[Discussion] Magic Anime suggestions?

[Mahesvara]

Hating ? i simply post the video and that's that,



With that much hype top 10 is not good enough, its should have been in the top, i remember everyone is talking about this adaption 6 month before the series premiere,
this is the list from october ( by that time the anime already ended and they already release some DVD/Blue ray volume

Spoiler

*1.　38,997　38,997　Love Live! School Idol Project 2nd Season Vol.5 Special Limited Edition
*2.　*6,738　*6,738　Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun Vol.2
*3.　*5,623　*5,623　No Game No Life Vol.5
*4.　*4,305　*4,305　Fate/kaleid liner Prisma☆Illya 2wei! Vol.2
*5.　*3,812　*3,812　Date A Live II Vol.5
*6.　*2,331　*2,331　Futsuu no Joshikousei ga [Locodol] Yatte Mita. Vol.2
*7.　*2,285　31,706　Monogatari Series: Second Season "Hanamonogatari" Vol.2 Suruga Devil Part 2 Limited Edition
*8.　*2,184　*2,184　New Prince of Tennis OVA vs Genius10 Vol.1
*9.　*2,007　*2,007　Fullmetal Alchemist Blu-ray BOX Limited Edition
10.　*2,002　*2,002　Tokyo Ghoul Vol.2
11.　*1,666　16,823　Sword Art Online II Vol.1 Limited Edition
12.　*1,638　*1,638　Sabagebu! Vol.2 Special Limited Edition
13.　*1,535　*1,535　Magic Knight Rayearth Blu-ray BOX
14.　*1,312　*1,312　Kenzen Robo Daimidaler Vol.4
15.　*1,226　*1,226　Kamigami no Asobi Vol.5
16.　*1,167　*1,167　Hitsugi no Chaika Vol.5
17.　*1,085　*1,085　Fullmetal Alchemist: The Conqueror of Shamballa
18.　**,998　**,998　Hybrid Child Vol.1
19.　**,982　*8,989　Gochuumon wa Usagi desu ka? Vol.5 Limited Edition

Budget ? what does budget have anything to do with it ? am talking about their poor executing in writing/scripting/screen play, not animation/voice actor and music quality.

come again ?



That's how boring it is, and you missed the point about the conversation being completely unnecessary,
I welcome infodumps and explanations, i have watched tons of series that did nothing but talked like Space Brother ( This manga is about Astronaut so am pretty you can imagine how high their conversation standards )
The problem with infodumps here is they were either not needed or needed, but done poorly.
I'll gladly read/watch magic explanation if it leads to something or is made as a mean to immerse watcher/reader,

Technobabble. Magical sequences in the show are interrupted by long explanations of the magical theory behind them. Characters would sit in the cafe and discuss magic. Tatsuya would move a block across a room then launch into a lengthy explanation why this was difficult for him. Tatsuya would explain why wizards flying is really difficult for most of an episode and then proceed to solve it a minute later accompanied by another explanation. I got a pretty good grasp on the world's magic system by the end of the show,

but these scenes are all excruciatingly boring even with that knowledge. Eyes glaze over as they talk about oscillating magical frequencies and squiddidly heebijeebies and whatnot. What was even more frustrating is you could use none of this knowledge to enjoy the show more. None of the explanations helped the viewer understanding what was going on in a battle better or let you work out what was going on yourself. Even with the knowledge of magic I gained, it never became useful to know for anything else. It wasn't building lore either since it felt mostly like reading from a highly boring textbook. So what was the point of these lengthy magical explanations?



And here you're talking about the LN ? am pretty sure am talking about the anime,




You're going round and round with that explanation and in the end its "Oni-Sama save her life that's why she want Oni-sama to bang her" surely my statement is spot on,



Good Characters ? really ? Good Story? in Mahouka ? did you just.......

Stephen Hawking pretends to be a kindergarten student and crushes them all in the science fair. Replace Stephen Hawking with "super soldier who has god like magic power" and kindergarten with "magic school" and you get the idea. Likeable characters and nice magical effects ruined by an idiotic story. The final 3 episodes have a battle which is like watching a kid stomp on ants. How did such a bad story ever get made?

When your show has two mary sues in it, both our main protagonists at that, then you know you have some explaining to do. Tatsuya, our male protagonist is not the strongest in the magical field, as i mentioned before he is part of the less skilled group, but this is overshadowed by his amazing martial arts skill and knowledge of how magic works. He is one of the biggest Gary Stues I have ever seen in a show, since even though he's not supposed to be good with magic, he actually is. He literally takes a guy down in less than a second. He has almost no personality and one of his biggest purposes is explaining everything to everyone.

Miyuki is our second protagonist, and as much a Mary sue as her bigger brother is a Gary stues. The opposite of Tatsuya when it comes to magical skills, Miyuki is very proficient in the use of magic. Having next to no personality, the only thing Miyuki does is praise her brother, call her brother ''Onii-sama'', praise her brother, tell people how awesome her brother is and praising her brother. It doesn't help that she obvously loves Tatsuya more than a little sister should.

Side characters are awful, and just serve the purpose of praising Tatsuya or getting told how things work, since Tatsuya is the only one who knows anything in this show.

Horrible characters that either serve no purpose or are thrown in as an excuse to get some expostion,

The story is not much better. Given the huge character cast and boring main characters, the story tends to be slow paced and takes too long to explain things. 90% of MKnR is spent explaining. Almost every time an action scene occurs or a new magic is shown, the show stops and has the characters indirectly explain to the audience what happened even though I never really cared to know most of the time.
Plus most things that are explained are rather unimportant overall and make it hard to focus on the actual important information.

For example
If the explanation for why Tatsuya can run super fast is because he can strengthen his legs with magic, I'm sure no one would complain - that's a satisfying enough explanation. However, an explanation in the show gives us would include talking about the absolute fundamentals of what Tatsuya does - creating psion waves which are the basic forms of magical energy and shifting them to the feet where waves of energy are released upon the foot's contact with the ground at a 45 degree angle - I'm sure you understand by now. The explanations are just too long and unnecessary, especially when they're not crucial for our enjoyment of the show.




Then you should check MAL/ANN/ and MH there you'll see LN readers blaming Madhouse for the poor anime adaptation and Madhouse fanboy defending Madhouse and claim mahouka for being mediocre to begin with,

Despite wanting to be taken seriously, the show can't help but have it's fair share of generic high school hijinks. Mahouka is a harem. None of the male characters get any significant screen time except for Tatsuya, and all other female characters are either in love, or appear to be in love with Tatsuya.

You agreed with a person who said the series was horrible and posted a video mocking it, how is that not hate?

Budget is a huge deal, how do you think the studio pays the animators and the writers?

Anime News Network is more reliable

You must be registered for see links

Do you realize all the explanations in the anime where simplified and shortened? Every part that had a explanation in the anime had a longer more complex explanation in the novel, so for you to say that the anime is badly adapted because of that is quite comical. If you think those are boring the yepp, the series is definitely not for you.

You asked a question and I answered it U_U.

Nope, that statement is still wrong.


The classic Mahouka hater statement that Tatsuya is just a boring over powered Gary Stu. Well personally I have no problem with the way he is. Tatsuya is a breath of fresh air from the common dumb and goofy MC's that we usually get. His personality is interesting to me, he's calm, he witty, he's humble, and he's kind but he doesn't hesitate to be cold and ruthless when it matters, he is sort of a hybrid between Itachi and Lelouch. I enjoy watching his character grow emotionally as well. I don't mind him being OP and Haxxed at all to be quite honest with ya, because the majority of the time he is heavily restricted, so he just resorts to using skill and strategy and its alway fun to see him let loose when the occasion arises.

Spoiler

Tatsuya is only good at combat magic, because his artifical processor only works efficiently with magics the run with 5 processes or fewer, which covers more than half of the known combat magic.

As for Miyuki, her Bro complex is annoying, but her love and loyalty to him is really admirable. She's is trying to repay the debt she owes him for the pain she caused him. I try to ignore her romantic feelings for him, because I believe the show won't follow that route, unless they turn out to not be siblings.

As for the side characters I find them all unique and interesting. Erika and Mayumi being my favorite female ones and Masaki being my favorite male side character.

Like I said many of the other side character's developement and background comes later in the series. Though if I have to nitpick the anime took out a whole piece of characterization from taking out some scenes of character interactions.

As for the story I find the world they are in truly interesting. A world where magic & science coexsist quite well with incredible deep and complex pseudo magic science that actually works and make sense. There are also deep political, discrimination, and prejudice concepts that are putting that really gives this show a realistic vibe. Combine that with Tatsuya's story of trying to live a normal life despite facing many challenges and constantly being used as weapon makes it one of the most unique and interesting stories I have ever watched/read and has earned a spot on my all time favorites.

For mahouka I always use the wiki site to talk about it and most LN's readers on their had overall positive reactions to the anime, though we all know its far from perfect and has many of flaws. Most LN's readers that I came across that hate the anime are the ones who overhyped for themselves and had way to high of expectations, so they ended up hating it for the fact that it wasn't as good as the Light Novel(which of course is way better), but this happens with a lot of series out there tbh.

Now your complaining about the harem? Lol The harem isn't even distracting to the main storyline and I don't have a problem with harems as long as they are not the main focus, the women are good interesting characters, and the guy isn't dumb or get flustered by the women.

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

You agreed with a person who said the series was horrible and posted a video mocking it, how is that not hate?

Do you hear yourself ? 1st you said there's nothing wrong with it, then say its stupid and then said its mocking the series, make up your mind....

Budget is a huge deal, how do you think the studio pays the animators and the writers?

Anime News Network is more reliable

You must be registered for see links

Budget is a huge deal, but budget matter the most when it comes to animation/music and hiring a good seiyuu,
we are talking about Madhouse here not some lowlife anime studio, they already have good directors/writers at their disposal as a member of their studio, and for your information the anime that i mention like Fate/Zero/Oregairu/haruhi Suzumiya series the latter 2 don't have a big budget and yet they manage to fit all the LN content perfectly with only 12/14 episode,

That list i posted is from Ann....

Do you realize all the explanations in the anime where simplified and shortened? Every part that had a explanation in the anime had a longer more complex explanation in the novel, so for you to say that the anime is badly adapted because of that is quite comical. If you think those are boring the yepp, the series is definitely not for you.

Yes i realized that, that's why i point it out by saying they got their priority wrong,
well like i said i welcome explanation and infodump in anime series, but how it is explaining Tatsuya can run so fast ina round about way matters to the viewers ?

If you're content with that kind of useless infodumb then you're beyond help, i mean did you get a boner every time Tatsuya said something to the point of that your turned your brain off ?, it looks to me everything is fine for you as long as it Tatsuya...

You asked a question and I answered it U_U.

Except that you don't answered anything,

Nope, that statement is still wrong.

That's how it looks like in the anime and from your long explanation,
Its like her in Goal in life is to get ****ed by her Oni-Sama

The classic Mahouka hater statement that Tatsuya is just a boring over powered Gary Stu. Well personally I have no problem with the way he is. Tatsuya is a breath of fresh air from the common dumb and goofy MC's that we usually get. His personality is interesting to me, he's calm, he witty, he's humble, and he's kind but he doesn't hesitate to be cold and ruthless when it matters, he is sort of a hybrid between Itachi and Lelouch. I enjoy watching his character grow emotionally as well. I don't mind him being OP and Haxxed at all to be quite honest with ya, because the majority of the time he is heavily restricted, so he just resorts to using skill and strategy and its alway fun to see him let loose when the occasion arises.

Spoiler

Tatsuya is only good at combat magic, because his artifical processor only works efficiently with magics the run with 5 processes or fewer, which covers more than half of the known combat magic.

