I was curious how the base would rate them going by Kishis own data book category.
Rate scale 1-10
Give 10 when its absolutely flawless. Also try to explain why you gave a certain rating if possible.
Madara
nin= 10 - Pair of Rinnegans and 3rd Tamoe Rinnegan
tai= 9 - Was able to compete against 8th gate until Kakashi and Minato, Lee and Gaara ganked.
gen= 10 - EMS, IT
intelligence= 10 - One of the few villains who accomplished his goal and came this far.
power= 10 - Juubi jin, Yin yang release
speed= 9 - Juubi jin
stamina/chakra= 9 - Juubi jin/ Indra chakra, Sage and what not. lol He has everything
Mental strength= 10 - Never once did he regret his actions during fight or had a breakdown.
Total= 77
Kaguya
nin= 9 - I expected more from her, Madara left a bigger impression since he was revived vs Alliance.
tai= 8 - She was able to hold herself against Naruto and Sasuke, well barely but still a great achievement.
gen= 9 - Besides IT we have not seen her use anything else.
intellegence= 4 - She actualy deserves lower than 4, but going by logic she shouldnt be really that dumb. I think she just lacks battle experience.
power= 10 - Juubi jin
speed= 8 - With 2 pair of eyes and Rinnegan she should have been able to react to Naruto, but got stomped instead.
Not really impressed, but giving her 8 seems reasonable.Maybe she deserves lower since Madara dint even lift a finger vs Nasuke with 2 Rinnegans.
stamina/chakra= 10 - Manga fact
Mental strength= 6 Would have given her 10, if she didnt started to cry. She is persistent about getting all the chakra, but still that breakdown was odd.
overall= 64
Madara=77
Kaguya= 64
Rate scale 1-10
Give 10 when its absolutely flawless. Also try to explain why you gave a certain rating if possible.
Madara
nin= 10 - Pair of Rinnegans and 3rd Tamoe Rinnegan
tai= 9 - Was able to compete against 8th gate until Kakashi and Minato, Lee and Gaara ganked.
gen= 10 - EMS, IT
intelligence= 10 - One of the few villains who accomplished his goal and came this far.
power= 10 - Juubi jin, Yin yang release
speed= 9 - Juubi jin
stamina/chakra= 9 - Juubi jin/ Indra chakra, Sage and what not. lol He has everything
Mental strength= 10 - Never once did he regret his actions during fight or had a breakdown.
Total= 77
Kaguya
nin= 9 - I expected more from her, Madara left a bigger impression since he was revived vs Alliance.
tai= 8 - She was able to hold herself against Naruto and Sasuke, well barely but still a great achievement.
gen= 9 - Besides IT we have not seen her use anything else.
intellegence= 4 - She actualy deserves lower than 4, but going by logic she shouldnt be really that dumb. I think she just lacks battle experience.
power= 10 - Juubi jin
speed= 8 - With 2 pair of eyes and Rinnegan she should have been able to react to Naruto, but got stomped instead.
Not really impressed, but giving her 8 seems reasonable.Maybe she deserves lower since Madara dint even lift a finger vs Nasuke with 2 Rinnegans.
stamina/chakra= 10 - Manga fact
Mental strength= 6 Would have given her 10, if she didnt started to cry. She is persistent about getting all the chakra, but still that breakdown was odd.
overall= 64
Madara=77
Kaguya= 64
Last edited: