Weapons eat Devil Fruits?

My take: Weapons don't have mouths they can't eat shit...loll jk. My point is there is ways around eating a DF because the Fruit isn't that important. Whats important is the "devil" whats inside that fruit which grants the user the power

What the process Vegapunk used?

This is obviously hypothetical. But I think Vegapunk is a smart enough man to create inescaple scinetific chambers

Inescapable Chamber + Devil Fruit + Weapon

Step by Step:He recreated the process of eating the DF by having it smashed automatically. When the Devil Fruit is smashed the spirit escapes it. The "devil spirit" or essence then starts to move around looking to find its host. Because it is trapped in the chamber it can not find a DF or a host. The spirit then looks around and it is forced to go into the weapon. That process is called "FUNNELIZATION" a name I made up. Also BB might have used the Blanket to hide this process so people couldn't recreate it.

Also BB is using the Yami Yami to funnel strong Devil Fruits into all of his crew mates. After killing someone with a strong DF..he imediately makes a vortex or a dark funnel on the person who has died and on the other end his crewmate so the "devils spirit" is funneled or transfered into his crewmate rather than seeking a DF again

[video=youtube;xnayvYG_KUo]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xnayvYG_KUo[/video]

How Blackbeard stores two devil fruits?

Two Devils+ One body=A fight over the body and you die because of the clash in your body

"Teach body is abnormal"-Marco

You must be registered for see images

Just let me say it now he is not a chimera thats the stupidest cliche ever. Let me explain why because a chimera has three heads its shares one body. Meaning that it doesn't matter which head eats the Devil Fruit there will still be a clash in the body for control leading to death. The reason why I quote Marco is because alot of people dismiss it and give the Yami Yami full credit for BB having multiple DF's. But it could be true but I'm thinking out of the box

"There is more than one"-Zoro

Zoro and Luffy has always has special type of abilities. Luffy hears the voice of all things and Zoro hears the breth of all things. They wouldn't have acknowledged it if it was simply a chimera. The reason why they acknowleged it because they felt another presence within BB.

You must be registered for see images

"Its not like I was careless"-Shanks

You must be registered for see images

This quote clearly shows BB was not weak. Now if we examine Blackbeards past he had a claw weapon. But keep in mind Blackbeard hasn't shown any feats without his DF other than durability and his physical strength. But in my opinion to effectively use claws and hit Shanks you have to be fast and BB is very slow. Keep reading

Blackbeard as a child was seen crying why was that. Was he tormented I would like to think so. But by who?

You must be registered for see images

The Jolly Roger

This is the thing which people looks to deeply into. I don't think Oda's that obvious where he would give BB thread heads because of his Jolly Roger.

Jolly Roger Meaning 1-I have a feeling its represents past,present and future how BB always talks about generations
Jolly Roger Meaning 2-Its forshadowing to BB having 3 devil fruits not 3 heads...

The Concept of Taming Devils from fighting

In my opinion a power or another enitity lives in Blackbeard I wouldn't think of it as a person but a devils spirit. This is the reason why BB was seen crying as a child. Do you guys remember how Shakuku tortured Gaara. Another example is how the ninetails would allow Naruto to merge with the frog. Lets say hypothetically the frog did enter Naruto's body wouldn't it be intimidated by the fox. We'll its the same concept I'm using with BB

The concept of taming devil fruits is simple. The two devil fruit spirits in BB "abnormal" body doesn't fight because they are intimidated not by Blackbeard himself but the thing inside of his body. So the 2 devils in Blackbeards body behave because there is a much darker being inside of his body that they are afraid of so they sit down quietly. Blackbeard turned his childhood curse into a blessing.

The reason why Blackbeard didn't use this power in Marineford is because he has no control over it. Instead it controls his body when it wants too. Blackbeard is also way more tolerant to pain because he shares it with this other entity. Just think about it the way Shanks explained Blackbeard it really hinted at BB being fairly powerful. So far he has no feats which shows he can successfully use claws because atleast some sort of speed would be required to catch someone with those claws..just think of wolverine does BB seem like that too you. And thats why he uses this spirit thing.

Also notice how we never saw Ace vs BB fight finish I think its a reason for that. Nothing is just coincidence with Oda

We are the Marshall D's theory(Ancestors)

Monkey D family
Gol D family
Marshall D family
Portugas D family
Jaguar D family


Short theory:These are some of the famalies that made up the ancient kingdom. All the D's lived in peace but the Marshall D's had there own agenda. They were selfish and they represented evil in the ancient Kingdom. They were the betrayers of the ancient kingdom because of there own evil ways

Sounds familar?

I usually don't like reincarnations but I feel Blackbeard is a representantion of how the Marshall D's were back in the day pure evil. If we think of all the stuff BB has done so far it makes sense..because he was the one that killed thatch and started the WB war all by himself. If that doesn't show you evilness I don't no what will and thats what makes BB a true pirate because the Marshall D were the same

My point with all this family crap is BB might have been born with this evil entity in his body. The BB we see now is only capitalizing off of a birth deffect and using it to his advantage.

Sidenote:I know alot of this theory is farfetched and the Yami Yami theory could be 100% the reason why BB can have multiple devil fruits. But that has been done a bunch of times in different theories. I tried to approach this is a more unique way according to Blackbeard body being abnormal and giving him a story line I made up...:rolleyes: Tell me what you think guys and add to the theory
ALL CREDITS TO luckyroo20 from OPB
 
Last edited:

Uchiha Samater

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Aug 29, 2012
Messages
2,037
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Parts of it match up and this theory is based on old theories made before... and over all it's possible because someone neesd to pick up Burgess whos locked in the cage.

there is more theories about how/who BB actually is and how he can posses 2 FD's



ALL CREDIT TO Cutty Flam from OPB

and another similar but from different person



ALL CREDITS TO luckyroo20 from OPB
Thanks Dude!!

although i already know them, i put in my thread that i have no idea how he stores devil fruits

its more of a theory about whats coming
 

ToadSageNaruto

Active member
Regular
Joined
Sep 15, 2011
Messages
1,188
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
great theory. really wouldn't mind this happening. i also think blackbeard will play vulture and swoop in to steal kaido's df after luffy and co. defeats em. would be perfect, and would mean luffy would have to be hella strong to even compete with BB at the EOS.
 

Red Swag

Active member
Regular
Joined
May 25, 2012
Messages
1,735
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
a lot of people already knew about this tho... but great anyway.

however, like i said before... teach aint about that life. kaido will murder him.
 
Top