Did you just compared Oni-sama to a well crafted characters like Itachi and Lelouch ? BLASPHEMY!!!, Tatsuya ain't no breath of fresh air for anime protagonist... Lelouch,Light,Alucard,Char Aznable,Jotaro Kujo,Inaho,Kira Yamato,Setsuna F Seie,Yuu Hero,Shiro from NGNL and Kiritsugu from fate/Zero every last one of them is not a dumb goofy MC,

Tatsuya is not as special as you think he is... at best he is Kirito from SAO

As for Miyuki, her Bro complex is annoying, but her love and loyalty to him is really admirable. She's is trying to repay the debt she owes him for the pain she caused him. I try to ignore her romantic feelings for him, because I believe the show won't follow that route, unless they turn out to not be siblings.

By repaying the debt means that she want Oni-sama to bang here eh ?

Like I said many of the other side character's developement and background comes later in the series. Though if I have to nitpick the anime took out a whole piece of characterization from taking out some scenes of character interactions.

Which is why i said they have could take out that stupid explanation like Tatsuya can run so fast and other unimportant explanation and put that character interaction instead,

As for the story I find the world they are in truly interesting. A world where magic & science coexsist quite well with incredible deep and complex pseudo magic science that actually works and make sense. There are also deep political, discrimination, and prejudice concepts that are putting that really gives this show a realistic vibe. Combine that with Tatsuya's story of trying to live a normal life despite facing many challenges and constantly being used as weapon makes it one of the most unique and interesting stories I have ever watched/read and has earned a spot on my all time favorites.

This is just sad... considering that you have watched the likes of Code Geass and still think Mahouka is an even better work,

For mahouka I always use the wiki site to talk about it and most LN's readers on their had overall positive reactions to the anime, though we all know its far from perfect and has many of flaws. Most LN's readers that I came across that hate the anime are the ones who overhyped for themselves and had way to high of expectations, so they ended up hating it for the fact that it wasn't as good as the Light Novel(which of course is way better), but this happens with a lot of series out there tbh.

This happens a lot but the one who got criticize the most is IMO Mahouka, because they have good studio animating the anime and yet people still complained about it, just you know I've hardly see anyone blame madhouse when they're animating a series,

Now your complaining about the harem? Lol The harem isn't even distracting to the main storyline and I don't have a problem with harems as long as they are not the main focus, the women are good interesting characters, and the guy isn't dumb or get flustered by the women.

Am not complaining am just pointing out how this series feels despite wanting to be taken seriously like Code Geass.

 

[Delcan]

Wanted to say Magi but the .gif is on your sig.

 

[Mahesvara]

Do you hear yourself ? 1st you said there's nothing wrong with it, then say its stupid and then said its mocking the series, make up your mind....



Budget is a huge deal, but budget matter the most when it comes to animation/music and hiring a good seiyuu,
we are talking about Madhouse here not some lowlife anime studio, they already have good directors/writers at their disposal as a member of their studio, and for your information the anime that i mention like Fate/Zero/Oregairu/haruhi Suzumiya series the latter 2 don't have a big budget and yet they manage to fit all the LN content perfectly with only 12/14 episode,

That list i posted is from Ann....



Yes i realized that, that's why i point it out by saying they got their priority wrong,
well like i said i welcome explanation and infodump in anime series, but how it is explaining Tatsuya can run so fast ina round about way matters to the viewers ?

If you're content with that kind of useless infodumb then you're beyond help, i mean did you get a boner every time Tatsuya said something to the point of that your turned your brain off ?, it looks to me everything is fine for you as long as it Tatsuya...



Except that you don't answered anything,



That's how it looks like in the anime and from your long explanation,
Its like her in Goal in life is to get ****ed by her Oni-Sama




Did you just compared Oni-sama to a well crafted characters like Itachi and Lelouch ? BLASPHEMY!!!, Tatsuya ain't no breath of fresh air for anime protagonist... Lelouch,Light,Alucard,Char Aznable,Jotaro Kujo,Inaho,Kira Yamato,Setsuna F Seie,Yuu Hero,Shiro from NGNL and Kiritsugu from fate/Zero every last one of them is not a dumb goofy MC,

Tatsuya is not as special as you think he is... at best he is Kirito from SAO



By repaying the debt means that she want Oni-sama to bang here eh ?



