MangaPanda or Manga Stream ??

Itachi The Solo King

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
2,406 posts 446 reactions
Joined
Mar 1, 2013
Messages
2,406
Status
Activity Streak
There's no possible chance any sane person or any logical person can say MP>MS. MS is greatly better. The translations are dead on correct (VIZ Manga correct) since they take their time, unlike MP who just do it as fast as they can and the quality of MS is also better. And if you go to other manga sites, you'll see by the next day or too, they use MS scans since the all know it's much better.

Narutobase stick with mangapanda scans so mangapanda > manga steam.. Manga stream translation is weird
 

moyo

Member
109 posts 5 reactions
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
109
Status
Activity Streak
*********** all day
 

Midday

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
4,824 posts 559 reactions
Joined
Mar 22, 2012
Messages
4,824
Status
Activity Streak
I'll like mangapanda more, the chapter's translated around the time I wake up so I can read it then get on with my day. The translations aren't as good, but they're good enough to understand what's going on.
 

Etari

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
701 posts 88 reactions
Joined
Oct 26, 2011
Messages
701
Status
Activity Streak
*********** > MangaPanda

MangaPanda Pros:
- Releases early.

MangaPanda Cons:
- Almost every chapter has typos, translation mistakes, etc.
- Sometimes, the dialogues don't make sense.
- Uses weak phrases in their translations.
- The photo quality (must be their scanlators) is low.
- Puts random fanarts in every chapter they release.

*********** Pros:
- Better translations - DEAD ON.
- Uses correct grammar and spelling. Although it may seem weird using such phrases, they actually do fit the character's personalities, character, age, time/era, etc.
- High quality releases.

*********** Cons:
- Slower release (which is understandable, because they put more effort into their releases)
- Puts random fanarts in every chapter they release.

Dare to say that this translation is better !!! ->
Than this ->

*********** uses a far more advanced English usage. You might say that MangaPanda's translation is better because you can understand it more than you can understand ***********'s.
 

Itachi The Solo King

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
2,406 posts 446 reactions
Joined
Mar 1, 2013
Messages
2,406
Status
Activity Streak
*********** > Mangapanda

Because sometimes, i just don't understand the MP chapter, so i check it out on MS for to make sense of it. I'm sure other do the same. Even though MP comes quicker than the MS, i prefer the MS waay more


MP = Mangapanda
MS= *********** NOT mangekyou sharingan XD
​

People like manga stream because the translations are longer, it doesn't mean the translations are accurate
 

ziggyZ

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
7,387 posts 593 reactions
1
Joined
Apr 11, 2012
Messages
7,387
Status
Activity Streak
Dare to say that this translation is better !!! ->
Than this ->

Yes it is better. Why? It's more sophisticated. And why is that better? Because Sasuke's character is that of a sophistic one. Hence how this proves my point. MP use the same language for every character. Whereas MS take their time, and actually translate it correctly and accurately enough which undoubtedly suits there character. And since you think the MP scan for that page is better, shows usthat your mind isn't matured enough to comprehend Naruto.
 

Highspeed

Member
282 posts 20 reactions
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
282
Status
Activity Streak
*********** > MangaPanda

MangaPanda Pros:
- Releases early.

MangaPanda Cons:
- Almost every chapter has typos, translation mistakes, etc.
- Sometimes, the dialogues don't make sense.
- Uses weak phrases in their translations.
- The photo quality (must be their scanlators) is low.
- Puts random fanarts in every chapter they release.

*********** Pros:
- Better translations - DEAD ON.
- Uses correct grammar and spelling. Although it may seem weird using such phrases, they actually do fit the character's personalities, character, age, time/era, etc.
- High quality releases.

*********** Cons:
- Slower release (which is understandable, because they put more effort into their releases)
- Puts random fanarts in every chapter they release.



*********** uses a far more advanced English usage. You might say that MangaPanda's translation is better because you can understand it more than you can understand ***********'s.

Nah i understand both scanlations pretty good .. but to me Ms is like a derpity derp trying to make it more dramatical by using those advanced phrases .. but in the end it looks more funnier than dramatical ...
 

ziggyZ

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
7,387 posts 593 reactions
1
Joined
Apr 11, 2012
Messages
7,387
Status
Activity Streak
Narutobase stick with mangapanda scans so mangapanda > manga steam.. Manga stream translation is weird
Weird? What? I guess your intellect isn't as developed as Kishi intended is audience for.

People like manga stream because the translations are longer, it doesn't mean the translations are accurate
Nope. If you compare MP to VIZ Manga (official volume release of Naruto, and compare it with MS. You'll see that MP's are truly messed up, and MS's are near perfect.
 

