[Question] Marineford Arc related question

WhistleBlower

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Apr 12, 2012
Messages
27,716
Kin
4,460💸
Kumi
1,041💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
All righty then. I'm just re-watching the marinford arc because it was epic. So yeah, threads are gonna follow.

Being that Whitebeard was the star of the show during the war, we saw him suffer sword stabs through his chest, face half ripped off, turned into swiss cheese and he still came forward. He was beyond a monster. He fought as if he was intangible; as if he was a logia. Now I could only venture to say it was because of his willpower or partial result of his CoC being so enormous. There are only a small hand full of people who have his willpower and are legends like him. My question to you is, Could Shanks take those licks? Roger? Rayleigh? Future Luffy? Garp? Doflamingo?

Seeming how shanks came on Whitebeards ship to talk about a scratch on his eye, you would think that excludes him from the argument. However, he didn't blink when he lost his arm, so that puts him right back in the conversation.

You would think that Roger is on the same level as Whitebeard with regard to being able to take damage and keep marching forward. However, it only to the thrust of 2 spears to end his life. Yet he was close to death which could've been the cause, So you decide.


Raleigh? You'd hope so but we just don't know. Of course I'm only bringing up the names of the strongest guys for a reason.

Garp? We sure know he can dish it out, being that his name is "Garp the fist" But can he take it? That's the real question. Unfortunately, Axehand Morgan one-paneled him early on; so you decide for yourself.

Doflamingo? We don't know anything about his threshold for pain, since everytime we've seen him fight, he's just outright owning people.

Future Luffy? that boy's showing some real promise. But if he takes it like WB did just to prove he can endure that pain, This manga will be without it's main character before the last episode. So chances are, he'll never have to be put for that type of torture.

If Only Whitebeard had Virgo's armament hardening ability. He would have won the war.
 

GenKiDama

Banned
Elite
Joined
Feb 13, 2012
Messages
7,832
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
whitebeard was on par with roger so i'd say he should be able too, plus whitebeard wasn't in his prime.

But the others? I don't think so.
 

kmrasengan

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jan 30, 2012
Messages
5,766
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Ok that thing about Garp didn't quite happened like that, Garp fell asleep that's why it seemed he was one shotted by Morgan. xd Dumb Garp. Roger probably, so does Shanks since he's still a yonko with just one arm, don't know about rayleigh though, but we hae to admit, Whitebeard was like a beast, he barely dodge the attacks, he tanks them, hence so many hits he received, the other ones rely more on dodging I assume, but I'm with you, I don't know how Whitebeard was able to fight till the end, 2 holes in his chest, half the face blown off, hundreds of bullets and cannon balls and sword wounds but not a single scratch on his back. The man is a Legend. dofla no and future luffy, well that's hard to tell, but future Zoro would be able to do that, look at the fight with Daz Bones and the pain he took from Luffy, baws.
 

chintu234

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Sep 3, 2011
Messages
2,004
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
how about zoro??
he absorbed luffys all pain and was already injured and still absorbed his pain and tolerated it was bleeding alot but was still alive
even at the start of the series he had gotten a big slash on his chest by mihawk and servived
he even tried to cut his legs off to escape mr.3's wax statue
 

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
Ok that thing about Garp didn't quite happened like that, Garp fell asleep that's why it seemed he was one shotted by Morgan. xd Dumb Garp. Roger probably, so does Shanks since he's still a yonko with just one arm, don't know about rayleigh though, but we hae to admit, Whitebeard was like a beast, he barely dodge the attacks, he tanks them, hence so many hits he received, the other ones rely more on dodging I assume, but I'm with you, I don't know how Whitebeard was able to fight till the end, 2 holes in his chest, half the face blown off, hundreds of bullets and cannon balls and sword wounds but not a single scratch on his back. The man is a Legend.
Whitebeard had one hole in his chest.
 

Punk Hazard

Active member
Immortal
Joined
Apr 21, 2011
Messages
59,542
Kin
1,661💸
Kumi
11,569💴
Trait Points
50⚔️
He has 2 here.

You must be registered for see images


is the manga different? I've only seen the anime till fishman Island. nvm, 1 in the chest and another in the stomach, my mistake.
Yeah. In the manga he had one hole from being stabbed by Spard or whatever his name is. In the manga, instead of getting another hole punched into his chest by Akainu, half of his face was melted off. The anime did it differently.
 

kmrasengan

Active member
Elite
Joined
Jan 30, 2012
Messages
5,766
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Yeah. In the manga he had one hole from being stabbed by Spard or whatever his name is. In the manga, instead of getting another hole punched into his chest by Akainu, half of his face was melted off. The anime did it differently.
Ok thanks. I guess the animators tought t was better another hole in the torso than half the face blown off.
 

24 12 11 to troll

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Dec 24, 2011
Messages
11,214
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
nobody can tank as much damage , aside from a giant with haki (about as powerful as luffy's minimum)
this is partly because anyone smaller would just have a hole in the torso spanning the whole upper body , meaning that they would be dead due to eradicated organs , but whitebard is huge so his organs are either: larger , or more spread out meaning less proportionate damage occured (haki obviously helped him though)

your remark about roger....:
he knew he was going to die soon anyways , he had nothing to lose so i see no need for haki , i doubt roger had a devil fruit , i believe he was basically an older version of the current shanks (with his extra arm , if shanks had both arms he could probably take on whitebeard 1v1)
 

jiraiya lives

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jul 11, 2012
Messages
4,581
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
how about zoro??
he absorbed luffys all pain and was already injured and still absorbed his pain and tolerated it was bleeding alot but was still alive
even at the start of the series he had gotten a big slash on his chest by mihawk and servived
he even tried to cut his legs off to escape mr.3's wax statue
yeah I'll say zoro could....dudes had some of the roughest fights among the straw hats, he carried injuries from his fight with mihawk over into later arcs and was still fighting
 

ziggyZ

Active member
Elite
Joined
Apr 11, 2012
Messages
7,388
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
The olny thing I'm gonna say is that Mugi should definitely. Why? because I believe that by EoS, he'd have the greatest CotSK.
 

Souji

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 13, 2012
Messages
12,750
Kin
4💸
Kumi
3💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
No one could take WB's beating the way he did. Every character in One Piece is powerful in their own way.

Examples: Shanks, Garp (Haki), Roger (just being Pirate King, 'nuff said), Luffy (spirit of determination), and WB (DF, durability).

I'm pretty sure WB could have used Vergo's ability; he was just too old and weak to at that point (and look what ended up happening to Marineford).

If anything, only Blackbeard and Zoro have shown endurance feats to match WB.
 

oerash11

Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2013
Messages
17
Kin
0💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
If we are looking at physically surviving damage most people would die from immediately, I'll have to agree WB is king, but there are some honorable mentions I'd like to add.
Obviously Zoro for the reasons stated
Chopper in beast mode? I don’t think he has ever been even taken down (dose being pushed into the ocean count?)
Usopp. He’s the most underestimated character, but he took a four ton bat to the face... more than once! And walked away!
Jimbe, he could withstand a magma punch to the chest. (Ya he did pass out cuz of it)
Luffy all that damage Zoro took when he took Luffy's pain? Ya that was already his, and he probably would have woken up without a problem where Zoro had a recurring injury from it. (That is what i thought was epic aside from Zoro's sacrifice, how much pain can Luffy take?!?)
But none of them could take what WB did and live to talk about it. Like I said honorable mentions.
 
Top