Which is why i said they have could take out that stupid explanation like Tatsuya can run so fast and other unimportant explanation and put that character interaction instead,



This is just sad... considering that you have watched the likes of Code Geass and still think Mahouka is an even better work,



This happens a lot but the one who got criticize the most is IMO Mahouka, because they have good studio animating the anime and yet people still complained about it, just you know I've hardly see anyone blame madhouse when they're animating a series,



Am not complaining am just pointing out how this series feels despite wanting to be taken seriously like Code Geass.

First I said the video you posted was stupid, then you presumed I meant disturbing, then I restated to you that I said it was stupid because your using the video to hate on the story, then you ask how does the video hate on the anime, and then I said because your using it to mock it, how is that so hard to understand?


You call it useless info dump, but it tells you exactly what the hell is going on and at the time the example you used people thought Tatsuya was suppose to be bad at magic, so the they took a little bit of time to explain what Tatsuya did to show the viewers that Tatsuya is actually capable in magic combat. Oh you level off to person insults, how mature XD.

You asked "what does tatsuya feel? I thought he was emotionless" and I answered it, how is that hard to comprehend?

If your still going to say that even though I proved how that wasn't her ultimate goal, your ignoring the facts and evidence and I gave you from the anime and the LN, but if your not sure rewatch the scene in the anime where Tatsuya talks with Miyuki about turning down the magic university for writing his name in the index for the new magic he created during the nine schools competition arc.

I'm not the only one who compares Tatsuya to those two, he's very similar to them. In fact a lot of people also compare him to Hei from Darker than Black as well. My point is that Tatsuya falls into the unique MC's like all of the characters you've listed except Kira Yammato, he's not really unique imo. The only things Kirito and Tatsuya in common is that they both are smart, they like the to wear black, and they have a harem.

No, her main goal is to free him from the Yotsuba clan, but no matter how many times I say so you just choose to ignore me.

Did I ever say Mahouka's anime was better than Code Geass? Nope., just said the series is one of my all time favorites.

Most LN readers tend to blame the anime for its issues, while the non LN readers tend to blame Mahouka itself. That's how I've come to see it anyway.

Anyways I'm done debating with you, if you have anything more to say just PM or VM me.

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

First I said the video you posted was stupid, then you presumed I meant disturbing, then I restated to you that I said it was stupid because your using the video to hate on the story, then you ask how does the video hate on the anime, and then I said because your using it to mock it, how is that so hard to understand?

What is so hard to understand is why would you respond to a video like that if you have no qualm to begin with ?

You call it useless info dump, but it tells you exactly what the hell is going on and at the time the example you used people thought Tatsuya was suppose to be bad at magic, so the they took a little bit of time to explain what Tatsuya did to show the viewers that Tatsuya is actually capable in magic combat. Oh you level off to person insults, how mature XD.

Took a little bit of time eh ? i remember tatsuya went to to explain every single detail about how he was unable to move a block of iron as good as everyone else only to reveal that he's actually better than everyone else, tell me how is that useful for our enjoyment for the plot and story as a whole ? i mean its quite obvious that he's the stephan hawking of mahouka,

And that's not an insult, not at all...because it seems you're fine with everything as long as it Tatsuya, its like you're preaching tatsuya for everything he does, you almost sounds like Miyuki,

You asked "what does tatsuya feel ? I thought he was emotionless" and I answered it, how is that hard to comprehend ?

Again you're not answering anything, i asked what does he feel you give me his background and that's that, am asking what he feel what he want its just that simple of a question,

If your still going to say that even though I proved how that wasn't her ultimate goal, your ignoring the facts and evidence and I gave you from the anime and the LN, but if your not sure rewatch the scene in the anime where Tatsuya talks with Miyuki about turning down the magic university for writing his name in the index for the new magic he created during the nine schools competition arc.