Etari

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
701 posts 88 reactions
Joined
Oct 26, 2011
Messages
701
Status
Activity Streak
Opinions differ, I guess.
 

Etari

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
701 posts 88 reactions
Joined
Oct 26, 2011
Messages
701
Status
Activity Streak
Nah i understand both scanlations pretty good .. but to me Ms is like a derpity derp trying to make it more dramatical by using those advanced phrases .. but in the end it looks more funnier than dramatical ...

The way *********** uses phrases somehow, in some way, sets the mood itself. I guess opinions differ, and it's something that we should keep to ourselves :yay:
 

ziggyZ

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
7,387 posts 593 reactions
1
Joined
Apr 11, 2012
Messages
7,387
Status
Activity Streak
Nah i understand both scanlations pretty good .. but to me Ms is like a derpity derp trying to make it more dramatical by using those advanced phrases .. but in the end it looks more funnier than dramatical ...

Derpity derp? What the ****? Okay man, I agree :sy:
 

Highspeed

Member
282 posts 20 reactions
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
282
Status
Activity Streak
Yes it is better. Why? It's more sophisticated. And why is that better? Because Sasuke's character is that of a sophistic one. Hence how this proves my point. MP use the same language for every character. Whereas MS take their time, and actually translate it correctly and accurately enough which undoubtedly suits there character. And since you think the MP scan for that page is better, shows usthat your mind isn't matured enough to comprehend Naruto.

Sasuke.. sophisticated.. A lunatic emo who wanted to destroy a whole village is sophisticated ...
You must be registered for see images
 

ziggyZ

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
7,387 posts 593 reactions
1
Joined
Apr 11, 2012
Messages
7,387
Status
Activity Streak
Sasuke.. sophisticated.. A lunatic emo who wanted to destroy a whole village is sophisticated ...
You must be registered for see images
Mate. have you ever read the VIZ Manga translation? If you have, you'd know that most (if not all) of his dialogues are spoken in a manner which is the polar opposite of Naruto's. (But you haven't read it, since you'd know MS>MP if you have.)
And as for sophisticated. His morale nor his mindset/views may not be, but he his damn knowledgeable and hence why he in a sense, is sophisticated. The fact that you needed me to point this out is shows you are not. :sy: Ignorance.
 

Highspeed

Member
282 posts 20 reactions
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
282
Status
Activity Streak
Mate. have you ever read the VIZ Manga translation? If you have, you'd know that most (if not all) of his dialogues are spoken in a manner which is the polar opposite of Naruto's. (But you haven't read it, since you'd know MS>MP if you have.)
And as for sophisticated. His morale nor his mindset/views may not be, but he his damn knowledgeable and hence why he in a sense, is sophisticated. The fact that you needed me to point this out is shows you are not. :sy: Ignorance.

Hmm i was just reading the MS scanlation of the latest naruto chapter ... ass,cloud nine, prick , diarrhea of mouth***,
Kakashi thinks that Obito uses Naruto as a GUINEA PIG ... dafuq ?
 

RikudouMadara

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
5,169 posts 505 reactions
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
5,169
Status
Activity Streak
I like MANGAHERE where does this fall in the scanlation hierarchy? Thnx in advance.
 

ziggyZ

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
7,387 posts 593 reactions
1
Joined
Apr 11, 2012
Messages
7,387
Status
Activity Streak
Hmm i was just reading the MS scanlation of the latest naruto chapter ... ass,cloud nine, prick , diarrhea of mouth***,
Kakashi thinks that Obito uses Naruto as a GUINEA PIG ... dafuq ?

What's so bad about the word "ass"? Do you get a giggle out of it? It's common Shonen language. And works perfectly in that context.
"Cloud nine" means that he his at the highest peak of enjoyment. It's just like Naruto to use these phrases.
Diarrhea is where one is continuously shitting. And hence why it works in that concept because in regards to Naruto, Obito continuously talks shit.
Prick is another term for ass-hole or f***wit I even say it's an uncensored term for c***. But you probably don't know that huh.
Do you even know what a guinea pig means in that context?

Another reason to why MS>MP. Because they take their time and translate the jutsu. Something MP has failed to do, continuously! And pages are much bigger with GREATER quality. Furthermore, MP want to censor words, however MS use the most accurate translations and thus they use swear words.
 

captainEO

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Veteran
2,385 posts 169 reactions
Joined
Mar 28, 2011
Messages
2,385
Status
Activity Streak
*********** is far superior.

MangaPanda's translations are abysmal, usually they aren't even remotely close to what's actually being said.

*********** is much better.
 
Top