Madara couldnt have been revived by nagato.

[Blaze Release]

First of all this thread isnt revealing who tobi is. Or the link between tobi and madara. This is about the limits, more specifically the time duration is which nagato cannot revive the dead, with Gedō: Rinne Tensei no Jutsu.

Now tobi said something about nagato using this technique for him

You must be registered for see links

, but obviously we know that it was used after the naruto fight. But also from his tone it sounds like that technique cannot be used again for a while.

Anyway When madara was revived he asked whether the tech used was Gedō: Rinne Tensei no Jutsu to which muu told him that it was edo tensei.

You must be registered for see links

. By his tone its obvious that at the time he died nagato was a child, but also it sounds as if he gave the rennigan he activated shortly before his death to nagato in order to revive him with this tech. This ties in with what tobi said about giving nagato the rennigan and madara the real one actually activating it. Again this thread isnt about the identity of tobi.

Anyway from what we know so far is that madara died before nagato was a teenager. Yahiko and nagato were around the same age when yahiko died

You must be registered for see links

. Nagato obviously liked yahiko as a brother and if he had/knew of that technique during that time he wouldve no doubtve revived him like he did to the konoha ninjas. This leads me to believe that after he learnt the technique later on but also the time interval is too big for him to bring back the dead, yahiko or madara.

You must be registered for see links

This leads me to believe that madara couldnt been revived even if nagato was still on akatsuki's side and was still alive due to the time duration.

I might be missing something though, so fill free to prove me wrong

 

[SADAO UCHIHA]

good theory

 

[Hipster Madara]

nice, idk what he meant now...

 

[BondedByBlood]

it makes me think....the same thing kinda happened with Jiraiya...am i right?

 

[Blaze Release]

it makes me think....the same thing kinda happened with Jiraiya...am i right?

I do also think that the time duration for jiraiya had already passed. Thats why he wasnt revived.

I think the time duration is like a day. once a day has passed i dont think he could revive the dead

 

[ostap98]

u are on to somthing

 

[EggesGabo]

Good theory.

 

[Blaze Release]

Can the person who clicked on totally wrong atleast explain why

 

[Out Of Ctrl]

Nice point but you have to remember that Nagato was given the rinnegan so it may be the case of Nagato not being able to fully master it. Even Nagato himself stated that his powers are nothing compared to that of Six Paths when he used his version of Chibaku Tensei.

You must be registered for see links

Also from the latest chapter, most of the people are saying that Madara's rinnegan are much better than Nagatos because he earned it.

And it also maybe the case of Tobi knowing more about the rinnegan's secrets so Tobi and Madara knew a way to use Nagato to revive Madara even long after the time duration. Thats what i think anyway

 

[Blaze Release]

Nice point but you have to remember that Nagato was given the rinnegan so it may be the case of Nagato not being able to fully master it. Even Nagato himself stated that his powers are nothing compared to that of Six Paths when he used his version of Chibaku Tensei.

You must be registered for see links

Also from the latest chapter, most of the people are saying that Madara's rinnegan are much better than Nagatos because he earned it.

And it also maybe the case of Tobi knowing more about the rinnegan's secrets so Tobi and Madara knew a way to use Nagato to revive Madara even long after the time duration. Thats what i think anyway

From what ive gandered i believe that nagato's rennigan is madara's. As i said i believe he gave it to him shortly before he died. Therefore madara's isnt stronger, its the same thing although what makes it look stronger is the user. Also believe that only 3 people ever activated the rennigan, the sage, the older brother and madara.

Anyway if tobi couldve increased the time duration in which nagato couldve revived madara, i still dont think it would be effective enough because he mostly likely died when nagato was a kid. The time duration is still too great

 

[Out Of Ctrl]

True true its all just confusing cause were not sure of anything yet lol but I would have guessed that Tobi had a plan somehow, for him to say that he had something for Nagato.

And were not entirely sure whether the older brother had true rinnegan eyes. Some sort of mutation apparently

You must be registered for see links

 

[Blaze Release]

I do agree that the older brothers eyes do look similar to the rennigan but maybe be different. Anyway this isnt the first mistake kishi has done with the rennigan. Cant remember but apparently it was red, but then later changed to purple. Anyway lets get back to subject.

There is something going on between those three. madara, tobi and nagato

 

[Out Of Ctrl]

yup, time will tell, cant effing wait tho!

 

[Hammy120290]

red - purple was the anime.

I believe Tobi is Madara (Yin half of soul) and Madara is the Yang. Hence why he can be summoned Yin allows Madara to use Genjutsu and Izanagi etc but he lacks physical attributes in battle i.e. Yang. Speed etc he relies on ST jutsu.

So that is how Nagato would revive Madara by somehow reviving Tobi using a path to extract the Yang soul and make Madara whole again...just a theory

 

[shez]

Yeah, had notcied this for a while and wondering why Madara thought he could. Nagato was very crippled and weak after synching with the gedo statue and we saw that this made all his techniques weaker. When he was healthy maybe the cut off time for reviving was longer. I mean Madara isn't dumb and he had the rinnegan for a short time so maybe he knows something that meant he wouldn have expected nagato to be able to revive him after a long period. He wouldn't have thought that Nagato could master the rinnegan in a day.

 

[TrollingSage]

Maybe he could revive someone who's been dead for a long time by sacrificing his life.