Wasn't her ultimate goal in life ? so its still one of her goal right ? and from anime perspective that's how i see it,

I'm not the only one who compares Tatsuya to those two, he's very similar to them. In fact a lot of people also compare him to Hei from Darker than Black as well. My point is that Tatsuya falls into the unique MC's like all of the characters you've listed except Kira Yammato, he's not really unique imo. The only things Kirito and Tatsuya in common is that they both are smart, they like the to wear black, and they have a harem.

Then you're just as deluded as that peoples, no one in their mind will compare Tatsuya with Lelouch let alone claiming that he was hybrid of Lelouch and Itachi, even putting them in the same line is pretty much insulting for Lelouch and Itachi,

And nope... Tatsuya does not fall in that unique MC category, i might want to asked you the definition of unique MC,
All that MC that i listed up there have their own goal and weaknesses and through their series they started to develop Insurmountable amount of characterization,

And Kira Yamato is actually have the same background as Tatsuya you know its just that he's lot more human, saying that he's not unique means that you never watched Gundam Seed,

What Kirito and Tatsuya have in common is they are invincible without weaknesses and they're both Gary Stu,

No, her main goal is to free him from the Yotsuba clan, but no matter how many times I say so you just choose to ignore me.

Freed him from the Totsuba ? IMO Tatsuya is more than capable of doing by himself surely her help is not needed,

Did I ever say Mahouka's anime was better than Code Geass? Nope., just said the series is one of my all time favorites.

so Code Geass is better Than Mahouka and Lelouch is Better character than Tatsuya yes ?

Most LN readers tend to blame the anime for its issues, while the non LN readers tend to blame Mahouka itself. That's how I've come to see it anyway.

Well yeah that's what I've been saying all along

Anyways I'm done debating with you, if you have anything more to say just PM or VM me.

What ? hah you're no fun.

 

[Mahesvara]

What is so hard to understand is why would you respond to a video like that if you have no qualm to begin with ?

Because it was mocking the series for a minor reason, and you were using it as a reason to hate it.


Took a little bit of time eh ? i remember tatsuya went to to explain every single detail about how he was unable to move a block of iron as good as everyone else only to reveal that he's actually better than everyone else, tell me how is that useful for our enjoyment for the plot and story as a whole ? i mean its quite obvious that he's the stephan hawking of mahouka,

It's so the viewers understand whats going on, nothing more nothing less.

And that's not an insult, not at all...because it seems you're fine with everything as long as it Tatsuya, its like you're preaching tatsuya for everything he does, you almost sounds like Miyuki,

I'm fine if it's anybody. Idk where you get your info that I only care about what Tatsiua does



Again you're not answering anything, i asked what does he feel you give me his background and that's that, am asking what he feel what he want its just that simple of a question,

I told you he does feel weaker emotions, while the stronger one's were erased, aside from his brotherly love for Miyuki. That's just a quick summary.

Wasn't her ultimate goal in life ? so its still one of her goal right ? and from anime perspective that's how i see it,

She wants to stay by his side and she's ashamed about her romantic feelings, but she can't help it and due to societies laws it can't happen anyway. That's one the things the anime didn't handle very well, but I believe they did good enough to show her main goal is to help him.

Then you're just as deluded as that peoples, no one in their mind will compare Tatsuya with Lelouch let alone claiming that he was hybrid of Lelouch and Itachi, even putting them in the same line is pretty much insulting for Lelouch and Itachi,

Your deluded if you deny the similarities, Tatsuya has many characteristics that are similar to those two. All three are geniuses, all three can be cold and ruthless, all three has one person they care more about then anyone else, all three are strategic masterminds, all three have had rough pasts, Tatsuya and Itachi both have conservative emotions, the list goes on and on.

