There are some Threads about this, but there Madara is Tobi.
Madara: Can use the same Mangekyou abilites as Itachi, also the six paths of Nagato and the wood release. He can't use Gedo Mazo. He is alive, no Edo Tensei.
Itachi and Nagato: Both of them are healthy and alive. Nagato can't use Gedo Mazo. Gedo Mazo is inaccessible to both, Nagato and Madara.
Madara combines (E)MS, Rinnegan and the wood release, Nagato and Itachi are teamed up.
So who win in your opinion?
Madara: Can use the same Mangekyou abilites as Itachi, also the six paths of Nagato and the wood release. He can't use Gedo Mazo. He is alive, no Edo Tensei.
Itachi and Nagato: Both of them are healthy and alive. Nagato can't use Gedo Mazo. Gedo Mazo is inaccessible to both, Nagato and Madara.
Madara combines (E)MS, Rinnegan and the wood release, Nagato and Itachi are teamed up.
So who win in your opinion?
Last edited: