Madara having double Rinnegan is a plot hole

[Devauzamaki]

Okay so we know Madara was born Indras next incarnate and his eyes had indras chakra in them.

After fighting Hashirama madara has to use Izanagi in his right eye pretty much deading that eye.

Madara then ate hashirama flesh and wherever he found another right eye Sharingan his eyes awakened into Rinnegan.

His eye should not have ascended. That was a foreign eye that did not possess Indras power.

Madara having double Rinnegan is a plot hole

 

[HowDidIGetPrem]

Indra's chakra exists all throughout Madara's body so any eye would've been enough. Tobirama explicitly explains how the eye is transformed by chakra from the brain & Madara would have had Indra's special chakra to transform the eye as long as he was hosting Indra.

 

[Pappasaur]

It doesn’t have to be his eyes, just his chakra. Neither eye was Madaras original they were both his brother Izunas, this would argue that Madara shouldn’t have the rinnegan at all

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

That’s because madara’s Ms eyes became a rinnegan and not his Ems.

 

[ThelUchiha]

I was thinking the same.... Madara was left with only one eye

 

[Animegoin]

Okay so we know Madara was born Indras next incarnate and his eyes had indras chakra in them.

After fighting Hashirama madara has to use Izanagi in his right eye pretty much deading that eye.

Madara then ate hashirama flesh and wherever he found another right eye Sharingan his eyes awakened into Rinnegan.

His eye should not have ascended. That was a foreign eye that did not possess Indras power.

Madara having double Rinnegan is a plot hole

@bold: Lmfao wait, are you suggesting that you believe Madara had swapped his original right eye with that spare sharingan before he manifested the Rinnegan? If so, that’s retarded. Madara kept both of his eyes up until he awoke the Rinnegan, and afterwards he gave them to Nagato.

 

[chaos control]

Okay so we know Madara was born Indras next incarnate and his eyes had indras chakra in them.

After fighting Hashirama madara has to use Izanagi in his right eye pretty much deading that eye.

Madara then ate hashirama flesh and wherever he found another right eye Sharingan his eyes awakened into Rinnegan.

His eye should not have ascended. That was a foreign eye that did not possess Indras power.

Madara having double Rinnegan is a plot hole

No it is not a plot hole. You got part of the story wrong.

After Madara used izanagi and implanted Hashirama's DNA into himself, he kept both of his eyes for many years despite one being blind. Then, as he was about to die, he awakened the rinnegan, which restored the sight in his blind eye. Then, some time after this, he gave his rinnegan eyes to Nagato, and then got one sharingan eye from somewhere. Some time later, he met Obito and the rest is history. That is why Madara only had one eye (one sharingan eye) when he met Obito.

Don't be so quick to call plot hole.

 

[Calpal]

doesnt really matter, the chakra for the persons dojutsu is awakened in the brain and not the actual eye itself.
its like replacing anyother organ, even though it isnt yours, it adapts to your body and still maintains the functions ir once had already.

its not reliant on madaras genes.
but rather his chakra, so theoretically any implanted sharingan could

 

[Ansatsuken]

One eye of Madara stayed in blindness state until he awoken the Rinnegan. So 80+ years before he awakened the Rinnegan Madara continue to lived witn one blind eye.

 

[Styles]

Madara used Izanagi with one eye and later in awakened Rinnegan in both eyes. How is that a plot hole? He never used a different sharingan.

 

[Guntah]

Presumably that means that the Rinnegan awakening on him somehow unblinded his Izanagi'd eye...which not THAT farfetched, really. That said, I wouldn't call it a plot hole since a clear picture is still present if you connect the dots.

 

[Mellanoma]

The eye is simply unlocked and mutated as shown when MS goes blind.

The REAL plot hole is how did Madara PRE-configure izanagi to activate after his death when he didn't have Senju DNA.

You must be registered for see images

 

[Rikudou Tobi]

The eye is simply unlocked and mutated as shown when MS goes blind.

The REAL plot hole is how did Madara PRE-configure izanagi to activate after his death when he didn't have Senju DNA.

You must be registered for see images

It was an

You must be registered for see links

to use it just like what Itachi did to Sasuke.
The real power of Izanagi doesn't require a mangekyo sharingan to use it, and it has many variants of it according to the 4th Databook.

 

[Styles]

The eye is simply unlocked and mutated as shown when MS goes blind.

The REAL plot hole is how did Madara PRE-configure izanagi to activate after his death when he didn't have Senju DNA.

You must be registered for see images

Thats not a plot hole either. To perfect Izanagi you need Senju DNA for no Uchiha. They Uchiha have been using Izanagi long before Madara’s time. He also used a time delay Izanagi to activate once he “died” to fake his death literally no plot hole anywhere.

 

[Mellanoma]

It was an

You must be registered for see links

to use it just like what Itachi did to Sasuke.
The real power of Izanagi doesn't require a mangekyo sharingan to use it, and it has many variants of it according to the 4th Databook.

Thats not a plot hole either. To perfect Izanagi you need Senju DNA for no Uchiha. They Uchiha have been using Izanagi long before Madara’s time. He also used a time delay Izanagi to activate once he “died” to fake his death literally no plot hole anywhere.

I just provided both of you the direct manga definition yet you argue against it?

 

[Styles]

I just provided both of you the direct manga definition yet you argue against it?

Except you didn’t and the manga even said Uchiha have been using Izanagi long before any Uchiha had Senju DNA. You’re going against the manga heavy.

 

[Mellanoma]

Except you didn’t and the manga even said Uchiha have been using Izanagi long before any Uchiha had Senju DNA. You’re going against the manga heavy.

When does the manga illustrate the uchiha performed it without Senju DNA?