And nope... Tatsuya does not fall in that unique MC category, i might want to asked you the definition of unique MC,
All that MC that i listed up there have their own goal and weaknesses and through their series they started to develop Insurmountable amount of characterization,

Tatsuya has a ultimate goal, he does have weaknesses, and he does get a lot of emotional growth and development as a human as the series is going on, but you wouldn't no that part since your basing his entire character off the first season of the anime. One thing the anime does poorly is that they took away many of his monologues, which give you a better understanding of his character.

And Kira Yamato is actually have the same background as Tatsuya you know its just that he's lot more human, saying that he's not unique means that you never watched Gundam Seed,

Another assumption out of you, I have actually seen Gundam Seed. He doesn't have the same background as Tatsuya Lol. He's a good character, he's been through a lot and he slowly grew into a pretty cool character. However that doesn't mean he's a unique character, because I've seen plenty of characters that started off as weak willed cry babies and become cool strong characters.

What Kirito and Tatsuya have in common is they are invincible without weaknesses and they're both Gary Stu,

Ugh are you kidding me? They both have weaknesses. Kirito can only fight at his full potential in a life or death struggle(he lost to Yuuki twice) and Tatsuya is constantly restricted from his full abilities and only able to go all out in certain conditions. It's stated that several people could beat him with certain advantages, not to mention he always loses to his master.

Freed him from the Totsuba ? IMO Tatsuya is more than capable of doing by himself surely her help is not needed,

Actually no, it's impossible for him to free himself from the clan, because of Miyuki. She's the only link binding him to the clan. The only way he can truly be free is if Miyuki relives him of his duty when she becomes the head of the clan.


so Code Geass is better Than Mahouka and Lelouch is Better character than Tatsuya yes ?

The anime, yes. Mahouka is my favorite novel series though. Tatsuya is my favorite character and Lelouch is one them as well and both of them are great characters. That's all I have to say about that.


Well yeah that's what I've been saying all along
Well your an anomaly, because your blaming the studio as well for a bad adaptation, when you haven't even read the source material yours self. Lol



What ? hah you're no fun.

Check edits.

Okay, I am going to bed now.

 

[Totsuka No Tsurugi]

Because it was mocking the series for a minor reason, and you were using it as a reason to hate it.

How is posting that video can be considered mocking ? i mean you said it yourself that there's nothing wrong about it yes ?

It's so the viewers to understand whats going on, nothing more nothing less.

And is that useful ? how ? such unimportant piece of information. like i said earlier...
Even with the knowledge of magic I gained, it never became useful to know for anything else. It wasn't building lore either since it felt mostly like reading from a highly boring textbook. So what was the point of these lengthy magical explanations?

The explanation is pretty easy really. You know in Kill la Kill one of the characters would have an explanation as to why Matoi Ryuko gained this incredible power of hers, delving into theories about life fibres and so on, until Mako would burst in and yell "so what you're saying is Ryuko has awesome powers", turning the entire previous conversation into a hilarious joke that outlined that none of it was really important? That's Mahouka's magical explanations except it's explaining why Tatsuya is totally awesome. Also it's not played as a joke.

In other words its self gratification at best

'm fine if it's anybody. Idk where you get your info that I only care about what Tatsiua does

Really ? you seemed so obsessed with him to the point that you're willing and actually happy to listen about how he is bad at pushing a square inch iron block across a floor with his mind,

I told you he does feel weaker emotions, while the stronger one's were erased, aside from his brotherly love for Miyuki. That's just a quick summary.

And what does that weaker emotion answered my question about what he feel ? he feel weaker emotion ? elaborate please,

She wants to stay by his side and she's ashamed about her romantic feelings, but she can't help it and due to societies laws it can't happen anyway. That's one the things the anime didn't handle very well, but I believe they did good enough to show that she just wants to help him.

So she's a hypocrite little ***** then ? she know its wrong but she did it anyway pftt, and what societies laws you're talking about ? this is LN and incest in LN happens all the time, just you know that most of the LN writers is no PRO they're just doing it as a hobby,

Your deluded if you deny the similarities, Tatsuya has many characteristics that are similar to those two. All three are geniuses, all three can be cold and ruthless, all three has one person they care more about then anyone else, all three are strategic masterminds, all three have had rough pasts, Tatsuya and Itachi both have conservative emotions, the list goes on and on.

