- Joined
- Aug 16, 2012
- Messages
- 7,335
- Reaction score
- 1,153
I tend to question whether Post Jin Hagoromo is any different from Pre Jin.
Hagoromo and Hamura were born with their mother's chakra. In other words, they already had Juubi chakra since birth. During their fight against her, they already had Gudoudama. Something Obito was only able to use since he had Juubi chakra (Post Jin). Not to mention, they were able to defeat her (although they used the seals).
That might be why two halves of Non-Jin Hagoromo were able to counter everything Juubi Jin Madara was throwing at them. A Post Jin partially retains some of the abilities he had while a Jin. Obito was compatible with Juubi chakra because of this which is why he managed to absorb Juubi chakra from Madara and reform his staff. Hagoromo, on the other hand, inherited it from his mother so he's always had it.
He then became even more powerful when he became Juubi Jin. The difference between Madara and Hagoromo should be clear. I personally wouldn't have Madara in Kaguya's tier.
Well you brought good question here and I will try to respond the best I can.
1. It is True that Pre Jin Yang Hagoromo and Yin Hamura has inherited Juubi's power/chakra through Kaguya, his Mother.
2. Well, we have never seen them using or having goudama, only holding staff in hands which most likely is made of goudama.
3. Yes Yang Naruto and Yin Sasuke was enough to match juubi Jin due to what you have typed
4. Yes, Post Jin has retained Jinchurki abilities.
5. Yes as Juubi Jin and most likely obtaining Yin from Hamura as well Rikudou was incredible powerfull.
Summary:
Post Jin Advantage over Pre Juubi Hagoromo form:
1. Retaining abilities while having Jinchurki state
2. Yin and Yang powers
3. More expierience
4. More abilities
Pre Jin state advantage over Post Jin Hagoromo state:
1. More chakra (because Hagoromo was in weak state after extracting Ten tails chakra from himself for awhile at leat.)?!
I feel SM DRM should be above Yang version of The Rikudou.... Everything else I'm content with.... Though I feel Madara is above both The Rikudou and Kaguya.... Yes the only villain to have to be beaten by sneak tactics.... Imho he cannot be defeated in direct confrontation this is also a Manga fact What happened to Madara could happen to absolutely anyone period....
Possible, but Yang version of Rikudou had already Juubi chakra inherited through kaguya,while Madara lacked it... Also Senjutsu of six paths is highter/supreme version of normal SM.
I disagree with your forced "Madara being above Kaguya and Hagoromo" argument. There is no hints to even assume this is possible. Back then I could agree but as manga advances it was proved to be incorrect.
I agre although that Madara was trolled and it would happen to everyone.
This is my tier list
this list is based on OVERALL abilities, if you feel that there are some faults with it, then feel free to VM me over them, but provide a legitimate reason over whats wrong
i have also included most of the forms for oother characters so if you feel annoyed by that then thats not legitimate enough,
Indra, ashura and Hamura are not included due to lack of feats and hype
Tier: 1
Kaguya Ootsutsuki
Sage of the Six Paths
Bijuu Powered Sasuke
RSM Naruto Uzumaki
Double Rinnegan Juubi Madara
Tier 2:
RG Sasuke Uchiha
Juudara
Juubito
DMS Kakashi
8th Gate Guy
Tier 3:
RT Madara Uchiha
Kabuto w/ Edo Tensei
Orochimaru w/ Edo Tensei
Tier 4:
Hashirama Senju
VOTE Madara Uchiha
BSM Naruto Uzumaki
BM Minato Namikaze
Edo Madara Uchiha
RG Obito Uchiha w/ Paths
Tier 5:
BM Naruto Uzumaki
EMS Madara Uchiha
Healthy Nagato Uzumaki
EMS Sasuke Uchiha
Tier 6:
KCM Naruto Uzumaki
KCM Minato Namikaze
Killer Bee
RG Obito Uchiha w/o Paths
DSM Kabuto Yakushi
Tier 7:
Pein
Tobi
Minato Namikaze
Tobirama Senju
SM Naruto Uzumaki
Edo Itachi Uchiha
Tier 8:
Pein arc SM Naruto Uzumaki
MS Sasuke Uchiha
Sick Itachi Uchiha
War Arc Kakashi Hatake
Might Guy
Spiral Zetsu
Tier 9:
Muu
Third Raikage
Second Mizukage
Danzo
Gaara w/ Shukaku
Onoki
Ay
SM Jiraiya
Kisame
Gaara
Tier 10:
Hebi Sasuke
Edo Hiruzen Sarutobi
Orochimaru
Kakuzu
Tsunade
Sakura
Mei
Sasori
Deidara
Konan
Fourth Kazekage
Tier 11:
Zabuza
Hidan
Darui
Kitsuchi
Kimimaro
Chiyo
Tier 12:
Rock Lee
Choji
Jugo
Suigetsu
Kankuro
Temari
Neji Hyuga
Asuma Sarutobi
Kurenai Yuhi
Really not bad list, It has some really well thought out characters placed in right tiers.
Most of tiers are also logically and correctly placed.
However Putting Naruto and Sasuke in Same category as Kaguya and JJ Hagoromo would be completly wrong, as there is not hint for that and Naruto and Sasuke lack both Hype and Feats to even assume they could be same tier.