I never denied their similarities, but comparing them is 1 thing i can't ignore, you see to compare someone its means you put them on the equal ground with the counterpart, and when it comes to that both Lelouch and Itachi character is grander than Tatsuya so comparing them is out of question since you can't put those two iconic character in the same ground as Gary Stu like Tatsuya its an insult for them,

Tatsuya has a ultimate goal and he does have weaknesses, and he does get a lot of emotional growth and development as a human as the series is going on, but you wouldn't no that since your basing his entire character off the first season of the anime and the anime doesn't cover everything about that we learn of from the novels

Weaknesses ? what is that ? He is a master magician who can cancel out other magicians magic. He's baffling intelligent to the point that he can calculate mind-bogglingly complex magical problems in milliseconds. In his spare time he's the world's greatest engineer, fronting as the mysterious Silver creating the best magical equipment in the world.

He solves magical problems that the rest of the world have been struggling with for years. He creates the power of flight on a whim. He can see through walls. He can take down an entire platoon of terrorists by himself. He can detonate the power equivalent of an atomic bomb over anywhere in the world. He can heal all wounds instantly. He can raise the dead,

and yes am basing his entire character from the anime, to begin with I've been talking about the anime only all along.. where have you been ?

If you want to talk about the LN then you're in the wrong place that's why i told you to ignore my post in the 1st place,

Another assumption out of you, I have actually seen Gundam Seed. He doesn't have the same background as Tatsuya . He's a good character, he's been through a lot and he slowly grew into a pretty cool character. However that doesn't mean he's a unique character, because I've seen plenty of characters that started off as weak willed cry babies and become cool strong characters.

By background i mean Kira being a product of science experiment known as the Ultimate Coordinator, if you watched Gundam seed you'll know that Kira is not even trying yet he bested everyone else in a blink of an eye, killing one ZAFT red uniform pilot in his very 1st fight in his life, and went on to solo Athrun and his team through the series,
and he's not even a soldier, he never received all that intense military training yet he's fighting on equal ground and actually bested all those elite pilot, He can't die he's always right and they called him Jesus Yamato,

Ugh are you kidding me? They both have weaknesses. Kirito can only fight at his full potential in a life or death struggle(he lost to Yuuki twice) and Tatsuya is constantly restricted from his full abilities and only able to go all out in certain conditions. It's stated that several people could beat him with certain advantages, not to mention he always loses to his master.

And again what weaknesses you're talking about ? Kirito can only fight when he's serious ? of course he only lose stupid battle, that fight against his master ? its just a stupid fight am pretty sure you're well aware that Tatsuya can killed him anytime he want,

Any problem presented to Tatsuya can be solved with no issue. Yet the show likes to pretend he genuinely has factors against him. It's purely lipservice though that has no practical limitations on his capability to do literally anything. Whenever the show tries to make me feel like Tatsuya is inconvenienced, it ends up flipping around and making me feel like I should be on the side of the people against Tatsuya.

It stated that several people could beat him ? comeback when it actually happen, then again its just another LipService,

Actually no, it's impossible for him to free himself from the clan, because of Miyuki. She's the only link binding him to the clan. The only way she can truly free him is if she relives him of his duty when she becomes the head of the clan.

As far as am concerned Tatsuya can just blast the Yotsuba mansion sky high, and then he can live happily ever after with his Imouto,

The anime, yes. Mahouka is my favorite novel series though. Tatsuya is my favorite character and Lelouch is one them as well, both of them are great characters imo and that's all I have to say about that.

Yes the Code Geass anime is better than mahouka anime+light Novel,

Well your an anomaly, because your blaming the studio as well for a bad adaptation, when you haven't even read the source material yours self.

what ? no..... i was the anime only viewers who blame madhouse for a poor adaptation, i have nothing to say against the original source because i have yet to read it and i don't have any plan on doing that, in short am in the same side with LN readers.